Gauss Proof (urgend)


by Mathman23
Tags: gauss, proof, urgend
Mathman23
Mathman23 is offline
#1
Nov23-05, 01:42 PM
P: 255
Hello

I have been tasked with proving the following:

[tex]cos(\frac{2 \pi}{5}) = \frac{\sqrt{5} + 1}{4}[/tex]

Any hints/idears on how I go about doing that?

Sincerely Yours

Fred
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Going nuts? Turkey looks to pistachios to heat new eco-city
Space-tested fluid flow concept advances infectious disease diagnoses
SpaceX launches supplies to space station (Update)
mathphys
mathphys is offline
#2
Nov23-05, 02:27 PM
P: 84
Start with the unit circle. Then construct a right triangle inside it with one of its angles equal to 2pi/5. From there, use trigonometry and geometry to figure out how to arrive to the answer.
Mathman23
Mathman23 is offline
#3
Nov23-05, 02:36 PM
P: 255
Quote Quote by mathphys
Start with the unit circle. Then construct a right triangle inside it with one of its angles equal to 2pi/5. From there, use trigonometry and geometry to figure out how to arrive to the answer.
I used Eulers formula [tex]cos(v) = \frac{e^{iv} + e^{-iv}}{2}[/tex]

if v = [tex]\frac{2 \pi}{5}[/tex]

cos(v) = [tex]\frac{\sqrt{5}-1}{4}[/tex]

Is that a wrong approach?

/Fred

mathphys
mathphys is offline
#4
Nov23-05, 03:31 PM
P: 84

Gauss Proof (urgend)


?? How dou you arrive to that result from euler's formula?

From it we just have

cos(2pi/5)= (e^(i2pi/5) + e^(-i2pi/5))/2 = cos(2pi/5),

because e^(iv)=cos(v)+i sen(v).

??
Mathman23
Mathman23 is offline
#5
Nov23-05, 04:01 PM
P: 255
Quote Quote by mathphys
?? How dou you arrive to that result from euler's formula?
From it we just have
cos(2pi/5)= (e^(i2pi/5) + e^(-i2pi/5))/2 = cos(2pi/5),
because e^(iv)=cos(v)+i sen(v).
??
Using this formula proofs the result doesn't?

Cause if I insert the numbers into the formula I get the cos(2pi/5).

/Fred
Jameson
Jameson is offline
#6
Nov23-05, 04:24 PM
P: 789
Can you show your work? I'm not following your steps. Your definition of cosine is correct though.
mathphys
mathphys is offline
#7
Nov23-05, 04:33 PM
P: 84
If you plug v=2pi/5 in the following

cos(v)=(e^(iv)+e^(-iv))/2 and use then the euler formula

you get

cos(2pi/5)=cos(2pi/5), not a specific numerical value...

How do you arrived to it then? post the steps you have followed.
Mathman23
Mathman23 is offline
#8
Nov23-05, 04:35 PM
P: 255
Quote Quote by Jameson
Can you show your work? I'm not following your steps. Your definition of cosine is correct though.
Sure,

I'm sure show the following cos(2 pi / 5) = (sqrt(5) -1)/4

Then I take Eulers formula

[tex]cos(v) = \frac{e^{iv} + e^{-iv}}{2}[/tex]

and I insert v = (2 pi)/5 into euler which gives (sqrt(5) -1)/4.

Thereby cos(2 pi / 5) = (sqrt(5) -1)/4

Is that approach correct?

/Fred
Mathman23
Mathman23 is offline
#9
Nov23-05, 04:42 PM
P: 255
Quote Quote by mathphys
If you plug v=2pi/5 in the following
cos(v)=(e^(iv)+e^(-iv))/2 and use then the euler formula
you get
cos(2pi/5)=cos(2pi/5), not a specific numerical value...
How do you arrived to it then? post the steps you have followed.
Sure I get = ((sqrt(5) - 1)/2)/2 = (sqrt(5) - 1)/4

/Fred
mathphys
mathphys is offline
#10
Nov23-05, 04:54 PM
P: 84
If you start with what you are trying to prove as known, then you're not proving nothing.

substituting 2pi/5 in the identity your using for cos(v) gives

cos(2pi/5)= (e^(i2pi/5)+ e^(-i2pi/5))/2=cos(2pi/5). Which does not give the numerical value you are requested to obtain.

You need to evaluate cos(2pi/5) and prove that the result is
(sqrt(5)-1)/4.

Now, the most elementary way(in which i can think right now) that do this is using the unitary circle and geometry/trigonometry as i mention in my first post.Of course it depends, From what course this problem came? It is likely that you have to use the methods you have learnt from this class. What do yo mean with Gauss proof?
Mathman23
Mathman23 is offline
#11
Nov23-05, 05:23 PM
P: 255
Okay I draw a unit cirle and plot in the value cos(2pi/5) ??? Or what do I do ?

/Fred

Quote Quote by mathphys
If you start with what you are trying to prove as known, then you're not proving nothing.
substituting 2pi/5 in the identity your using for cos(v) gives
cos(2pi/5)= (e^(i2pi/5)+ e^(-i2pi/5))/2=cos(2pi/5). Which does not give the numerical value you are requested to obtain.
You need to evaluate cos(2pi/5) and prove that the result is
(sqrt(5)-1)/4.
Now, the most elementary way(in which i can think right now) that do this is using the unitary circle and geometry/trigonometry as i mention in my first post.Of course it depends, From what course this problem came? It is likely that you have to use the methods you have learnt from this class. What do yo mean with Gauss proof?
mathphys
mathphys is offline
#12
Nov23-05, 05:52 PM
P: 84
You have to draw the corresponding right triangle inside the circle and then use the pythagoras theorem and other trigonometry concepts to solve the problem.

If you want a 'faster', 'algebraic' solution you may prefer to use the results/methods presented here

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/TrigonometryAnglesPi5.html
and here

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Multipl...eFormulas.html

You just need to figure out which of them are the ones you need to construct your proof. They do it for sin(pi/5), you need to do it for cos(2pi/5).
Martin Rattigan
Martin Rattigan is offline
#13
Dec4-05, 07:42 PM
P: 311
Sounds suspiciously like homework, but try using the identity:
[tex](\cos(x)+i\sin(x))^n=\cos(nx)+i\sin(nx)[/tex]
(which you can easily prove by induction).
You can then equate the real parts and substitute [tex]1-\cos^2x[/tex] for [tex]\sin^2x[/tex] to get a quintic polinoleum in [tex]\cos(\frac{2\pi}{5})[/tex] which should be easier for you to factorize than it was for Gauss because you already know the answer. You can then throw away all but one solution because they obviously don't fit.

By the way if this is illegible it's because it's the first time I've used tex and I can't get it to display in the preview.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Urgend Calculus Question: Please Look Calculus & Beyond Homework 0
Urgend: Sum of digits question Calculus & Beyond Homework 6
Urgend calculus question Calculus & Beyond Homework 10
Proof of Gauss-Markov Theorem Introductory Physics Homework 0
Proof of Coulomb's Law using Gauss' Law Introductory Physics Homework 1