What Is This Mysterious Creature Found in San Antonio?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ivan Seeking
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Animal Strange
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the identification of a mysterious creature found in San Antonio, with participants speculating on its possible species, including a hairless Mexican dog, a coyote with mange, or a hybrid. The conversation includes references to visual evidence and media coverage, as well as the implications of DNA testing for identification.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest the creature could be a hairless Mexican dog, a coyote with mange, or an armadillo without a shell.
  • Others express skepticism about the quality of the photographs and question the ability to identify the creature based on them.
  • A participant mentions that the San Antonio Zoo has not seen anything like it and speculates it might be a wild Mexican dog.
  • There are discussions about the possibility of DNA testing to confirm the creature's identity, with some questioning why visual identification isn't sufficient.
  • Participants share anecdotes about ligers and discuss genetic factors related to their size, drawing parallels to the current mystery creature.
  • Some express frustration with the media's focus on sensational topics rather than informative news about local events.
  • There are references to other potential animals, such as a muntjac deer, and links to external resources for further information.
  • Updates indicate that DNA testing is underway, which could take several weeks to yield results.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the creature's identity, with multiple competing views and ongoing speculation about its nature and the adequacy of the evidence presented.

Contextual Notes

The discussion includes limitations related to the quality of visual evidence and the uncertainty surrounding the identification process, as well as the potential for differing interpretations of the creature's appearance.

Who May Find This Useful

Readers interested in cryptozoology, animal identification, or local news regarding unusual wildlife encounters may find this discussion relevant.

Ivan Seeking
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
8,252
Reaction score
2,664
A Hairless Mexican dog, a coyote with mange, an armadillo without a shell, a hybrid? An interesting story with a [dead] body for evidence.

Be sure to watch the video.

...People at the San Antonio Zoo say they have not seen anything like it. Terry DeRosa with the zoo says at a feather-light 20 pounds, he thinks it might be a wild mexican dog. [continued]

http://www.woai.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=FAE91F84-A264-4AC3-8EA4-9097690CDEFC
 
Last edited:
Biology news on Phys.org
Can't they put up some larger pictures?
 
Ivan Seeking said:
A Hairless Mexican dog, a coyote with mange, an armadillo without a shell, a hybrid? An interesting story with a [dead] body for evidence.

Be sure to watch the video.



http://www.woai.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=FAE91F84-A264-4AC3-8EA4-9097690CDEFC
That animal looks like the one from an xH outer space, just compare the picture of their faces, you will see what I mean..
 
I have no idea what you are talking about.
 
:confused: why are ALL the newsitems about sex/death/abuse? typical..
 
Monique said:
funny that they put such grainy pictures up.. it looks just like a dog to me :confused:

Here's an update to the story.. they even got a 'liger' animal in there
(cross tiger and a lion) :-p
http://video.woai.com/viewer/viewerpage.php?Art_ID=23556&tf=woaiviewer.tpl

The face doesn't look like a dog's face to me...except maybe a little like a Chihuahua. What surprises me is that people at the Zoo couldn't be sure. Can't they do some kind of simple test to show whether or not its a breed of dog, or is DNA the only method beyond visual identification for something like this?

An interesting note about the Liger: I will probably get this backwards, but the gene that controls growth is found in the female lion, and in the male tiger. So, if we cross a male lion, with a female tiget we get something absolutely amazing - the biggest kitty cat I have ever seen! I think it may weigh almost twice as much as a normal lion or tiger. I saw a short nature diddi on this quite some time ago so the exact details are a bit vague. Must google.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ivan Seeking said:
The face doesn't look like a dog's face to me...except maybe a little like a Chihuahua. What surprises me is that people at the Zoo couldn't be sure. Can't they do some kind of simple test to show whether or not its a breed of dog, or is DNA the only method beyond visual identification for something like this?

An interesting note about the Liger: I will probably get this backwards, but the gene that controls growth is found in the female lion, and in the male tiger. So, if we cross a male lion, with a female tiget we get something absolutely amazing - the biggest kitty cat I have ever seen! I think it may weigh almost twice as much as a normal lion or tiger. I saw a short nature diddi on this quite some time ago so the exact details are a bit vague. Must google.

Hey! I saw the same program about the liger. I don't remember if you have the parent's sexes right, but yeah that was really neat, because the gene that limited growth was in the parent of each species that they *didn't* use to breed. Really neat! Remember the shot where it was standing with its paws on the table, and how tall it was??

With this "chupacabra", like you said, why can't they just get some DNA and compare it whatever breed of C. familiaris (dog?)? I don't see why it's so difficult, the profs at my university compare DNA of plants all the time.
 
Monique said:
:confused: why are ALL the newsitems about sex/death/abuse? typical..

Because it grabs attention :-) Who wants to watch news about the worlds biggest cookie?
 
  • #10
Maybe some social or political topics would be in place.. I was actually curious what's going on in San Antonio.. that's why you'd usually watch the news.. well.. I won't be stopping by when I'm in the neighbourhood :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
  • #11
aychamo said:
Hey! I saw the same program about the liger. I don't remember if you have the parent's sexes right, but yeah that was really neat, because the gene that limited growth was in the parent of each species that they *didn't* use to breed. Really neat! Remember the shot where it was standing with its paws on the table, and how tall it was??

and the guy is standing on the picnic table and holding the meat as high as he can, and the Liger stands up and takes it with its mouth. :surprise:

That is one big animal! AMAZING!
 
  • #12
Monique said:
Maybe some social or political topics would be in place.. I was actually curious what's going on in San Antonio.. that's why you'd usually watch the news.. well.. I won't be stopping by when I'm in the neighbourhood :rolleyes:


chicken of tham thar chupacabras are yeh? :biggrin:
 
  • #13
omg [PLAIN]http://www.tigers-animal-actors.com/pom/liger.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #14
Yes that would be the one. Incredible isn't it?
 
  • #15
Monique said:
Maybe some social or political topics would be in place.. I was actually curious what's going on in San Antonio.. that's why you'd usually watch the news.. well.. I won't be stopping by when I'm in the neighbourhood :rolleyes:

Are you in San Antonio often? ;)
 
  • #16
Monique said:
Maybe some social or political topics would be in place.. I was actually curious what's going on in San Antonio.. that's why you'd usually watch the news.. well.. I won't be stopping by when I'm in the neighbourhood :rolleyes:

It's bland and boring as hell. Don't speed, either. The cops are ruthless.
 
  • #17
Yes, but can you still legally drink while you drive? For me, many years ago at least, that defined Texas.
 
  • #18
It's impossible to tell anything from those pictures...those have to be some of the worst quality photos I've ever seen, and no way to even enlarge them. I'm sure they could just do a DNA test to confirm it's a dog if that's what they think it is. Looks emaciated...ribs and hip bones just sticking out...or has it been dead a while?

Hard to believe it was doing that good of a job catching chickens if it looks so scrawny. Wonder if he really got the right culprit there.
 
  • #20
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #22
DNA Testing Underway
...Biologists dug up the animal's remains for DNA testing, a process that could take up to six weeks...

http://www.woai.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=317D3A73-8413-449D-A218-DEE30F924E81
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #23
S.A. Zoo Weighs-In on Chupacabra Debate

...Bones from a mystery animal shot by an Elmendorf rancher have been taken to an expert from the San Antonio Zoo. But can he tell what it is? John Gramieri, the Mammal Curator at the San Antonio Zoo, doesn't think it's the Chupacabra. It's definitely unique, but he thinks it's a mix between a dog and a coyote. [continued]

http://www.woai.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=4E470718-F7B0-48AB-AC65-C5A1108E62B0
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #24
A second mystery animal killed?

We're still waiting on the DNA report from the first animal, but there may be a another...

LUFKIN, Texas -- Local animal experts are having a hard time identifying a strange looking animal killed in Angelina County on Friday -- an animal that looks eerily similar to the as yet unidentified "Elmendorf Beast" killed near San Antonio earlier this year. [continued with good pictures]

http://woai.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=EBC8FC7B-ED5D-46A5-8DA4-3C6F6C31975E

If the link doesn't work then try again later - it is a good. The story is linked at Coast to Coast AM which is famous for swamping servers.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #25
Well, at least we finally get to see some clear, close-up photos! That article is right, it looks like it's been dead for days, not hours! Demodex mange...yipes, that's pretty nasty stuff and will kill an animal. I think that article gets to the important point, it's more of a concern to find out what these animals are infected with than whether it's a dog or coyote. If you've got wild animals around spreading a serious infection of mange, the local livestock farmers need to know to watch their herds.
 
  • #26
Whatever the results the finding will be interesting nonetheless. Either we have some new species or we have some seriously sick animals. If this is the fables "Chupacabra" maybe that isn't such a good thing if they are being found. Although you would wonder how something that has been stories for years would all of a sudden just pop up out of no where.
 
  • #27
I found some upclose photo's...
http://www.unknowncountry.com/lufkin_images.phtml
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #28
It's a fox with mange. I'll pull a link if needed later.
 
  • #29
I didn't spot anything except unsubstantiated statements as such. Where did you find this?
 
  • #30
I am wondering if this story is getting confused with the Maryland story.

UPDATED: 11:57 am EDT August 2, 2004

GLYNDON, Md. -- The mystery may be over as one of the creatures roaming through central Maryland was finally captured on Saturday.

According to the veterinarians at Falls Road Animal Hospital, the animal was a male red fox. However, Dr. Michael Herko -- a vet at the animal hospital -- and the man who caught the fox say it is not the mysterious creature videotaped in July, but a relative.

...Animal control officers took the creature to the Falls Road Animal Hospital. They determined it was a fox with sarcoptic mange[continued]

http://www.thewbalchannel.com/news/3604238/detail.html

Here is a picture of a Red Fox with mange.
http://www.bto.org/gbw/mammals/species%20accounts/redfo.htm
It should be relatively straightforward to identify a fox. The conspicuous features are the slender muzzle, erect black-backed ears and long, bushy tail. Individuals suffering from mange (see photograph below) may have patches of fur missing and in some cases the tail is far from bushy. Fresh fox droppings (known as scats) are black with a characteristic odour. They often have a characteristic twist in them, which helps distinguish fox droppings from those of dog.

There are reports of similar sightings from many parts of the country. Maybe a real problem for the fox population?
 
Last edited by a moderator: