Mathematical appraisal of Pascal's Wager


by 2AlphaMales?!
Tags: appraisal, mathematical, pascal, wager
2AlphaMales?!
2AlphaMales?! is offline
#1
Jul5-12, 02:57 PM
P: 14
For those who aren't familiar with it, Pascal's Wager, in it's bluntest manifestation, is the idea that being religious (Christian or Muslim) is worth any finite cost, because the possible consequence (eternal damnation) of not being religious is of infinite magnitude.

There are several problems with Pascal's Wager although they're...conversational, and it's potency remains for many.

Is it possible to define the failings (or, indeed, the irrefutable truths) of Pascal's wager in terms of mathematics? My knowledge of maths is limited to say the least, but I'm thinking in terms of ill defined operands/independant variables as negating the valididty of the finite VS infinite quandry...perhaps.

On th other hand, perhaps the "infinite" component of the equation really does render all opposing factors inefectual - again, my maths is poor so I'm not sure of the mathematical definition of infinity, if, indeed, it is a mathematical concept at all and not a philosophical one.

Any thoughts about this would be very welcome, although I should probably remind that one need remain strictly academic in appraisal of this issue so as not to get into theism VS atheism arguments which could fall foul of the forum rules...I think : /...this topic is just about the mathematical realities of Pascal's Wager, not asserting that there is god or not.
Phys.Org News Partner Mathematics news on Phys.org
Researchers help Boston Marathon organizers plan for 2014 race
'Math detective' analyzes odds for suspicious lottery wins
Pseudo-mathematics and financial charlatanism
SteveL27
SteveL27 is offline
#2
Jul5-12, 03:06 PM
P: 799
Quote Quote by 2AlphaMales?! View Post
For those who aren't familiar with it, Pascal's Wager, in it's bluntest manifestation, is the idea that being religious (Christian or Muslim) is worth any finite cost, because the possible consequence (eternal damnation) of not being religious is of infinite magnitude.

There are several problems with Pascal's Wager although they're...conversational, and it's potency remains for many.

Is it possible to define the failings (or, indeed, the irrefutable truths) of Pascal's wager in terms of mathematics? My knowledge of maths is limited to say the least, but I'm thinking in terms of ill defined operands/independant variables as negating the valididty of the finite VS infinite quandry...perhaps.

On th other hand, perhaps the "infinite" component of the equation really does render all opposing factors inefectual - again, my maths is poor so I'm not sure of the mathematical definition of infinity, if, indeed, it is a mathematical concept at all and not a philosophical one.

Any thoughts about this would be very welcome, although I should probably remind that one need remain strictly academic in appraisal of this issue so as not to get into theism VS atheism arguments which could fall foul of the forum rules...I think : /...this topic is just about the mathematical realities of Pascal's Wager, not asserting that there is god or not.
By the same logic, you don't want to piss off the flying spaghetti monster.
micromass
micromass is online now
#3
Jul5-12, 03:10 PM
Mentor
micromass's Avatar
P: 16,543
Religious debates are not allowed on this forum.

If you're interested in questions like this, then you should probably research game theory a bit.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Pascal law Classical Physics 2
Pascal: How to use floor function in Pascal? Programming & Computer Science 4
Pascal's Law Introductory Physics Homework 0
Pascal's Wager General Discussion 6
please help pascal Computing & Technology 1