Register to reply 
Moment of Inertia Problem 
Share this thread: 
#1
Nov2412, 11:04 AM

P: 147

Here's a derviation from HyperPhysics:
He says: [tex]dV=πy^{2}dz[/tex] However, if we're finding the surface area of the sphere: [tex]dA=2πRdz≠2πydz[/tex] If we cannot use [tex]dA=2πydz[/tex], how come [tex]dV=πy^{2}dz[/tex] is still applicable? 


#2
Nov2412, 11:31 AM

Mentor
P: 41,457

What does finding the surface area of the sphere have to do with this? 


#3
Nov2412, 12:11 PM

P: 147

If I want to find the MoI of a hollow sphere. Based on the same assumptions [tex]dA=2πydz[/tex], it should be like that, but it's not . I'm trying to calculate the MoIs of some hollow objects, not sure what kind of area formula I should use. 


#4
Nov2412, 02:49 PM

Mentor
P: 41,457

Moment of Inertia Problem



#5
Nov3012, 09:05 AM

P: 147

As z tends to zero, that particular segment of a sphere should tend toward a segment of a cone. And for a cone, when z tends to zero [tex]A→2πrz[/tex] The difference between the conical area and the area of a cylinder wrapped around it should decrease until they are equal when z tends to zero. 


#6
Nov3012, 09:19 AM

Mentor
P: 41,457




#7
Nov3012, 09:47 AM

P: 362

Is this for the moment of inertia of a sphere?



#9
Nov3012, 09:56 AM

P: 362

I'm pretty sure it's for a full sphere, that dI there represents the moment of inertia of a single disk at height z, and then he integrates from the bottom to the top.



#10
Nov3012, 10:01 AM

Mentor
P: 41,457




#12
Dec212, 07:11 AM

Mentor
P: 41,457

The volume is the area times thickness: dV = area * dz = πr^{2}dz If we vary the radius by dr, we get: dV = π(r + dr)^{2}dz = π(r^{2} + 2rdr + dr^{2})dz dV = πr^{2}dz + The higher order differentials can be ignored. 


#13
Dec212, 07:47 AM

P: 147

What if the external area is perimeter times thickness: dA = perimeter * dz =2πrdz Varying the radius by dr, we get: dA = 2π(r+dr)dz =(2πr+2πdr)dz = 2πrdz + 


#14
Dec212, 07:56 AM

Mentor
P: 41,457




#15
Dec212, 09:37 AM

P: 147

but then volume can also be considered area times some funny ratio and not just the vertical height dz 


#16
Dec212, 09:55 AM

Mentor
P: 41,457




#17
Dec212, 10:29 AM

P: 147

but for external area, you said we must account for the slant, I used (r + dr), doesn't that do the job? I'm afriad my mathematical understanding is really sketchy. 


#18
Dec212, 11:34 AM

Engineering
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 7,157

Of course you can use trig and get the length in terms of an angle, if you want. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Another moment of inertia problem. help!  Introductory Physics Homework  7  
Moment of inertia problem...please help  Introductory Physics Homework  6  
Moment of inertia problem  Introductory Physics Homework  8  
Moment of Inertia problem  Classical Physics  3  
What are moment of inertia, mass moment of inertia, and radius of gyration?  Introductory Physics Homework  1 