Register to reply

Geometry Problem

by cepheid
Tags: geometry
Share this thread:
cepheid
#1
Aug2-07, 06:18 PM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
cepheid's Avatar
P: 5,196
Hi,

This is not really a problem for the template (it is not even homework). I have come across the elementary geometry problem shown in the figure below.



I am wondering whether there is some way to solve for a and b uniquely. Although I was able to come up with an expression for every single angle in the diagram in terms of a or b, the only constraint I have found so far is the obvious one: a + b = 90 degrees. That alone leads to infinitely many solutions. Wondering whether there was another constraint I had missed, I tried an arbitrary solution a = 40, b = 50, and it works. It seems more likely that any thing in the solution set to a + b = 90 is fine, rather than me having stumbled upon the only unique solution there is.

The problem as stated does not ask for the values of a and b, it asks only whether:

a > b
a < b
a = b
OR
there is not enough info to make a determination


(yes this is one of those stupid GRE "quantitative comparision" questions)

The solution proposed by the GRE people is to exaggerate the difference between the 91 degrees and the 89 degrees by drawing the former angle larger, requiring that the nearly-square rectangle be redrawn as a rectangle much wider than it is tall. Once this has been done, it becomes "clear" that a > b.

I am wondering whether there is a less crude way of arriving at this conclusion (one that makes use of geometric principles)

Thanks
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
New type of solar concentrator desn't block the view
Researchers demonstrate ultra low-field nuclear magnetic resonance using Earth's magnetic field
Asian inventions dominate energy storage systems
Dick
#2
Aug2-07, 11:16 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 25,228
Am I confused? If the figure is supposed to be a rectangle, then all of the triangles are isosceles. So 2a+89=180 and 2b+91=180. a>b. Am I missing something that is making this hard?
Gib Z
#3
Aug3-07, 04:09 AM
HW Helper
Gib Z's Avatar
P: 3,348
We don't know that the angles at the corners are right angles.

Dick
#4
Aug3-07, 08:35 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 25,228
Geometry Problem

If its an arbitrary quadrilateral then a>b is not necessarily true. Start drawing non-rectangular cases.
cepheid
#5
Aug20-07, 06:22 PM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
cepheid's Avatar
P: 5,196
Quote Quote by Dick View Post
Am I confused? If the figure is supposed to be a rectangle, then all of the triangles are isosceles. So 2a+89=180 and 2b+91=180. a>b. Am I missing something that is making this hard?
No, I don't think you are missing anything. It was supposed to be a rectangle, so that's the answer. Thanks.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Geometry problem General Math 14
Geometry problem General Math 1
A problem in geometry Introductory Physics Homework 7
Geometry problem General Math 5
Geometry Problem General Math 3