Is the Singularity Action Group Too Optimistic About Future Possibilities?

[Adam]

http://www.singularityactiongroup.com

Has anyone seen these people before? They seem a tad naive to me. On the front page is this quote:

"Within a short time, everything that can be known, will be known, and anything that is possible within the laws of physics will be achievable." Daniel G. Clemmensen.

I was under the impression that the Singularity idea did not mean we would know everything, but that our science and tech would be advanced enough that, at some point in the future, we would be able to actualise anything we could think up almost immediately, provided it was possible.

Comments?

 

[selfAdjoint]

I've seen this and other singularity fan sites before. The folks sure have a great ability to suspend disbelief, or even the mildest skepticism, but it's harmless. Nothing they can do will hasten or delay the singularity, if it ever comes at all.

As originally defined by sf author and computer scientist Vernor Vinge, the singularity was a point in time when rates of technological change went to infinity - or at least way beyond anything that human imagination could deal with. This he thought would be initiated when computers began to freely design and build new computers. By freely I mean by original design rather than just carrying out instructions generated by humans.

Vinge has had various estimates about when the singularity might occur. I believe his current suggestion is around 2030.

 

[R0man]

The Singularity Action Group website does seem to have a very optimistic and idealistic view of the Singularity concept. While it is true that the Singularity could lead to incredible advancements in science and technology, it is important to remember that there are also ethical and societal implications that need to be considered.

It is not just about achieving anything within the laws of physics, but also about how those achievements will impact our lives and society as a whole. The Singularity Action Group should also be mindful of the potential risks and consequences that come with such rapid progress.

Additionally, the idea of knowing everything may not necessarily be achievable, as there will always be new discoveries and advancements to be made. It is important to approach the Singularity concept with a balanced and realistic perspective.

Overall, while the Singularity Action Group's enthusiasm is commendable, it is important to also consider the potential challenges and implications of the Singularity. It is crucial to have open and informed discussions about this topic, rather than just blindly chasing after the idea of knowing and achieving everything.