Register to reply 
Paradoxical definition of the Derivative 
Share this thread: 
#1
Feb2405, 08:39 AM

P: 181

A common definition I've read: A derivative of a arbitrary function is the change in one given instant.
It's hard to think about it. I mean, movement, which is change of position cannot be defined for zero time. Has Zeros paradox something to do with this? If I don't misstaken, Zeros paradox is about the sum of infinity many parts can be finite. Very confusing... 


#2
Feb2405, 08:54 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 9,396

Or it could be that your "common definition" is just an illustrative explanation and not acutally a rigorous definition at all.



#3
Feb2405, 09:50 AM

P: 181

Ahh. I see. But how does Zenos paradox relate?



#4
Feb2405, 11:04 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 12,016

Paradoxical definition of the Derivative
Note that in the "ordinary" interpretation of Zeno's paradox, that paradox is RESOLVED by noting the fact that, say, an infinite number of terms may add up to something finite. 


#5
Feb2405, 12:09 PM

Math
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 39,345

That's exactly WHY we need a rigorous definition for the derivative!
In fact, that's exactly what led Newton to develop the calculus! He wanted to show that the gravitational force was dependent on the distance from the mass (and, of course, the acceleration due to that force). But the distance could (in theory anyway) measured at any instant while neither speed nor acceleration could, without calculus, be DEFINED at a given instant. The fact that "speed at a given instant" (and, therefore "acceleration at a given instant") could not even be defined was really Zeno's point and the calculus was a way to do that. Arildno, Zeno had several different "paradoxes". You, I think, are thinking of the one about "You can't cross this distance because you would first have to cross 1/2 of it, then 1/4 of it, then 1/8 of it, etc." danne89 was probably think of the "arrow" paradox: "At any given instant, the arrow is AT a specific point and therefore, not moving! Since it is not moving at any given instant, it can't be moving at all." 


#6
Feb2405, 03:11 PM

P: 181

Nice. But as I've heard it, Newton's definiton wasn't rigorous.



#7
Feb2405, 04:01 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 11,895

Not in the terms of modern analysis.At that time,IT WAS RIGUROUS ENOUGH TO DELIVER THE CORRECT THEORETICAL RESULTS...Namely explaing the laws of Kepler.
Daniel. 


#8
Feb2405, 04:13 PM

P: 181

So todays rigurous definition may turne out to be nonexact tomorrow, when new physic demands avaible?



#9
Feb2405, 04:45 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 11,895

Daniel. 


#10
Feb2405, 10:13 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 9,453

the derivative is not , even in a roiugh intuitve sense, the change of the function in zero time. rather it is an approximation to the change of the function in UNIT time.
to compute by extrapolation the change of the function in unit time, you take the change in time delta(t) and divide that change by delta(t). if delta(t) is very small, this result will extrapolate the change over a small interval to a change over a unit time interval. we do this for a sequence of smaller and smaller injtervals, and then try to guess what number these results are tending toward. 


#11
Feb2505, 04:55 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 9,396

No, today's rigorous definitions are rigorious definitions within th current rigorous definition of "rigorous definition". Newton's weren't rigorous at the time. But this is a sign of the way the philosophy of mathematics has changed. What constituted a proof to Gauss, Euler, and even Galois often wouldn't pass muster in modern mathematics. That isn't to say their proofs were incorrect, but that there were some gaps, small ones, that they glossed over, or ignored.



#12
Feb2505, 05:49 AM

P: 181

Conclusion: I'll look it up in a more rigurous book...



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Derivative using the definition  Calculus & Beyond Homework  16  
Definition of Derivative  Calculus & Beyond Homework  2  
Derivative Definition...  Calculus & Beyond Homework  2  
Use definition of derivative  Calculus  3  
Definition of a derivative  Introductory Physics Homework  2 