Register to reply

Why can you blow glass and not other materials?

by waltl
Tags: blow, glass, materials
Share this thread:
waltl
#1
Sep14-11, 11:20 AM
P: 3
Hi. Often, when I am a tour guide at the Museum of Glass, Tacoma,WA. glassblowing shop. I get a question for which I don't have a definitive answer. I thought someone might know
What is special about glass that enables it to be formed by blowing? Which forces are the major factors in holding the bubble together and allows it to be deformed in an inelastically.
How is it different from other materials wax, steel, ceramics, wood, etc which do not have this ability? with respect to the blowing phenomena.
Phys.Org News Partner Engineering news on Phys.org
Lawsuits challenge US drone, model aircraft rules
CU-Boulder leads international unmanned aircraft testing event at Pawnee Grassland
Gesture-controlled, autonomous vehicles may be valuable helpers in logistics and trans-shipment centers
spartanx
#2
Sep14-11, 11:57 AM
P: 2
u can blow glass when it is in the molten state ..it is light and relatively less dense.
Remember that glass is a super cooled liquid.
enigma
#3
Sep14-11, 12:13 PM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
enigma's Avatar
P: 1,817
Just shooting from the hip here, but I would guess it has to do with the relatively low melting point of glass combined with the ductility of the molten material.

I guess you could, in theory, blow a metal, but they're probably too hot to get close enough to, along with probably too dense to be able to do much with human lungs.

Again, I'm not any sort of expert in the matter - just brainstorming.

spartanx
#4
Sep14-11, 12:21 PM
P: 2
Why can you blow glass and not other materials?

what i meant to say was that when it is in the sort of molten state ..it is like a deformable plastic and yet dense enough to hold the air blown inside.The air bubble does not diffuse into the material.
I heard this explanation on national geographic during one of the programs they covered regarding Ireland history and thier glass factories.

i'm no expert either but confident of the statement as i got to observe an expert.
Dr_Zinj
#5
Sep14-11, 01:13 PM
P: 24
Anything you see that can be injection molded can basically be blown just like molten glass; especially if it has a viscosity similar to glass. That pretty much limits it to glass, plastics, some ceramics, and some metals. And really only glass or plastics are formable under lung pressure alone.
uby
#6
Sep15-11, 11:05 AM
P: 176
The glass is not molten when it is being blown (molten refers to the formation of a liquid, liquids cannot hold shape). It is still a solid, just in what's called a supercooled state. The liquid's atomic structure is locked in place within the solid from when it was originally taken from the molten state and cast/extruded to shape, but the temperature of glassblowing is not sufficient to allow for atomic rearrangement into the equilibrium solid crystal structure (devitrification).

Silica-based glasses are covalent network oxides, and as such they have low solubility for molecular oxygen as compared to other ceramic oxides which have ionic bonding that can readily incorporate oxygen as O(2-) in its crystal structure. This is why you can perform glassblowing with air.

In theory, you can plastically deform lots of materials using applied inert gas pressures, but the temperatures and pressure needed wouldn't make it practical in most cases.
Borek
#7
Sep15-11, 11:26 AM
Admin
Borek's Avatar
P: 23,546
I would say it is a (coincidental) combination of viscosity and surface tension, that just happen to have correct values in the temperatures that are easy to achieve.

Coincidental in the sense that it just happens this particular material has them, for sure it can be explained in terms of physicochemical properties of the compounds present, there are probably other materials with similar properties (although I think we would classify them as glass as well, just because they would behave in a similar way).

Or, to put it differently - of many materials that we can test, this one has a correct combination of viscosity and surface tension at elevated temperatures, so it was selected for blowing thousands years ago.
0xDEADBEEF
#8
Sep22-11, 02:27 PM
P: 824
Another factor that makes glass blowing possible, the low thermal conductivity, which is important so you can selectively melt parts of the glassware. Finally glass has amazing properties: it is transparent, very hard and chemically extremely stable, making it preferable over other materials that might work -- like tar.
Dbrickner
#9
Sep28-11, 12:51 AM
P: 6
This group was in the news awhile back.

http://newenergyandfuel.com/http:/ne...-metal-shapes/

They have a fancy metal with properties that allow it to be blown at low temp's and pressures. Mechanically blown though, not by lung pressure.
pukb
#10
Oct22-11, 08:47 AM
P: 92
I think it is the transition temperature which matters, Transition temperature is the the temperature at which glass is in semi solid state as what is seen in some polymers. Metals do not have transition temperature because they have a definite melting point.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Using snell's law, observations thru a glass of water & glass of air Introductory Physics Homework 2
Plastics and glass - materials question Materials & Chemical Engineering 0
Transparency of water, glass and plastic materials General Physics 10
Need a paper published in Glass Technology-European J of Glass Science and Tec 2009 Materials & Chemical Engineering 0