New Reply

Japan Earthquake: nuclear plants

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
Mar24-11, 12:02 AM   #970
 

Japan Earthquake: nuclear plants


Quote by TCups View Post
Anton, RenoDeno:

Can you comment why the accumulation of NaCl from evaporated sea water poses such a
concern and be more specific about where exactly that accumulation is likely to take place?
because the salt crystals will clog the system and encase the fuel rods thus decreasing cooling
capacity, and grind away the impellers of Recirculation pumps and making these inoperative.
 
Mar24-11, 12:07 AM   #971
 
Quote by TCups View Post
Are you indeed sure?!
Hello TCups
Yes - I edited original post with below sentance

also satellite photo confirms this look at the arrangement of access roads.
 
Mar24-11, 12:09 AM   #972
 
Quote by AntonL View Post
We are comparing apples with pears!

The radiation map (the pink one) is from Fukushima Daini NPS
Although I cannot read Japanese I can read the numbers on the reactors
which compares with the Daini plant

also satellite photo confirms this look at the arrangement of access roads.
I think not, sir. Apples and Apples, unless the two have EXACTLY the same layout:

 
Mar24-11, 12:14 AM   #973
 
Quote by TCups View Post
I think not, sir. Apples and Apples, unless the two have EXACTLY the same layout:

TCups - hat off - you are right!!

Also Daini reactor are all inline
 
Mar24-11, 12:14 AM   #974
 
Quote by AntonL View Post
We are comparing apples with pears!

The radiation map (the pink one) is from Fukushima Daini NPS
Although I cannot read Japanese I can read the numbers on the reactors
which compares with the Daini plant

also satellite photo confirms this look at the arrangement of access roads.
Sorry to have to disagree, again, Anton. Did I mention I am a radiologist by trade and make my living by looking at pictures and that I am pretty good with spatial relationships and extracting 3D info from 2D images? Daini is not a match. Daiachi (spelling?) is.

 
Mar24-11, 12:16 AM   #975
 
Quote by AntonL View Post
TCups - hat off - you are right!!

Also Daini reactor are all inline
Now go back and match the radiation readings to the debris fields we spent so much time on earlier. . .

I must get some sleep.
 
Mar24-11, 12:19 AM   #976
 
Quote by TCups View Post
Now go back and match the radiation readings to the debris fields we spent so much time on earlier. . .

I must get some sleep.
So should I but you guys are so loud your keeping me awake.
 
Mar24-11, 12:52 AM   #977
 
Surface winds are due to temporarily turn onshore from the northeast @ the 25th
 
Mar24-11, 01:46 AM   #978
 
http://www.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/asiapc...ex.html?hpt=C1

Nishiyama:
"The "vapor" rising near the No. 1 reactor at the plant is "only natural" and not a cause for alarm, he said, especially since water is now in that unit's nuclear spent fuel pool"

-------
My comment: hmmmm, at least they are now telling us that #1 SFP is SERIOUS hot too.... Has it been dry?
If I read the comment squarely, I could argue that he implies that before todays dousing, the pool was dry....
 
Mar24-11, 02:15 AM   #979
 
2 nuclear plant workers sent to hospital
Japan's nuclear safety agency says 2 workers at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant were taken to hospital on Thursday after being exposed to high-level radiation at the plant.

The agency says the workers' feet were accidentally exposed to 170 to 180 millisieverts of radiation while they were working in the turbine building of the Number 3 reactor.

A third worker was also exposed to radiation but apparently did not require treatment.
Thursday, March 24, 2011 15:43 +0900 (JST)
http://www3.nhk.or.jp/daily/english/24_39.html
 
Mar24-11, 02:18 AM   #980
 
The austrian news service orf.at reports

Quote by The Austrian news service orf.at reports
Die Arbeiten im Atomkraftwerk Fukushima I gehen nur langsam voran: Immer wieder müssen Arbeiter abgezogen werden, weil die radioaktive Strahlung zu hoch wird. „Nach gegenwärtiger Lage dürfen wir nicht zu optimistisch sein“, sagte Regierungssprecher Yukio Edano am Donnerstag auf einer Pressekonferenz in Tokio. Ausgerechnet die Kühlung, die langsam Wirkung zeigt, könnte zum neuen Problem werden.
Translated means:
The work at the nuclear power plant Fukushima I going slowly: Time and again, workers must be withdrawn because the radiation is too high. "According to current situation we must not be too optimistic, " said government spokesman Yukio Edano on Thursday at a press conference in Tokyo. Of all the cooling, showing slow action might become a new problem.

Is he referring to salt problem addressed earlier - and what does "we must not be too optimistic" mean?
 
Mar24-11, 02:20 AM   #981
 
Quote by jensjakob View Post
2 nuclear plant workers sent to hospital
Japan's nuclear safety agency says 2 workers at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant were taken to hospital on Thursday after being exposed to high-level radiation at the plant.

The agency says the workers' feet were accidentally exposed to 170 to 180 millisieverts of radiation while they were working in the turbine building of the Number 3 reactor.

A third worker was also exposed to radiation but apparently did not require treatment.
Thursday, March 24, 2011 15:43 +0900 (JST)
http://www3.nhk.or.jp/daily/english/24_39.html
Jens - that would be the building in front of Unit 3 with the holes in the roof (and with radioactive debris now on its floor?).

http://s306.photobucket.com/albums/n...g%26newest%3D1
 
Mar24-11, 03:43 AM   #982
 
Quote by TCups View Post
Jens - that would be the building in front of Unit 3 with the holes in the roof (and with radioactive debris now on its floor?).

http://s306.photobucket.com/albums/n...g%26newest%3D1
NHK reported the workers were in the basement of #3, whatever that means.
 
Mar24-11, 03:52 AM   #983
 
Lots of information was release regarding the situation at the plant this morning (GMT)
I'll try to get a proper translation....

The Underground of the turbine room linked to the unit 3 was flooded with 30 cm watter , the worker doing stuff there related to pump had there feet in the watter "radioactive" those were the worker rushed to the hospital (radiation exposure about 180 mSv)

edited
 
Mar24-11, 04:43 AM   #984
 
Ok, found this quote on BBC:
""Although they wore protective clothing, the contaminated water seeped in and their legs were exposed to radiation," said a spokesman."
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-pacific-12845304
 
Mar24-11, 04:49 AM   #985
 
Quote by jensjakob View Post
How can ANYONE go into a building with water in the basement below a reactor and SFP being cooled by dousing - and not think "WOW - bad idea, bad idea"?

Where are the disaster-management in this NPP?

I could accept it if they were working in the basement (high risk), and a pipe rupture - that would be an accident - but if the water was there allready - then I read this setup as a quite bad example of disaster management...
An idea that might even be worse is waiting too long to get the situation under control. I have a feeling the workers were aware that they were taking risks, but were weighing the consequences of further delays. There have been a lot of delays. Delays at this point are not good.

P.S. An NHK spokesman even implied the workers might not be wearing the safety equipment properly, but I doubt that.
 
Mar24-11, 05:37 AM   #986
 
Well, my personal FEELING is that there is what is being said which (tries to) give the impression that some things are under control, like the personnel management concerning radiations. I'm not so confident with this, but only time will tell the true story and the reality behind this. There are always the words and the numbers on one side, and on the other side there is the "real thing". My work as an environmental expert for court and environmental management teached me that sometimes the two ones fit together. Sometimes.

We live more and more in a world of words, numbers and images, but reality still continue to exist and PREVAIL. With time, the two tend to better fit though. We are all here trying to fit words, numbers and images on a reality which we are not experiencing on the ground (fortunately for us) and this is always a tricky game (especially when these words, numbers and images are not from us but from other people!), we have to recognize the limit of this, even if obvioulsy we still can get a feeling of what's going on.

This moment, like every disaster, is a big come back to reality in a world where virtuality or "augmented reality" (hummmm!) seemed to replace the true experience of reality.

By the way, but i won't go further with this here, the guy talking in the CNN interview has a point of view which is typical of this tendency, as his conclusions is basically that the japanese would rather build psychiatric hospital than a sarcophagus to deal with the health consequences of the accident (to summarize it in a few words!). This is a strange way of dealing with reality. Military troops are always subject to psychic trauma of course but I'm not sure this trauma would be the same if they were fighting moving pixels with electronic weapons actioned by a keyboard/joypad in front of a 30 inch flat screen... This is a strange way of trying to describe the reality, yes.
 
New Reply

Tags
japan, nuclear
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Japan Earthquake: nuclear plants
Thread Forum Replies
8.9 earthquake in Japan: tsunami warnings Current Events 671
New Nuclear Plants Nuclear Engineering 9
Gen IV Nuclear Plants Nuclear Engineering 10
New Nuclear Plants Nuclear Engineering 14
Astronomer Predicts Major Earthquake for Japan General Discussion 65