Throwing a ball in a moving train


by nobelium102
Tags: ball, moving, throwing, train
nobelium102
nobelium102 is offline
#1
Jul30-11, 03:27 PM
P: 66
If you throw a tennis ball straight up in a moving train, the ball will drop back down on the same spot so you can catch it
right?
Does this happen because i am in a closed space where the air is still?
What would happen if i went on top of the train (so i guess the roof of the train) and did the same experiment?
will the ball be flown backward because of the wind?
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
Information storage for the next generation of plastic computers
Scientists capture ultrafast snapshots of light-driven superconductivity
Progress in the fight against quantum dissipation
xts
xts is offline
#2
Jul30-11, 03:42 PM
P: 882
Quote Quote by nobelium102 View Post
If you throw a tennis ball straight up in a moving train, the ball will drop back down on the same spot so you can catch it
right?
Does this happen because i am in a closed space where the air is still?
Right!
What would happen if i went on top of the train (so i guess the roof of the train) and did the same experiment?
will the ball be flown backward because of the wind?
You need not to risk that much. Just take your tennis ball and go to backyard of your house during stormy wind to see what happens.
Ryan_m_b
Ryan_m_b is online now
#3
Jul30-11, 03:48 PM
Mentor
Ryan_m_b's Avatar
P: 5,340
Remember that it's not just the train travelling at 80mph! You, the ball and the air in the carriage all have the same velocity. The wind outside the train is the same wind resistance that a ball would feel if you fired it from standing to 80mph.

kevinfrankly
kevinfrankly is offline
#4
Aug4-11, 02:56 AM
P: 17

Throwing a ball in a moving train


wind => external force
jeannagui
jeannagui is offline
#5
Aug4-11, 06:00 AM
P: 10
you don't need a moving train to see if a ball moves with wind!
Actualy the question would be why didn the ball remain in its place in space when you threw it in the air and didn go bakward? in fact, you re stick to the train but it's not? why didn it loose the train speed when not being attached to it? well that's cz it's got some kinetik energie wich let it move with nearly same speed! and that's why(ignoring wind) u'll get the same results at the top of the train


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Throwing a ball into the air Introductory Physics Homework 50
Throwing ball out of a moving car Introductory Physics Homework 10
Ball dropped from a moving train General Physics 4
a cannon ball and a moving train. General Physics 8
Thrown Ball on Moving Train Introductory Physics Homework 1