Calculate distance between two planets in elliptical orbits

In summary, two planets, Q and R, are orbiting the sun in elliptical orbits in the same plane with semi-major axis lengths of 64.8 AU and 42.5 AU, and eccentricities of 0.445 and 0.825 respectively. The perihelion point of R's orbit is rotated relative to that of Q by 124 degrees. The closest and greatest distance between the two planets in AU can be determined by plotting their orbits using a spreadsheet's plotting function or using the PolarPlotter2 Excel add-in, and locating the most distantly separated points on their orbits. This will provide a visual representation of the two orbits and allow for the calculation of the physical distance between the two planets at
  • #1
emilinus
15
0

Homework Statement



Two planets are orbiting the sun in elliptical orbits in the same plane. The orbit of planet Q has a semi-major axis of 64.8 AU and eccentricity of 0.445. Planet R has a semi-major axis of 42.5 AU and eccentricity of 0.825. The perihelion point of Planet R's orbit is rotated relative to that of Planet Q by 124 degrees. Determine the closest and greatest distance that Planet R and Q get from each other in AU.

Homework Equations


P^2 is proportional to a^3
c^2=a^2-b^2 (where b is the semi-minor axis)
c=ae
Circumference (orbital distance) = 2pi*sqrt((a^2+b^2)/2))

The Attempt at a Solution


P = sqrt*(a^3)
PQ= 277.0661022 yrs
PR= 521.6299378 yrs
cQ = (64.8*0.445) = 28.836 AU
cR = (42.5*0.885) = 35.0625 AU
bQ = sqrt*(64.8^2-28.836^2) = 58.03 AU
bR = 24.02 AU

So I'm not sure that I understand the set up of the orbits but either way I don't know where to go from here. How I understand it is that when both are at their perihelion points, there is an angle of 124 degrees between them where planet R's orbit is rotated from that of Planet Qs so that they aren't perfectly aligned but are still within the same plane (I hope that makes sense). With that I have two side lengths (both of their semi-major axis lengths) and an angle so I can get a distance between them. What next (if that's even a correct start)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Do you know the polar form for a planetary orbit?
 
  • #3
No that wasn't provided. I do have mean angular motion though. n=2pi/P and for Q = .012045292 and for R = .022677567. I'm not sure what the units are though...is it radians/year?
 
Last edited:
  • #4
Well, if it's a mean then it could be for anything ;-)

It's easy to rotate a polar equation through an angle simply by adding an offset to the angle. That's why I asked about the polar form. You should have it somewhere in your text. It looks like:

[tex] R(\theta) = \frac{p}{1 + e\; cos(\theta)}[/tex]

Where p is the semi latus-rectum for the orbit: p = a(1 - e2)

I don't know what tools you're expected to have on hand to find the maximum separation. Since the major axes of the two ellipses are not collinear, it will not be simply a matter of checking at the axes ends.
 
  • #5
Do you think it would be possible to use radians/year and go through different amounts of time to find the least and greatest amount of angular distance between the two planets? Then maybe I could plug the angles into that polar form equation to find the distance (using cosine law).
 
  • #6
I don't know what other information you were given other than what's in the problem statement that you provided. For example, I don't see any information on initial positions of the planets, or the mass of their Sun. I haven't checked to see if the orbital periods will be harmonically related, so that they might repeat the same patterns and "avoid" certain relative positions.

If it is assumed that the orbits are not harmonically related, then over time they will take on all relative positions allowed by their trajectories. So you don't even need to worry about particular mean angular velocities; just step the angles by small increments, and capture the maximum separation.

Even easier would be to use a "canned" solver to minimize the distance function (a function of two variables). What course is this for? Are you expected to have this sort of software available?
 
  • #7
The Sun I believe it supposed to be this solar system's Sun. No there's no software available. It's for an intro astronomy course in university.

The only other info I was given was that the use of spreadsheet might be helpful in solving the problem. So I'm assuming I just have to go through and find the closest and farthest angle differences...but wouldn't they just be 180 and 0 if the planets take all possible trajectories? That seems too easy.
 
  • #8
emilinus said:
The Sun I believe it supposed to be this solar system's Sun. No there's no software available. It's for an intro astronomy course in university.

The only other info I was given was that the use of spreadsheet might be helpful in solving the problem. So I'm assuming I just have to go through and find the closest and farthest angle differences...but wouldn't they just be 180 and 0 if the planets take all possible trajectories? That seems too easy.

Yes, that would be too easy :-) It's not angular separation that you're looking for, it's physical distance. Remember, the planets move independently, so one can be anywhere on its own orbit and the other anywhere on its own orbit. So you're looking for the most widely separated locations between the two orbits. Due to the rotation of one of the ellipses, this won't occur when the planets are at the ends of their axes, but somewhere else on their orbits.

There are two ellipses, one of which is rotated 124 degrees about its focus (essentially the Sun). So their major and minor axes are not aligned. At least you should be able to plot the two ellipses using a spreadsheet's plotting functions so that you can see what you're up against. You'll then be able to locate by eye the approximate locations of the most distantly separated points.
 
  • #9
I don't know how to use a spreadsheet plotting function...

I'm going to attempt to draw out the two ellipses properly to visualize where the farthest and closest points should be and then I suppose I'll have to sort of guess what angle that will be and use the calculated R lengths to solve for the distance between them (with a bit of trial and error to get the values as large and small as possible).
 
  • #10
The PolarPlotter2 Excel add-in is handy. It can be obtained http://www.andypope.info/charts/polarplot3.htm".

First create your data to be plotted. A column of angles and another two columns containing your R(angle) results. With the add-in installed, there will be an "Insert Polar Plot" selection on the "Insert" pull-down menu. Select it and follow the "wizard". easy-peasy.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #11
Thanks! I can't seem to figure out how to rotate one of the ellipses but I can try to visualize it.
 
  • #12
emilinus said:
Thanks! I can't seem to figure out how to rotate one of the ellipses but I can try to visualize it.

For the polar plot, just subtract the offset angle inside the cos() function:

R(Θ) = p/(1 + e(cos(Θ - Φ))
 
  • #13
That's very cool, thank you again. It actually matches my drawing, which is nice. I'm wondering though, because their orbits actually overlap, would their closest points be if they theoretically collided? From what I understand this isn't possible...and so my new dilemma lies in where to assume the closest point would be.
 
  • #14
emilinus said:
That's very cool, thank you again. It actually matches my drawing, which is nice. I'm wondering though, because their orbits actually overlap, would their closest points be if they theoretically collided? From what I understand this isn't possible...and so my new dilemma lies in where to assume the closest point would be.

If the planet's periods are not locked into some fixed harmonic ratio (which can happen when the mutual gravitational perturbations are just right), then they are doomed to collide if they are in the same plane. So your minimum distance will likely be zero, as you've surmised. It's possible that the overlapping orbits are the result of the problem's author not checking to see what he had wrought.
 
  • #15
I'm actually doing the same question (unless I'm mistaken, I'm in the same class), and the numbers are pseudo-randomly generated, meaning any orbit is possible. When you have orbits that don't intersect, how would you find longest/shortest distance?
 
  • #16
mysterypengui said:
I'm actually doing the same question (unless I'm mistaken, I'm in the same class), and the numbers are pseudo-randomly generated, meaning any orbit is possible. When you have orbits that don't intersect, how would you find longest/shortest distance?

Your choices, if the ellipses are not conveniently oriented so that the solution is obvious, is either a graphical approach (plot and measure with a ruler) or numerical (computer) method. I don't know of any convenient, direct mathematical approach.
 
  • #17
gneill said:
Your choices, if the ellipses are not conveniently oriented so that the solution is obvious, is either a graphical approach (plot and measure with a ruler) or numerical (computer) method. I don't know of any convenient, direct mathematical approach.

I still don't understand this problem, don't you clearly need to know the closest (perihelion) and furthest (aphelion) points to the sun as well to make this easier?

we have both the semi major axis's and eccentricity's and the rotation at the perihelion point (for one planet)
how do we get on about finding the min and max distances?
 
Last edited:
  • #18
zuberous said:
I still don't understand this problem, you clearly need to know the closest (perihelion) and furthest (aphelion) points to the sun as well to make this easier?

any detailed help would be beneficial!

The perihelion and aphelion points may or may not help depending upon the relative orientation of the two ellipses (draw a few and see... make sure that they share a focus).

If you know that one ellipse is rotated with respect to the other, and if that angle of rotation is not something trivial like 180 degrees, you'll have to plot them and "eyeball" the closest and furthest distances between their trajectories. You 'll then have to decide if you can get away with measuring from the plot, or solving numerically for the distances.
 

What is the formula for calculating the distance between two planets in elliptical orbits?

The formula for calculating the distance between two planets in elliptical orbits is given by the Kepler's third law of planetary motion, also known as the law of harmonies. It states that the square of the orbital period of a planet is proportional to the cube of the semi-major axis of its orbit.

What are the factors that affect the distance between two planets in elliptical orbits?

The distance between two planets in elliptical orbits is affected by the semi-major axis of their orbits, the eccentricity of their orbits, and the position of the two planets along their respective orbits. These factors determine the size and shape of the elliptical orbits and therefore, the distance between the two planets at any given point in time.

How do you calculate the semi-major axis and eccentricity of the orbits of two planets?

The semi-major axis of an orbit is half of the longest diameter of the elliptical orbit. It can be calculated using the distance between the furthest point and the closest point of the orbit, known as the apoapsis and periapsis, respectively. The eccentricity of an orbit is a measure of how elliptical the orbit is and can be calculated using the distance between the two foci of the orbit.

Can the distance between two planets in elliptical orbits change over time?

Yes, the distance between two planets in elliptical orbits can change over time. This is because the orbits of planets are not perfect ellipses and are affected by external factors such as the gravitational pull of other planets, asteroids, and comets. This can cause the orbits to become more or less elliptical, altering the distance between the two planets at different points in time.

How is the distance between two planets in elliptical orbits important in space missions?

The accurate calculation of the distance between two planets in elliptical orbits is crucial for successful space missions. It helps in determining the ideal launch window, trajectory, and fuel requirements for spacecraft to reach the desired planet. It also helps in planning for maneuvers and rendezvous between two spacecraft in orbit around different planets.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
774
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
763
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
784
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
6
Views
1K
Back
Top