Register to reply 
Roll or slide? 
Share this thread: 
#1
Jun2409, 12:12 AM

P: 34

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
Does a perfect ball roll or slide down a perfectly frictionless ramp? 2. Relevant equations 3. The attempt at a solution Let P be the contact point of the ball with the ramp. Then it appears to me there is a torque (about the contact point, P) acting on the ball due to its weight, W. Therefore it should rotate ie roll. Is this right? (The torque has magnitude W*R*tan(Theta) where R is the radius of the ball and Theta is the angle of the ramp. The Normal force does not exert a torque as it passes through P. ) 


#2
Jun2409, 12:16 AM

P: 4,512

Where is the normal force directed through the ball?



#3
Jun2409, 12:34 AM

P: 34

As noted in the original post, the normal force passes through the point of contact, P, and through the center of the ball.
Therefore, there is NO torque due to the normal force about P. 


#4
Jun2409, 01:07 AM

P: 4,512

Roll or slide?
It would require torque to change angular velocity. The question implies by omission, but does not state, that it is not rotating to begin with. 


#5
Jun2409, 01:35 AM

P: 34

I presume it is not moving to start with.
I was wondering if my original analysis was correct? 


#6
Jun2409, 04:47 AM

Mentor
P: 41,563

It's certainly true that the weight exerts a torque about the contact point, but you cannot conclude from that that the ball will start rolling. Hint: Consider torques about the ball's center of mass, where a nonzero torque would imply an angular acceleration. 


#7
Jun2509, 03:29 AM

P: 34

I have been researching this question elsewhere (see links below). And it seems the ball will SLIDE rather than roll! I don’t understand this! I thought a torque measured the tendency of a body to rotate.
Why doesn’t the torque about the point of contact (P) cause rolling? Why is friction is needed to cause rolling? I’m puzzled! LINKS: 1) I found a thread in Physics Forums > Physics > Classical Physics called “Can a ball roll down a frictionless plane?” Posted by physics_liker (http://www.physicsforums.com/showthr...light=friction) 2) I found another thread in “Ask a scientist” (Argonne National Laboratory) called "Sliding Versus Rolling on Friction Free Incline" posted by Alicia (http://newton.dep.anl.gov/aasquesv.htm http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasc...5/phy05139.htm) Any other links? 


#8
Jun2509, 04:53 AM

Mentor
P: 41,563




#9
Jun2509, 01:01 PM

HW Helper
P: 2,322

But the ball does roll about point P. The ball's center of mass is moving down the slope, which means the line connecting P with the C.O.M. is rotating counterclockwise.



#10
Jun2509, 02:01 PM

Mentor
P: 41,563




#11
Jun2509, 02:59 PM

HW Helper
P: 2,322




#12
Jun2709, 12:55 AM

P: 34

P is the point of contact with the ball and the ramp. So it is constantly changing if the ball is rolling.



#13
Jun2709, 03:17 AM

P: 34

If what is said is correct, then a wooden cylindrical rod standing on end on a frictionless ramp would NOT topple over (ie rotate)? It would simply slide down the ramp still standing on end!
Does this seem counterintuitive to you? I thought it would topple over. 


#14
Jun2709, 11:35 AM

HW Helper
P: 2,322




#15
Jun2909, 01:37 AM

P: 34

Thanks all. I see I am going to have change my idea about an unbalanced torque implying rolling!



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Which car will slide first?  General Physics  11  
Roll Cages  Materials & Chemical Engineering  4  
Roll of Paper  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Will it slide?  Classical Physics  5  
When I'm on a roll I'm on a roll  General Discussion  1 