View Poll Results: My situation is described by: a 3 42.86% b 3 42.86% c 0 0% d 1 14.29% e 0 0% f 0 0% Voters: 7. You may not vote on this poll

## Level of enforced secrecy in nuclear physics

This poll is purely to satisfy my curiousity

"enforced secrecy" in this context means a legal obligation not to share information, such as having to sign an agreement.

a) I never studied nuclear phyics
b) I studied nuclear physics during a degree without encountering any enforced secrecy
c) I studied nuclear phyics during a degree and encountered enforced secrecy
d) I do research into nuclear physics without encountering enforced secrecy
e) I do research into nulcear physics and encounter enforced secrecy
f) I can't answer this question for legal reasons
 PhysOrg.com science news on PhysOrg.com >> Leading 3-D printer firms to merge in $403M deal (Update)>> LA to give every student an iPad;$30M order>> CIA faulted for choosing Amazon over IBM on cloud contract

Recognitions:
 Quote by jackle This poll is purely to satisfy my curiousity "enforced secrecy" in this context means a legal obligation not to share information, such as having to sign an agreement. Which best describes your situation a) I never studied nuclear phyics b) I studied nuclear physics during a degree without encountering any enforced secrecy c) I studied nuclear phyics during a degree and encountered enforced secrecy d) I do research into nuclear physics without encountering enforced secrecy e) I do research into nulcear physics and encounter enforced secrecy f) I can't answer this question for legal reasons
jackie,

Your choices above span a couple "universes" of possibilities.

First, (f) is out - there is NOT a legal prohibition which would prohibit anyone from even

Answers (b) and (c) form the two possible responses for the case of someone studying
nuclear physics. If you are studying nuclear physics; in a University, for example;
then you will not encounter "enforced secrecy". You will be studying the basic physics;
and the laws of physics are NOT classified in any way shape or form.

If you are doing research; you may or may not have to contend with enforced secrecy
depending on where you are doing this research. If you are doing research in the
nuclear weapons design progams at either Los Alamos or Lawrence Livermore; then
YES - there is enforced secrecy - what else would you expect?

You would also encounter enforced secrecy if you were working on the design of naval
nuclear reactors at either Knolls Atomic Power Lab or Bettis Atomic Power Lab. If you
know the design of the reactor; you know how much power it can put out; and hence that
helps you figure out how fast the reactor and turbine can propel the sub through the water.
How fast a nuclear sub can travel is something the Navy wants to keep secret.

The prohibition against revealing secret nuclear information is codified in a LAW - the
Atomic Energy Act of 1954. You don't have to sign a document to be bound by this;
EVERYBODY in the USA is bound by this law. Even if you decided to work independently
on your own nuclear weapon design - this law has a concept called "born secret" -
anything you come up with is classified at inception.

However, if you are working for a reactor manufacturer or any business regarding the
commercial use of nuclear power; you won't encounter prohibitions; except for the
ordinary "trade secrets" that you might encouter at ANY business. If you work at
Apple; you can't take the source code that runs the new iPhone with you if your leave
and go to one of Apple's competitors.

Dr. Gregory Greenman
Physicist
 Thanks Morbius. This is probably everything I wanted to know.

 Similar discussions for: Level of enforced secrecy in nuclear physics Thread Forum Replies Current Events 22 Current Events 2 Academic Guidance 1 General Discussion 0 General Physics 11