| Thread Closed |
clarification of photon "arrows" in feynmans QED book |
Share Thread |
| May31-08, 05:00 AM | #1 |
|
|
clarification of photon "arrows" in feynmans QED book
Hi! In Feynmans QED, strange theory of light and matter, he spends the
first 60 pages by pedagogically describing the in-flight turning arrows and the resulting interference phenomena which result after path summation. Then on p.60 I think it was, he mentions almost in passing that for the photon, there is no turning of the amplitude in flight, but instead the reason we get interference effects is that the source amplitude in the light-source (a monochromatic source in his example there) varies with time - so there really is no turning of the arrows for a photon but you have to consider many photon paths coming from the same source at different times instead to keep the effect. Leaving the "real" QED math aside, which obviously works fine, is this all there is to this issue ? What about for example red-shift due to space-time expansion in cosmology. If the photons arrows do not turn in flight, what is the "Feynman" arrow description of such an event ? How do different photons have different energies at absorption if there is no oscillation or turning at the fundamental level - am I missing something for example that the emitted photon needs to be in a temporal superposition of many amplitudes and times and the collective superposition leads to the conventional effects of individual photons' "wavelengths" ? Sorry if this sounds messy, but I'm interested in Feynmans simple discussions on QED as a complement to "just calculating". I also have a hunch that the resolution to this lies in the difference between virtual and real photons.. /Bjorn |
| Thread Closed |
Similar discussions for: clarification of photon "arrows" in feynmans QED book
|
||||
| Thread | Forum | Replies | ||
| Photon "Wave Collapse" Experiment (AJP Sep 2004, Thorn et al.) | General Physics | 5 | ||
| Photon "Wave Collapse" Experiment (Yeah sure; AJP Sep 2004, Thorn...) | Quantum Physics | 128 | ||
| Critique of the "photon" theory of electromagnetic radiation | General Physics | 21 | ||
| Clarification needed for "acoustic length" | Introductory Physics Homework | 0 | ||
| Clarification on "Inverse" of x^3 | General Math | 10 | ||