Register to reply 
Why does bringing N 1orbital atoms together yield N levels? 
Share this thread: 
#1
Oct313, 10:00 PM

P: 7

A common example of this is that when bringing N hydrogen atoms together into a ring. Far apart, assume each electron exists in the 1s state. As we bring them together, instead of each electron staying at the original 1s level, or all of them changing by the same amount, the 1s level fans out into N.
For the case of 2 atoms, I can understand this as bonding or antibonding of the atoms. i.e., do the wavefunctions add between the protons, meaning each electron can share in the potential of both protons (bonding) or do the wavefunctions destructively interfere between the protons (antibonding). With 3 atoms, I can't find 3 levels. Assuming Gaussian shaped wavefunctions, note that the sign of each wavefunction between any two atoms defines the wavefunction on the rest of the ring. Since the signs of the wavefunction are independent, there should be 2^3=8 possibilities since each wavefunction can be + or . Yet, there are really only 2 energetically distinct arrangements that I see: all have the same sign (two cases) or 2 of 3 have the same sign (2*(3 choose 2)), to account for both sign cases). So I get 3 atoms yield 2 levels. Can somebody shed light on what I've done incorrectly? Or is 3 too small to work correctly? Is there an argument about the shape of the orbitals I've neglected? Thank you. 


#2
Oct413, 12:56 AM

Homework
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 13,135

Hint: Pauli exclusion principle.



#3
Oct413, 01:19 AM

Sci Advisor
P: 3,633

In the case of a ring with N atoms, you get (N+1)/2 distinct energy levels. 


#4
Oct413, 09:42 PM

P: 7

Why does bringing N 1orbital atoms together yield N levels?
Also, the (N+1)/2 argument seems contrary to what I remember reading in Kittel: N atoms yield N levels. I assumed the levels were distinct. Thanks for your replies, please follow up! 


#5
Oct413, 11:52 PM

Homework
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 13,135

Lets restrict talk to energy eigenstates of the system then.
When you bring a lot of atoms together, the electronelectron interactions mean that there is no longer a welldefined 1s state. The new system has different energy levels. The old 1s state is a superposition of the new system ... and the electrons decay into the new energy levels creating the new ground state. You can model this by putting two finite square wells at different distances from each other and look what happens to the first few bound states when they are different distances apart. Also start with just one square well, with one particle, and "switch on" a second one. Another way of thinking about it: no two electrons in the universe are ever in exactly the same discrete state  its just that the energy levels for farseparated wells are so very similar our instruments cannot tell the difference. When the wells get closer, their interactions force the states to split and you can see the difference. Whatever  once the combined system has formed, the inital 1s states no longer exist and their energy levels may even be forbidden. When lots of atoms are close together, like in a solid, the energy levels merge to form bands. Note: I was wondering if DrDu was thinking of molecular energy or, maybe, configuration states. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Energy levels in atoms  Quantum Physics  3  
Energy of atoms in different levels  Advanced Physics Homework  4  
Molecular Orbital energy levels  Atomic, Solid State, Comp. Physics  1  
Orbital Blocks and Energy Levels  Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework  1  
Weight percent of Ge needed to yield alloy with x atoms/cm3  Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework  2 