image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > PF Lounge > Scepticism & Debunking


Reply

image Portrait of a pet psychic Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Sep21-04, 06:53 PM                  #1
Ivan Seeking

PF Mentor
 
Ivan Seeking's Avatar

Ivan Seeking is Offline:
Posts: 10,391
Portrait of a pet psychic

A couple of weeks ago, my cat Fritz began talking to me. After a lifetime of silence, his comments were surprisingly ordinary: among other things, he mentioned that he’s not very fond of the kibble he eats on a regular basis and would prefer to be on a more nutritious diet. He also said that he would appreciate it if I got him a better scratching post, one that he could really stretch out his back on.

In the interest of full disclosure, I should point out that Fritz was not speaking directly to me, but through Maleah Jacobs, an animal communicator who specializes in two-way telepathy with critters. [continued]
http://msnbc.msn.com/id/6010801/
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep21-04, 09:08 PM                  #2
Chronos

Chronos is Offline:
Posts: 5,361
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Not impressed. Anyone can be an animal communicator if they quiet their minds. I happen to be a household appliance communicator - and my rates are quite reasonable. My specialty is kitchen appliances, but, I can do most room varietals, including garage and woodshed appliances.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep21-04, 09:23 PM                  #3
Math Is Hard

PF Mentor
 
Math Is Hard's Avatar

Math Is Hard is Offline:
Posts: 3,734
Blog Entries: 7
Originally Posted by Chronos
Not impressed. Anyone can be an animal communicator if they quiet their minds. I happen to be a household appliance communicator - and my rates are quite reasonable. My specialty is kitchen appliances, but, I can do most room varietals, including garage and woodshed appliances.
Can you tell me why my toaster is depressed?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep21-04, 11:26 PM                  #4
Ivan Seeking

PF Mentor
 
Ivan Seeking's Avatar

Ivan Seeking is Offline:
Posts: 10,391
I want to know why they can see animal's thoughts but not people's thoughts. Lets see, could it be that we can verify what people are thinking but not what Fido is thinking? But that would imply fraud!

So, do these people really think they see the thoughts of animals - are they fooling themselves as well as others - or is this simple fraud?
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep21-04, 11:41 PM                  #5
Math Is Hard

PF Mentor
 
Math Is Hard's Avatar

Math Is Hard is Offline:
Posts: 3,734
Blog Entries: 7
People who claim to be psychic frequently use the metaphor that they are radios, and that they "tune in" to a certain frequency when they are doing their work. Maybe they are saying that some psychics are better at receiving the "animal frequency" and some are better at receiving the "human frequency".

p.s. Bun said she would like have a new catnip mousie- red preferably- and Zoobie asks that you please not rub her belly fur in the opposite direction that it grows.
( kidding!)
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep22-04, 01:11 AM                  #6
Moonbear
 
Moonbear's Avatar

Moonbear is Offline:
Posts: 11,648
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Retired Staff Retired Staff
Originally Posted by Math Is Hard
- and Zoobie asks that you please not rub her belly fur in the opposite direction that it grows.
( kidding!)
But you don't need to be psychic to know this...cats are very effective at communicating this through sign language, i.e., claws!

I don't think these people really believe this stuff, I think they just found a gullible audience willing to pay for such a service.

Then again, I can communicate with sheep...I just pace the field, telepathically talking to each of them, and they all walk in the direction I ask them to...well, except that one stubborn one that always refuses to listen to me and has to do her own thing.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep22-04, 01:18 AM                  #7
Chronos

Chronos is Offline:
Posts: 5,361
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Originally Posted by Math Is Hard
Can you tell me why my toaster is depressed?
That is an easy one. Your toaster is depressed because it feels crumby deep down inside.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep22-04, 01:36 AM                  #8
Ivan Seeking

PF Mentor
 
Ivan Seeking's Avatar

Ivan Seeking is Offline:
Posts: 10,391
I have no doubt that we can communicate with animals on many levels. Body language tells much. Tsu and I have learned to read cats extremely well, and dogs reasonably well, but I can say that they read me better than I read them; much better. Sometimes I could almost believe that they can read our minds.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep22-04, 01:38 AM                  #9
Ivan Seeking

PF Mentor
 
Ivan Seeking's Avatar

Ivan Seeking is Offline:
Posts: 10,391
Originally Posted by Math Is Hard
p.s. Bun said she would like have a new catnip mousie- red preferably- and Zoobie asks that you please not rub her belly fur in the opposite direction that it grows.
( kidding!)
I strongly suggest staying out of Buns little head. She's psychotic!!!
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep22-04, 02:51 AM                  #10
Chronos

Chronos is Offline:
Posts: 5,361
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Er, catatonic judging by the avatar.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep22-04, 01:22 PM                  #11
Les Sleeth
 
Les Sleeth's Avatar

Les Sleeth is Offline:
Posts: 2,189
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
I just wanted to repeat an earlier suggestion I made that a better test for psychics is being demonstrated currently on Court TV (Tuesday evenings) with their new series of episodes called "Psychic Detectives." There one can witness how predictions turn out and judge them by results. So far I am really impressed by how well some of the psychics do; if the TV show isn't scamming us, then the results are far better than what guessing could achieve.
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep22-04, 02:36 PM                  #12
Math Is Hard

PF Mentor
 
Math Is Hard's Avatar

Math Is Hard is Offline:
Posts: 3,734
Blog Entries: 7
Ivan, I think a psycho-kitty mind-meld could only improve my personality.
Moonbear, that sheep trick is pretty cool! I thought only border collies could use mind control on sheep. They really do seem to have a supernatural communication - all they do is look at the sheep a certain way and the sheep behave.
Chronos, you are a true "toaster-whisperer".
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep22-04, 03:17 PM                  #13
Ivan Seeking

PF Mentor
 
Ivan Seeking's Avatar

Ivan Seeking is Offline:
Posts: 10,391
Originally Posted by Chronos
Er, catatonic judging by the avatar.
You're looking at the wrong kitty. THIS is Bun! [Thanks to dduardo for helping with this shot].

http://umsis.miami.edu/~dduardo/evil_genius_bun.png
  Reply With Quote
Old Sep23-04, 12:55 AM                  #14
Evo

PF Mentor
 
Evo's Avatar

Evo is Offline:
Posts: 10,498
Blog Entries: 1
Originally Posted by Moonbear
Then again, I can communicate with sheep...I just pace the field, telepathically talking to each of them, and they all walk in the direction I ask them to...well, except that one stubborn one that always refuses to listen to me and has to do her own thing.
Moonbear, you kill me!!!
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Portrait of a pet psychic
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Portrait Of Math Is Hard by zoobyshoe zoobyshoe General Discussion 72 Apr5-07 04:26 AM
clockwise or counterclockwise? (linear system phase portrait) ak416 Calculus & Beyond 1 Feb13-07 07:10 AM
Psychic at Large laminatedevildoll Scepticism & Debunking 8 May9-06 07:21 PM
Phase Portrait Question MathematicalPhysics Calculus & Analysis 1 Apr29-04 05:07 AM
Blind Psychic zoobyshoe Scepticism & Debunking 5 Aug4-03 01:00 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image