Can energy only be transferred if there is motion.

In summary, when punching an object and it does not move, you are not giving it energy as the Earth or surrounding forces are pushing against it in the opposite direction. If you consider deformations, there may be a small amount of energy transferred, but this is not related to the object's overall motion. However, in situations where objects are being hammered or shaped, a significant amount of energy is being transferred and this may result in heat and deformation, but does not affect the object's overall kinetic energy. Therefore, according to the equation e=mc2, repeatedly punching an object and not causing it to move would not result in a gain of mass.
  • #1
Berney123
8
0
For example if I punch an object and it doesn't move, am I giving it energy, if so after doing that billions of times wouldn't it gain mass because e=mc2.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
For example if I punch an object and it doesn't move, am I giving it energy
You are not. The Earth (or whatever prevents the object from moving) pushes against the object in the opposite direction, and the energy gained by the object is 0. If you take deformations into account, you could heat it a tiny bit, but that is not related to the motion of the whole object.
 
  • #3
Berney123 said:
For example if I punch an object and it doesn't move, am I giving it energy, if so after doing that billions of times wouldn't it gain mass because e=mc2.
Depends I guess. If you are hammering iron to make a sword you transfer quite a lot of energy into unmovable object.
 
  • #4
Kinetic energy is directly tied to motion, so in that sense, no. However, there are many other types of energy, such as the deformation that has already been alluded to. When you punch a box or you hit a sword with a hammer, however, the give the slightest amount, and in that moment apply a great deal of force, absorbing energy in the form of heat and deformation. The kinetic energy of the object as a whole doesn't change though.
 
  • #5


Energy can be transferred in various ways, not just through motion. In the example given, when you punch an object and it doesn't move, you are still giving it energy in the form of thermal energy. This is because the molecules of the object are vibrating and moving faster due to the impact of your punch. However, this increase in thermal energy does not necessarily result in an increase in mass according to the equation E=mc^2. This equation relates to the conversion of mass into energy and vice versa, not the transfer of energy. In order for an object to gain mass, there would need to be a significant amount of energy involved, such as in nuclear reactions. In everyday situations, the transfer of energy through motion or other means does not significantly impact an object's mass.
 

1. Can energy be transferred without motion?

No, energy can only be transferred from one object to another if there is motion involved. This is because energy is defined as the ability to do work, and work is only done when a force acts on an object and causes it to move.

2. What types of motion can transfer energy?

Any type of motion can transfer energy, including linear motion, rotational motion, and vibrational motion. For example, when a car accelerates, its engine transfers energy to the wheels through linear motion, while a wind turbine converts rotational motion into electrical energy.

3. Is there a limit to how much energy can be transferred through motion?

Yes, there is a limit to how much energy can be transferred through motion. This limit is called the maximum kinetic energy, which is dependent on the mass and speed of the object. Once the maximum kinetic energy is reached, any additional energy will be dissipated as heat or sound.

4. Can energy be transferred through motion in a vacuum?

Yes, energy can be transferred through motion in a vacuum. In fact, motion in a vacuum allows for the most efficient transfer of energy, as there is no air resistance or friction to slow down the object. This is why objects in space can travel at high speeds without losing much energy.

5. Are there other ways to transfer energy besides motion?

Yes, there are other ways to transfer energy besides motion. Energy can also be transferred through heat, light, sound, and electric or magnetic fields. In fact, energy is constantly being transferred and transformed from one form to another in various natural processes and human-made systems.

Similar threads

Replies
34
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
846
Replies
27
Views
11K
Replies
2
Views
61
Replies
24
Views
1K
Replies
18
Views
970
Replies
4
Views
918
  • Mechanics
Replies
2
Views
996
Back
Top