Register to reply 
Water in bucket and GR 
Share this thread: 
#1
Jan2012, 05:34 PM

P: 287

I am reading about rotating water in bucket  about Mach's principle. But, how general relativity explains this bucket.
1. Let us say, that bucket with water is the only object in universe. What GR says. 2. Let us say that one star in distance is in this universe. How rotating water "know" that it rotates and so curves it surface. 3. etc. 


#2
Jan2012, 06:00 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 5,060

1) Same as Newton. Rotation is absolute.
2) Same as Newton. GR does not incorporate a naive Mach principle. However, there is a sense in which is Machian. In Newtonian theory, the question of what frames are inertial is somehow God given. In GR, the totality of matter influences what frames are inertial, and in a closed universe, completely determines what frames are inertial. It is presumably beyond you, but the following discusses different formulations of Mach's Principle and discusses how at least one form of it is encompassed in GR: http://arxiv.org/abs/1007.3368 


#3
Jan2012, 06:12 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
P: 7,634

1) Gr says that the surface of the water curves if it rotates, and doesn't curve if it doesn't. It doesn't particularly matter whether the bucket is alone in the universe or not. Assuming an asymptotically flat spacetime (you need to specify this as well as the matter distribution), you can write down solutions where the bucket's surface curves, and ascribe rotation to these solutions and you can write down solutions where the bucket's surface doesn't curve, and ascribe no rotation to those solutions, regardless of the rest of the universe,
2) This may or may not be compatible with a specific interpretation of Mach's principle, depending exactly on what you interpret Mach's principle to mean. It seems to be incompatible with the average person's interpretation of the principle from my observations but not necessarily incompatible with all possible intepretations of the principle. 


#4
Jan2012, 09:03 PM

P: 1,555

Water in bucket and GR



#5
Jan2012, 10:21 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 5,060




#6
Jan2112, 02:30 AM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 9,454

If you could rotate a bucket of water in an 'empty' [Minkowski] universe, the results might be surprising.



#7
Jan2112, 02:56 AM

P: 287

It is also a question why it is easier to find relativity in linear direction than in circular direction!!! 


#8
Jan2112, 03:01 AM

P: 287

What was Einstein's opinion about this? It seems to me, that if we remove all from universe, there no spacetime remains  according to difeomorphism and general covariance. There are claims that gravitational waves defines empty space  but they need one rest inertial sistem, but if we remove all matter, there is not reference rest inertial system... 


#9
Jan2212, 01:13 AM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
P: 7,634

While we can't actual perform the experiment, we CAN easily analyze the situation to see what special and/or general relativity predicts. The short version is that SR and GR predict "nothing surprising". So the way I see it is that we are currently left with no theoretical and no experimental support for any such surprises. It's possible that some other theory will someday give theoretical support for "suprises", but that theory won't be SR or GR. If you call the idea that there are "suprising" results in this circumstance "Mach's principle" (this isnt universally accepted, but it seems common, though I might add it seems more common on PF than it does in the literature), then we can say that SR and GR are "not Machian". Now we haven't disproved this particular interpretation of Mach's principle, the problem with the principle as stated is that it can't be disproved in any experiment we can actually perform, putting it into the realm of philosophy. But what we can say is that SR and GR are not "Machian" in this particular sense. 


#10
Jan2212, 06:59 AM

P: 287

Maybe it is a cause because relativistically the bucket cannot rotate as a rigid body, thus we can always decipher zero position? 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Whirling a bucket full of water  Classical Physics  10  
Water Bucket problem  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
Bucket of water?  General Discussion  4  
Water flowing in and out of a bucket  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Falling bucket of water  Classical Physics  18 