You have 2 boxes and 20 balls riddle


by Gokul43201
Tags: balls, boxes, quickie, riddle
Gokul43201
Gokul43201 is offline
#1
May26-04, 10:44 AM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
Gokul43201's Avatar
P: 11,154
Give yourself a minute or two to solve this :

You have 2 boxes and 20 balls, 10 black and 10 white. How would you distribute the balls in the boxes (any number in each box so long as the total is 20) to maximize the odds of picking 2 whites on a random selection of 1 ball from each box ?

i.e: how many blacks and whites in each box ?
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Cougars' diverse diet helped them survive the Pleistocene mass extinction
Cyber risks can cause disruption on scale of 2008 crisis, study says
Mantis shrimp stronger than airplanes
jcsd
jcsd is offline
#2
May26-04, 10:53 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,226
Well to get the largets chance you want to maximize the numerator and minimize thedenominator of the fraction.

So I guess 5 white and 10 black in one box and 5 white in the other box.
jcsd
jcsd is offline
#3
May26-04, 10:57 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,226
Actually it'd be better to but 1 white in one box and the rest of the balls in the other I think.

Gokul43201
Gokul43201 is offline
#4
May26-04, 11:29 AM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
Gokul43201's Avatar
P: 11,154

You have 2 boxes and 20 balls riddle


I think so too...

There's a common trap that a lot of people fall into. Here's the argument I've heard most commonly (including out of my own head). All balls in Box 1 or all balls in Box 2 gives you a zero chance of success. The problem is symmetric w.r.t the boxes, and starting from one of the above extremum cases, and moving balls into the empty box can only improve your odds. So the best odds will the found at the midpoint, i.e : 5 black and 5 white balls in each box.

The "apparent" similarity with problems like maximising entropy in a 2-chamber system, or finding the rectangle of largest area for given perimeter leads to the taking of the bait quite happily


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Just a quickie! Introductory Physics Homework 2
A quickie General Discussion 12
Quickie! I think I got it, but I need some help! Introductory Physics Homework 1
Quickie Introductory Physics Homework 2
divine what i have hid...over this verse must you go. utter each Brain Teasers 6