
#1
Mar2106, 10:25 AM

P: 34

(One version of) Poincare's Recurrence Theorem states that for any conservative system whose possible states S form a compact set in phase space, that system will "almost always" return arbitrarily close to its initial state, provided we wait long enough. ('Almost always' means 'all but a set of Lebesgue measure zero'.)
Carlo Cercignani, in a discussion of the Boltzmann equation, has this to say: the set of possible states for a conservative system is not compact in phase space for the limit where the number of particles in the system goes to infinity (N > infty). (See The Mathematical Theory of Dilute Gases, SpringerVerlag: 1994, page 56 first paragraph.) Why? He also says that, in the N > infty limit, the recurrence time for the system is expected to go to infinity (albeit at a much faster rate than N). Why? Can someone please explain? Does the noncompactness of S in the N > infty limit have to do with S becoming unbounded? or not closed? Which one? And is there some intuitive reasoning to explain this? Or maybe a rigorous explanation too? I've been through lots of Cercignani's work; I can't find an explanation. The answer is not this: the recurrence time is really really long, and that is why the Boltzmann equation is consistent with the recurrence theorem. Cercignani thinks that his claim *exempts* the Boltzmann equation from the strictures of the recurrence theorem, since he proves the validity of the Boltzmann equation for the N > infty limit. Thanks in advance! 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Help With Infinite Exponential Limit  Calculus & Beyond Homework  6  
Proof of Poincare Recurrence Theorem  Classical Physics  3  
Infinite Limit  Calculus & Beyond Homework  2  
Question on Poincare Recurrence Theorem  Classical Physics  1  
Limit of an infinite sum.  Calculus  1 