Register to reply 
Finding the magnitude difference between two star 
Share this thread: 
#1
Oct707, 10:34 PM

P: 569

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
Determine the apparent magnitude difference between sirius and the sun,as seen from the Earth. How much more luminosity is sirius than the Sun ? 2. Relevant equations f=sigma*T^4(eff) mn=2.5*log(f(m)/f(n)) 3. The attempt at a solution the apparent magnitude difference is mn, m and n being the apparent magnitudes being the sun and sirius. I probably need the find the flux of each star. the flux=5.67e8 W/(m^2*K^4)*T^4(eff). 30000 K is the effective temperature of Sirius and T(eff)=5780 K for the sun. f(sirius)/f(sun)=(30000 K)^4/(5780)^4=726 . Therefore, m(sirius)n(sun)=2.5*log(726)=7.152 


#2
Oct707, 10:57 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 8,953

The boltzman law formula isn't enought to give the total luminosity of a star, you also need it's diameter  a halogen spotlight is a similair temperature to sirius but doesn't have quite the same power output.
What other information are you given about Sirius? YOu will also need to know the flux from the sun or it's absolute mangnitude. YOu can easily look these up so I'll tell you, m(sirius) = −1.47, m(sun) = −26.74 


#3
Oct807, 12:04 AM

P: 569

Why do I need to calculate the total Luminosity when I can easily calculate the flux of each star by look up the effective temperature of each star? The ratio of the two fluxes of the stars are given in the equation for apparent magnitude difference



#4
Oct807, 10:49 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 8,953

Finding the magnitude difference between two star
You can't work out the fluxes of the two stars just from their temperatures unless you also know that their diamters are the same.
To calculate the magnitude difference you either need to know the magnitude of each or the fluxes of each  these are observed parameters. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Finding vector magnitude  Calculus & Beyond Homework  1  
Apparent magnitude of binary star?  Introductory Physics Homework  4  
Finding the magnitude difference between two star  Introductory Physics Homework  0  
Find the magnitude of the difference between the weights (temperature question)  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Finding Magnitude  Introductory Physics Homework  18 