Register to reply 
How to interpret a negative yintercept? 
Share this thread: 
#1
Sep1610, 05:32 PM

P: 10

I'm taking Physics 11 and we're doing a graphing exercise. The graph is Cricket Chirps per minute(as dependent variable) on the YAxis versus Degrees Celsius(Independent Variable) Along the xaxis.
I've drawn my line of best fit. The exercise asks that I find the yintercept of the line of best fit. I've found it to be 65 chirps/minute. The next question asks how would one interpret the yintercept. This doesn't make any sense to me.. I'm positive I've done the graphing and calculations correctly as the equation works find for finding points on the graph. I've asked my physics teacher some questions and he says they're not correct. I've asked: Is it possible the cricket stops chirping and begins processing chirps. He said no, which leaves me at a dead end. I could just put 'undefined' not sure if that'd be correct though. Also, how would I show this on a graph? 


#2
Sep1610, 06:10 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 5,197

Welcome to PF,
The bottom line is that for a discrete, countable thing like cricket chirps, it just doesn't make sense to have a negative value. Your result is unphysical, and it indicates either that you have done something wrong, or that the graph should be a piecewise function (meaning that it is linear with some nonzero slope down to the temperature at which the crickets stop chirping altogether, and then linear with zero slope (i.e. flat) below that temperature). So, assuming you have done the fitting right, then maybe the best interpretation of your data is, "below some positive temperature, the crickets stop chirping altogether." EDIT: Another way to express what I'm saying is that the cricket chirp rate is only wellmodelled by a linear function over a limited temperature range. Below some temperature, there is a cutoff. 


#3
Sep1610, 06:13 PM

P: 10

So say the cricket chrips 0 times a minute at 10 degrees, could I say:
The yintercept is undefined because the temperature must be above or equal to 10 degrees? 


#4
Sep1610, 06:14 PM

P: 15,319

How to interpret a negative yintercept?
Can you describe your data a little? I'd like to see how your data led to a negative yintercept.



#5
Sep1610, 06:19 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 5,197

Again, all of this ASSUMES you've done the earlier parts of the homework exercise properly, which is not a given. EDIT: Yes, DaveC is right. Taking a look at what you've done so far is the best way of making that determination. 


#6
Sep1610, 06:21 PM

P: 10

Where Temperature is the Independent Variable Chirps Per Minute : Degrees Celsius 7 : 11 20 : 13 36 : 15 47 :17 61 : 19 69 : 20 Using this data I created a line if best fit. The mathematical equation of the line is: y = 6.7x  65 


#8
Sep1610, 06:29 PM

P: 10

Alright, so it would it be fair to say:
There is not a sufficient amount of data to accurately determine the true yintercept, as the rate of chirps per degree Celsius does not grow or decline at a consistent enough rate. So than my equation for finding chirps per minute is only accurate between a given range of temperature. Would this mean I would have to add a limit to the temperature value in the equation? i.e (Mathematically) Y: Chirps/min X: Temperature y = 6.7x  65 20>x>=10 Would that be correct? 


#9
Sep1610, 06:39 PM

P: 15,319




#10
Sep1610, 06:50 PM

P: 10

Ohh, okay. So than one should interpret a negative 65 chirps per minute as 0 chirps per a minute. Or presumably 0 chirps per a minute, though I can't be sure because I haven't been given enough data?



#11
Sep1610, 06:54 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 5,197




#12
Sep1610, 06:56 PM

P: 10

Alright.
Thanks cepheid & DaveC426913. I just started in Physics and I know my teacher is trying to trick me with this question, lol. I don't want to be tricked w\ it though. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Interpret this geometrically  Calculus  4  
Passive sign convention (negative watts, and negative current confusion)  Advanced Physics Homework  7  
How should I interpret?  Calculus & Beyond Homework  3  
How to interpret QM  Quantum Physics  27  
How to interpret 3^3 + 4^3 + 5^3 = 6^3 ?  General Math  3 