image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Physics > Special & General Relativity


Reply

image increasing mass approachng c. Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Jul1-09, 10:43 PM                  #1
keepitmoving

keepitmoving is Offline:
Posts: 87
increasing mass approachng c.

as i heard it, as an object increases velocity toward c, the mass of the object will increase as a result of the increasing energy which resulted from the increased speed. What is this speed relative to? - the object the speeding object departed from, or relative to an object in the direction of motion? What if those objects moved or ceased to exist - wouldn`t that change the relative speed and therefore the relative energy and therefore the mass?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul1-09, 10:55 PM                  #2
DaveC426913
 
DaveC426913's Avatar

DaveC426913 is Offline:
Posts: 8,234
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

Originally Posted by keepitmoving View Post
as i heard it, as an object increases velocity toward c, the mass of the object will increase as a result of the increasing energy which resulted from the increased speed. What is this speed relative to? - the object the speeding object departed from, or relative to an object in the direction of motion? What if those objects moved or ceased to exist - wouldn`t that change the relative speed and therefore the relative energy and therefore the mass?
Yep. You have to define what reference point you are observing from.

Note that if you define your observational reference point from a point that is pacing the object, you will not observe any untoward changes in mass, length or passage of time.

This is the meaning of relative in relavity. Your relationship with the object is relative and therefore, so are your measurements. There is no such things as an objective change in mass, length or passage of time.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul1-09, 11:29 PM                  #3
keepitmoving

keepitmoving is Offline:
Posts: 87
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

once the moving object approaches c, the other object which was used as a reference point is far away and maybe it has moved away with great speed. How can that object have an effect on the original moving object?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul1-09, 11:52 PM                  #4
Libohove90

Libohove90 is Offline:
Posts: 5
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

Originally Posted by keepitmoving View Post
once the moving object approaches c, the other object which was used as a reference point is far away and maybe it has moved away with great speed. How can that object have an effect on the original moving object?
You still don't get it. There is no ORIGINAL moving object. Once the moving object approaches c, from the reference frame of the other object...it is increasing energy and mass only from the object's reference point.

Bring a third object thats moving at a different speed, it will measure different results than the previous object.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 12:27 AM       Last edited by keepitmoving; Jul2-09 at 12:32 AM..            #5
keepitmoving

keepitmoving is Offline:
Posts: 87
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

i guess what i`m saying is how do the measurements of objects far away determine the ability of the original moving object to continue to accelerate? The ability to accelerate is controlled by it`s mass (it`s increasing mass) which according to what you say, is determined by measurements made by objects far away, objects that don`t even get the same measurements. I can see how their measurements might differ but how can their measurements determine the fate of the original moving object?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 12:39 AM                  #6
bucher

bucher is Offline:
Posts: 76
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

The relativistic mass is only in the reference frame of the observer, not the moving object itself. If you were to move near the speed of light, you wouldn't actually gain mass. However, if someone else were observing your movements, then they would observe you having more mass.

It's all relative to an observer.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 12:42 AM                  #7
keepitmoving

keepitmoving is Offline:
Posts: 87
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

if, as i move close to the speed of light, i am only gaining mass according to the measurements of the observer, why can`t i continue to accelerate?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 01:14 AM                  #8
darkhorror

darkhorror is Offline:
Posts: 16
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

You can still continue to accelerate, on a spaceship you could accelerate forever at a constant acceleration. It's with respect to the outside observer that your acceleration will be slowing down, and since this is happening your mass seems to be increasing to that observer.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 06:30 AM                  #9
keepitmoving

keepitmoving is Offline:
Posts: 87
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

but wouldn`t continued acceleration result in a velocity faster than c?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 06:36 AM                  #10
fatra2

fatra2 is Offline:
Posts: 318
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

Originally Posted by keepitmoving View Post
but wouldn`t continued acceleration result in a velocity faster than c?
No. It would be the case if you follow Newton's 2nd law:
LaTeX Code: F=m\\frac{dv}{dt}
which says that a force acting on an object will make it's velocity change.

But what Newton did not know is that the mass is not constant. With increasing kinetic energy, the mass of the object increases. You could still follow Newton's law, with this simple change:
LaTeX Code: F = \\frac{d(mv)}{dt}
which says that a force acting on an object will make the combination of it's mass and velocity change.

Cheers
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 06:40 AM                  #11
HallsofIvy

PF Mentor

HallsofIvy is Offline:
Posts: 24,778
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

Originally Posted by keepitmoving View Post
but wouldn`t continued acceleration result in a velocity faster than c?
The point you may be missing is that your speed is always relative to some other coordinate frame. In your frame, you mass doesn't change because your speed is always zero relative to your own frame. You are accelerating, and your speed approaching c, only relative to some other frame of reference. And relative to that other frame, your mass is increasing.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 06:41 AM                  #12
keepitmoving

keepitmoving is Offline:
Posts: 87
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

are you saying that the expenditure of fuel causes the mass of the object to increase?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 07:01 AM                  #13
fatra2

fatra2 is Offline:
Posts: 318
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

You are talking about different things.

Originally Posted by keepitmoving View Post
are you saying that the expenditure of fuel causes the mass of the object to increase?
You are referring to a technical point, which relates to the way we know of increasing the energy of a space ship. Of course that the more gasoline you use, the less your space ship will have mass.

We are talking about the mass of an object that is accelerated, independant of the process to do so. For example, the astronaut's mass in the spaceship will increase with increasing velocity.

Cheers
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 10:34 AM                  #14
stone1

stone1 is Offline:
Posts: 12
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

or you could move so far away from the original object that space expansion kicks in and you can move relative to the original object at speeds higher than c.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 10:50 AM                  #15
Matterwave

Matterwave is Offline:
Posts: 161
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

You don't have to think of an increase in mass. The mass is invariant; however, the "inertia" it feels will change. The modification term, gamma, is usually lumped with the mass and people call that the "effective mass"; however, there is no reason that the gamma term actually suggests the actual mass of the thing ever changes. If you look at the equations, there's no reason to really lump gamma together with the mass, you very well may lump it with the entire quantity (mv).
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 02:59 PM                  #16
bucher

bucher is Offline:
Posts: 76
Re: increasing mass approachng c.

Originally Posted by keepitmoving View Post
but wouldn`t continued acceleration result in a velocity faster than c?
The energy required for you to accelerate would increase substantially as you approach c.

Kinetic Energy = mc2(LaTeX Code: \\gamma -1)

As you approach the speed of light, it will cause a near infinite amount of energy to accelerate you any further.
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: increasing mass approachng c.
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Increasing mass of Earth Blenton Earth 5 Jun11-09 11:46 PM
Question about SR and increasing mass LennoxLewis Special & General Relativity 6 May27-09 06:16 PM
Object's Mass Increasing leftyguitarjo Special & General Relativity 5 Apr26-08 05:43 PM
increasing mass, decreasing force? Rothiemurchus Special & General Relativity 15 Sep26-04 05:02 PM
Mass increasing with energy Swiss Army Special & General Relativity 6 Apr13-04 05:25 AM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image