Register to reply 
Prove that the set of those $c$ is countable 
Share this thread: 
#1
Apr2713, 12:35 PM

P: 12

The **mean values theorem** says that there exists a $c∈(u,v)$ such that $$f(v)f(u)=f′(c)(vu)$$ My question is: Assume that $u$ is a root of $f$, hence we obtain $$f(v)=f′(c)(vu)$$ Assume that $f$ is a nonzero analytic function in the whole real line. My interest is about the real $c∈(u,v)$. I believe that the set of those $c$ is contable, otherwise we conclud that $f′(c)$ is constant (in an open set containing $c$) since $v$ is a constant and hence $f$ is identically zero. Also, I think that the set of those $c$ is countable (for analytic functions) but I am not able to prove that.



#2
Apr2713, 01:18 PM

P: 181

For all c that satisfy that equation, [itex] f'(c)(vu)f(v)=0 [/itex]. The LHS is an analytic function in c (v and u are constant) and is not identically zero unless f is linear. That any nonzero analytic function has countable zeroes is well known. (http://planetmath.org/ZeroesOfAnalyt...onsAreIsolated is a proof for complex functions, but the idea is the same)
Edit: My link only proves that the zeroes are isolated. Here is how you would show that the set of zeroes in countable: Let a be a zero. If all other zeroes are separated from a by at least ε, let q be a rational number which is no more than ε/3 away from a. Each rational number can be associated with a zero in this way. The cardinality of the set of zeroes is the same as for this set of rational numbers and rational numbers are countable. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Prove that if X is countable and a is in X then X \{a} is countable.  Calculus & Beyond Homework  6  
Topology  prove that X has a countable base  Calculus & Beyond Homework  8  
Prove N X N is countable and provide a bijective function  Calculus & Beyond Homework  5  
Prove is countable  Calculus & Beyond Homework  4  
Prove algebraic numbers are countable  Calculus & Beyond Homework  2 