Register to reply 
3D Vector Inconsistency 
Share this thread: 
#1
May2111, 10:46 AM

P: 179

If I put these 2 lines in to wolframalpha.com it comes up with a solution
x = 1 + 2t , y = 2 – t , z = t ; x = 2 – s , y = 3 + 3s , z = 1 + 4s t = 8/5 and s = 1/5 using equations for x & y Solution; x = 11/5 y = 18/5 z = 9/5 But the z values do not match so how can these lines intersect ? Thanks for your input 


#2
May2111, 11:20 AM

Mentor
P: 21,397

Setting the x, y, and z values equal, you get the system of equations
1 + 2t = 2  s 2  t = 3 + 3s t = 1 + 4s Moving the variables to one side gives this system s + 2t = 3 3s + t = 1 4s  t = 1 Using matrix methods, this turns out to be an inconsistent system, meaning that the two lines don't intersect. Are you sure that the equations you entered into wolframalpha are the same as you posted? 


#3
May2111, 11:41 AM

P: 179

Yes I checked the data several times
Wolframalpha's solution seems to ignore that z=t which gives a different value than the 9/5 from z=1+4s Perhaps there is some subtle interpretation they are making ? The lines appear skew to me Thanks for the comments 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Ever catch an inconsistency in your own thoughts?  General Discussion  22  
Inconsistency in textbooks  General Math  6  
Einstein's Inconsistency?  Special & General Relativity  70  
Godel and Inconsistency  Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics  3 