image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Other Sciences > Chemistry


Reply

image Electrolysis of water Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Sep1-07, 11:01 AM                  #1
chanller

chanller is Offline:
Posts: 25
Exclamation Electrolysis of water

While doing electrolysis of water, I have put a rheostat and a battery in series with the apparatus. I found that when I increase the resistance of the rheostat, the number of bubbles produced per second decreases. How can you explain that?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 11:17 AM                  #2
Gokul43201
 
Gokul43201's Avatar

Gokul43201 is Offline:
Posts: 10,319
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Retired Staff Retired Staff
Before we can respond, we need to see what you think. Do you have any idea what other electrical quantities are affected by changing the resistance in a constant-voltage circuit? And the bubbles - what physical quantity do they relate to?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 11:32 AM       Last edited by chanller; Sep1-07 at 11:39 AM.. Reason: Too impulsive!            #3
chanller

chanller is Offline:
Posts: 25
Electrolysis of water

If the power withdrawn from a battery depends on the resistance of the circuit, then i guess current changes if P=IV. But, how can you keep the voltage from a battery constant while varying power withdrawn?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 11:35 AM                  #4
Gokul43201
 
Gokul43201's Avatar

Gokul43201 is Offline:
Posts: 10,319
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Retired Staff Retired Staff
Yes, that's correct, though it actually follows more directly from Ohm's Law, V=IR. So, does the current increase or decrease?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 11:49 AM       Last edited by chanller; Sep1-07 at 11:56 AM..            #5
chanller

chanller is Offline:
Posts: 25
I believe current for the electrolysis decreases if the voltage is constant and if current = electrons and electrons= gas bubbles, current decreases. Is it that when i increase resistance of the rheostat, power through it increases and that through the electrolysis decreases? This would explain why gas flow decreases but then it would mean power from the battery is constant! But, how can you keep the voltage from a battery constant while varying power withdrawn?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 01:35 PM                  #6
Gokul43201
 
Gokul43201's Avatar

Gokul43201 is Offline:
Posts: 10,319
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Retired Staff Retired Staff
There is no need to worry about power here. A bettery is, by definition, a device wich produces a constant voltage over a large range of currents. The power dropped (both at the rheostat and at the cell) decreases as you increase the resistance (because the current decreases, while the voltage is constant) but that's not the relevant quantity here. The relevant quantity is the current, which decreases.

As you mentioned, the current is simply the rate at which electrons are transfered between the electrodes. Each pair of electrons arriving at the cathode makes a molecule of hydrogen gas form there. The slower the rate of electrons, the slower will be the rate of hydrogen bubble formation.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 01:55 PM                  #7
chanller

chanller is Offline:
Posts: 25
Well, what I did not know is that voltage from a battery is constant; now everything is clear! But can the voltage be changed and if yes, how?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 02:48 PM                  #8
Astronuc

PF Mentor
 
Astronuc's Avatar

Astronuc is Online:
Posts: 14,052
The battery represents the maximum allowable voltage, and then there is a voltage drop proportional to resisance and current.

Two resistance in series represent a voltage divider.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 05:03 PM                  #9
chanller

chanller is Offline:
Posts: 25
I finally had to leaf through my physics book. Well I learned that physics was not just theory which I have to learn by heart!! Thanks everyone!
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep1-07, 06:34 PM                  #10
chanller

chanller is Offline:
Posts: 25
Talking about electrolysis, what happens to the excess power input when gas production rate remains constant even though power is increased? Droplets of water settled at the top of my gas storage cylinder, does this mean excess power is converted into heat which vaporises water in the electrolyte?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep2-07, 06:26 PM                  #11
Astronuc

PF Mentor
 
Astronuc's Avatar

Astronuc is Online:
Posts: 14,052
Originally Posted by chanller View Post
Talking about electrolysis, what happens to the excess power input when gas production rate remains constant even though power is increased? Droplets of water settled at the top of my gas storage cylinder, does this mean excess power is converted into heat which vaporises water in the electrolyte?
There is heat involved from resistance, and the heat will cause some liquid to evaporate which would condense on a cooler surface.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep3-07, 07:55 AM                  #12
chanller

chanller is Offline:
Posts: 25
If i use 1 molar sulphuric acid at rtp what voltage do you think i should use? 1.5V will be good?

Also, how can i keep the concentration of the acid constant?
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Electrolysis of water
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Electrolysis of water 3 hemu_electro Chemistry 1 Jun22-08 02:38 PM
Electrolysis of water 2 chanller Chemistry 13 Sep6-07 10:37 PM
building a Electrolysis for water Gadget_Wizard Other Sciences 2 May10-07 10:54 AM
Electrolysis of water - Hydrogen PPonte Other Sciences 1 Feb26-06 05:27 PM
Electrolysis Of Water Help Please.... derekmohammed Chemistry 11 Sep18-05 05:24 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image