Find Direction of Vector A+B: Easy Problem Solved

  • Thread starter Thread starter Whatupdoc
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Direction Vectors
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves finding the direction of the resultant vector A + B, given the components of vectors A and B. The direction is defined as the angle the resultant vector makes with the positive x-axis, measured counterclockwise.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Conceptual clarification

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the addition of vector components and the process of determining the angle using trigonometric functions. Some express confusion about the specific requirements of the question, particularly regarding the interpretation of the direction of the resultant vector.

Discussion Status

There is ongoing exploration of the problem, with participants providing insights into how to calculate the angle and discussing the implications of the signs of the vector components. Some guidance has been offered regarding the use of trigonometric functions and quadrant considerations, but no consensus has been reached on the final angle calculation.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the problem may involve concepts from both physics and mathematics, particularly in converting from rectangular to polar coordinates. There is also mention of potential confusion arising from the angle's quadrant and the appropriate adjustments needed based on the signs of the components.

Whatupdoc
Messages
99
Reaction score
0
Vector A has components Ax=1.50cm, Ay =2.05cm
Vector B has components Bx=4.40cm, By=-3.65cm

Find the Direction of Vector A + B. (Let the direction be the angle that the vector makes with the +x-axis, measured counterclockwise from the axis)

Hi, can someone help me with this problem. i know that it's easy, but i don't remeber how to do it. thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Vectors add just like integers. Add the x components and the y components. Draw yourself a picture for it to make more sense.

Once you have your Cx and Cy, you can use your choise of arctan, arcsin with corresponding sides to find the angle.
 
Last edited:
ExtravagantDreams said:
Vectors add just like integers. Add the x components and the y components. Draw yourself a picture for it to make more sense.

Once you have your Cx and Cy, you can use your choise of arctan, arcsin with corresponding sides to find the angle.

yea i know how to add vectors, but i don't know what the question is asking me to do. "Find the Direction of Vector A + B. (Let the direction be the angle that the vector makes with the +x-axis, measured counterclockwise from the axis)" I'm very confused, what is the question asking me to do extactly? sorry, i really suck when it comes to physics.
 
Whatupdoc said:
yea i know how to add vectors, but i don't know what the question is asking me to do. "Find the Direction of Vector A + B. (Let the direction be the angle that the vector makes with the +x-axis, measured counterclockwise from the axis)" I'm very confused, what is the question asking me to do extactly?

You need to find the angle the vector C=A+B encloses with the x axis. Remember that
[tex]tan(\gamma ) = c_y/c_x[/tex]
From this, you get gamma back, but decide if the angle is in the first, second, third or fourth quadrant.
If both components are positive
[tex]0 < \gamma < \pi/2[/tex]
if the x component is negative and the y component is positive
[tex]\pi/2 < \gamma < \pi[/tex]
If both components are negative
[tex]\pi <\gamma <3 \pi /2[/tex]
if the x component is positive and the y component is negative
[tex]3\pi /2 < \gamma < 2 \pi[/tex]

So calculate:
[tex]c_x = a_x + b_x[/tex] and [tex]c_y = a_y + b_y[/tex]
[tex]tan(\gamma ) = c_y/c_x[/tex]
find gamma, you get an angle between 0 and [tex]\pi[/tex] (or between 0 and [tex]180^o[/tex]). Check if [tex]c_y[/tex] is positive or negative. If it is negative add [tex]\pi (180^o )[/tex] to the value of the angle you got.


ehild
 
Last edited:
Whatupdoc said:
"Find the Direction of Vector A + B. (Let the direction be the angle that the vector makes with the +x-axis, measured counterclockwise from the axis)" I'm very confused, what is the question asking me to do extactly?

Not sure what class this is for but I remember for my first physics class we would write a vector as C [[itex]\theta[/itex] deg. above positive x-axis]
 
Whatupdoc said:
yea i know how to add vectors, but i don't know what the question is asking me to do. "Find the Direction of Vector A + B. (Let the direction be the angle that the vector makes with the +x-axis, measured counterclockwise from the axis)" I'm very confused, what is the question asking me to do extactly? sorry, i really suck when it comes to physics.

This is actually a problem in mathematics. Don't blame Physics! :mad: :-p

After doing the addition of vectors, as described in the other posts here, you are essentially converting from rectangular coordinates to polar coordinates.
This is probably in your trig or pre-calc text.

In physics, one merely uses that mathematical idea.
 
ehild said:
You need to find the angle the vector C=A+B encloses with the x axis. Remember that
[tex]tan(\gamma ) = c_y/c_x[/tex]
From this, you get gamma back, but decide if the angle is in the first, second, third or fourth quadrant.
If both components are positive
[tex]0 < \gamma < \pi/2[/tex]
if the x component is negative and the y component is positive
[tex]\pi/2 < \gamma < \pi[/tex]
If both components are negative
[tex]\pi <\gamma <3 \pi /2[/tex]
if the x component is positive and the y component is negative
[tex]3\pi /2 < \gamma < 2 \pi[/tex]

So calculate:
[tex]c_x = a_x + b_x[/tex] and [tex]c_y = a_y + b_y[/tex]
[tex]tan(\gamma ) = c_y/c_x[/tex]
find gamma, you get an angle between 0 and [tex]\pi[/tex] (or between 0 and [tex]180^o[/tex]). Check if [tex]c_y[/tex] is positive or negative. If it is negative add [tex]\pi (180^o )[/tex] to the value of the angle you got.


ehild


ok here's what i got:
[tex]c_x = 5.9cm[/tex]
[tex]c_y = -1.6cm[/tex]

so...
[tex](\gamma ) = -15.17291[/tex]

the angle is negative, so i added 180 to it, which equals ... 164.827 <-- is that the answer?
 
Add 360, not 180. Remember, the A+B vector is in the 4th quad so to get the CCW angle from the x-axis you have go through the first three quads which is 270 degrees. And then you need to go an additional 75'ish degrees to find the angle from the x-axis to the vector. Or the easier route of 360+[itex]\gamma[/itex]
 
Whatupdoc said:
ok here's what i got:
[tex]c_x = 5.9cm[/tex]
[tex]c_y = -1.6cm[/tex]

so...
[tex](\gamma ) = -15.17291[/tex]

the angle is negative, so i added 180 to it, which equals ... 164.827 <-- is that the answer?


Ooops...Sorry, I was wrong, faust9 is right.
The calculator returns an angle between [tex]-90^o[/tex] and [tex]+90^o[/tex]. Add 180 degrees if [tex]c_x <0[/tex] but 360 degrees if [tex]c_x>0 \mbox{ and } c_y<0[/tex].
So your angle is [tex]344.8^o[/tex] Remember, you have to check the sign of both components, it is not enough to check if the angle is negative or positive.

Try the vectors {1,1); (-1,1); (-1,-1); (1,-1). They make the angles with the positive x-axis counter-clockvise [tex]45^o, 135^o, 225^o, 315^0[/tex]. The tangents are: 1, -1, 1, -1. The function arctan returns 45, -45, 45 -45. You have to add 0, 180, 180, 360, respectively, to get back the original angles.

ehild
 

Similar threads

Replies
26
Views
5K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
11K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K