Register to reply 
Approach To Critical  1/M and Penultimate Method 
Share this thread: 
#1
Feb2013, 07:42 PM

P: 5

Can someone explain to me the basic process involved in an approach to critical with a nuclear reactor. I understand that you basically start with the rods all the way in and bring them out, while taking counts  waiting for them to stabilize. I understand with the penultimate method, you change the control rod position and take count rates, and then take the ratio of the count rates and extrapolate to the xaxis with each measurement in order to determine the critical point, however I'm confused as to how the 1/M method works to find the critical position.
Thanks, Derek 


#2
Feb2113, 12:24 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 3,739

It's a beautifully simple graphical method. Plot rod position (or dilution) on Ordinate 1/m on Abscissa Since multiplication is approaching infinity as you approach criticality, 1/m is approaching zero  but you don't multidecade log graph paper to see it. Extrapolate your slope to intersect ordinate and you have an estimate. Closer you get, the better your estimate. After you do one it's second nature. Probably i answered the wrong question, though. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Which approach is nicer? UK MEI approach? American approach?  Academic Guidance  0  
Volume, washer method another approach  Calculus  0  
Physics summer placements for penultimate year undergrad?  Career Guidance  0  
Sub Critical, critical and supercritical  Question  High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics  0 