# Gibbs distribution and Bose statistics

by ala
Tags: bose, distribution, gibbs, statistics
 P: 23 For photon gas chemical potential is zero. It is because derivate of free energy with respect to number (T, V fixed) of particles is zero in equilibrium. (free energy has minimum). I was wondering why cannot I apply this reasoning to conclude (wrong) that chemical potential is zero for any Bose gas? Explanation: When deriving Bose statistics one applies Gibbs distribution for variable number of particles (grand canonical) to set of particles in the gas which are in a given quantum state. Then apply formula for grand potential (equal to -PV), mean number of particles in given quantum state is then obtained as derivate of grand potential with respect to chemical potential. So one gets Bose distribution. But if I say now that chemical potential is equal to derivate of free energy with respect to number of particles and latter is equal to zero (when gas is in equilibrium) I get wrong conclusion. Why?

 Related Discussions Quantum Physics 5 Quantum Physics 3 Advanced Physics Homework 4 Quantum Physics 14 Quantum Physics 0