The ratio of the gravitational force between electron and protonby Richard Ros Tags: electron, force, gravitational, proton, ratio 

#1
Sep1013, 10:22 AM

P: 17

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
Some of the earliest atomic models held that the orbital velocity of an electron in an atom could be correlated with the radius of the atom. If the radius of the hydrogen atom is 10^−10 m and the electrostatic force is responsible for the circular motion of the electron, what is the ratio of the gravitational force between electron and proton to the electrostatic force? How does this ratio change if the radius of the atom is doubled? Explain {Answer: Fg/Fe = 4.39 x 1040}. 2. Relevant equations fe = (1/4πε0)*(q^2/r^2) fg = G m^2/r^2 3. The attempt at a solution The answer says Fg/Fe, so I divided fg/fe to get (Gm^2)/((9*10^9)q^2). I tried every different way possible but cannot manage to get the correct answer. Can anyone help me solve this problem, I've been stuck for a long time. I preferred you show me how to do it and how you got to the final answer. 



#2
Sep1013, 10:28 AM

P: 43

What are you using as the masses? One of them would be the mass of a proton; the other would be the mass of an electron.




#3
Sep1013, 11:01 AM

P: 17

Maybe my formula is wrong . Do you think this formula would be correct? G*me*mp/(9*10^9 n m^2/c^2)*q1*q2?




#4
Sep1013, 11:10 AM

P: 17

The ratio of the gravitational force between electron and proton
Oh never mind. I got the answer. How does the ratio change if radius if atom is doubled?




#5
Sep1013, 11:14 AM

P: 43

What do you think  does it look like the formula depends on the radius?




#6
Sep1013, 11:26 AM

P: 17

Since the radius isn't included in the formula. I'm assuming it doesn't matter?




#7
Sep1013, 11:28 AM

P: 43

Yep.




#8
Sep1013, 11:51 AM

P: 17

Thanks a lot. I got more homework questions if you're willing to help. http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=709611



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Proton:Electron mass ratio  General Physics  1  
magnitude of the gravitational force of attraction between the proton & electron  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Electron/Proton mass ratio  Quantum Physics  5  
Chargetomass ratio of electron/proton  Introductory Physics Homework  0  
Proton electron mass ratio  General Physics  3 