Register to reply

Gluons, where do they come from and where do they go?

by llynne
Tags: gluons, nuclear composition
Share this thread:
llynne
#1
Jan26-14, 07:12 AM
llynne's Avatar
P: 27
I want to learn more about gluons. I understand that they are what bind the neutrons and protons into a nucleus. Do they spontaneously arise from a neutron+ positron relationship or are they related to some process?
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
Optimum inertial self-propulsion design for snowman-like nanorobot
The Quantum Cheshire Cat: Can neutrons be located at a different place than their own spin?
A transistor-like amplifier for single photons
Drakkith
#2
Jan26-14, 08:14 AM
Mentor
Drakkith's Avatar
P: 11,583
The gluons that mediate the color force between quarks are virtual gluons, as are the mesons that are responsible for binding neutrons and protons to each other in nuclei. Do you know much about virtual particles?
llynne
#3
Jan26-14, 08:39 AM
llynne's Avatar
P: 27
I should by now, but not quite fitting all together yet. I need meson too? Mesons are gluons? Both are virtual? Born of the need to mediate the Other forces?

mfb
#4
Jan26-14, 10:21 AM
Mentor
P: 11,602
Gluons, where do they come from and where do they go?

Quote Quote by llynne View Post
neutron+ positron relationship
This has nothing to do with positrons. Do you mean protons?

Yes, they "spontaneously arise". Quarks (the parts in neutrons and protons) can "emit" and "absorb" them. Note the quotation marks, as those gluons are virtual particles.

Mesons consist of a quark and an antiquark, bound by the strong interaction (so they have gluons inside). They are not gluons.
Both are virtual?
Depends on the phenomenon you want to describe.
Bill_K
#5
Jan26-14, 10:49 AM
Sci Advisor
Thanks
Bill_K's Avatar
P: 4,160
Quote Quote by mfb View Post
Depends on the phenomenon you want to describe.
Please give us an example of a situation involving a gluon that is not virtual.
mfb
#6
Jan26-14, 11:35 AM
Mentor
P: 11,602
I thought of the mesons (virtual as effective action of the strong force between hadrons, real if they fly through a particle detector).


The gluon discovery was based on 3-jet events. Those gluons were still virtual, but not so far away from the properties of real particles as far as I know.
Hawkwind
#7
Jan26-14, 12:35 PM
P: 45
Quote Quote by llynne View Post
I want to learn more about gluons. I understand that they are what bind the neutrons and protons into a nucleus. Do they spontaneously arise from a neutron+ positron relationship or are they related to some process?
Particles which carry the quantum number "colour" interact with each other by exchanging gluons ("strong force"). Proton and neutron however are neutral with respect to the colour quantum number. As already mentioned in other replys, the quarks do have colour - they are glued to each other by gluons.

The interaction which binds neutrons and protons to nuclei, is called "nuclear force". This is a residual of the strong force but electromagnetic and weak force contribute to the nuclear force, too.
Phenomenolgically, the nuclear force is often described by the exchange of mesons between the nucleons. However, in principle, the standard model of particles is the theoretical base for describing nuclear forces. However, calculations are a challenge.
ChrisVer
#8
Jan26-14, 06:30 PM
P: 756
With no offence- not knowing whether mesons are gluons or not, I doubt you'd know what virtual particles are all about. So an introductory book on elementary particles (eg Griffith's) would be recommended if you are interested in this field.
llynne
#9
Jan26-14, 08:14 PM
llynne's Avatar
P: 27
Thanks, ( oops I got proton mixed up, sorry) Is there any possibility that gluon's are a force or a field rather than a particle. The term virtual makes me want to focus on its function. If it mediates the strong force could it be interpreted in a different way?
ChrisVer
#10
Jan26-14, 08:28 PM
P: 756
Well, we've never seen gluons as we have never seen quarks in the first place... Quantum Chromodynamics that deals with the topic (of quarks/partons interacting among themselves with gluons) is just successful in allowing us to make predictions and explain what we see in experiments....
What different interpretation do you have in mind?
Drakkith
#11
Jan26-14, 09:28 PM
Mentor
Drakkith's Avatar
P: 11,583
Quote Quote by llynne View Post
Thanks, ( oops I got proton mixed up, sorry) Is there any possibility that gluon's are a force or a field rather than a particle. The term virtual makes me want to focus on its function. If it mediates the strong force could it be interpreted in a different way?
In quantum field theories, particles are interpreted as excitations of a field.
llynne
#12
Jan26-14, 09:50 PM
llynne's Avatar
P: 27
I have nothing specific in mind, these were the questions I ask myself. The experiment being the same, and the results the same has anyone argued for alternative interpretations?
Nugatory
#13
Jan27-14, 02:15 AM
Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 3,460
Quote Quote by llynne View Post
I have nothing specific in mind, these were the questions I ask myself. The experiment being the same, and the results the same has anyone argued for alternative interpretations?
An alternative to the standard model would have to do two things before it would be taken seriously. First, it would have to agree with the experiments that have already been done, at least as well as does the standard model. Second, it would have to predict something that the standard model doesn't, so that we can perform an experiment to see which one works better.

So far no one has found any such alternative.
Hawkwind
#14
Jan27-14, 02:34 AM
P: 45
Quote Quote by ChrisVer View Post
With no offence- not knowing whether mesons are gluons or not, I doubt you'd know what virtual particles are all about. So an introductory book on elementary particles (eg Griffith's) would be recommended if you are interested in this field.
Getting curious: what exactly do you think is wrong in my post?
Hawkwind
#15
Jan27-14, 03:09 AM
P: 45
Quote Quote by ChrisVer View Post
Well, we've never seen gluons as we have never seen quarks in the first place... Quantum Chromodynamics that deals with the topic (of quarks/partons interacting among themselves with gluons) is just successful in allowing us to make predictions and explain what we see in experiments....
What different interpretation do you have in mind?
For instance effective field theories like chiral pertubation theory could be a candidate:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiral_perturbation_theory

These are promising attempts to describe the low energy region of strong interactions, where QCD perturbation theory is not applicable. BTW, this theory justifies the historical attempt to describe nuclear forces by the exchange of mesons:
Quote Quote by Wiki
The theory allows the description of interactions between pions, and between pions and nucleons (or other matter fields). SU(3) ChPT can also describe interactions of kaons and eta mesons, while similar theories can be used to describe the vector mesons. Since chiral perturbation theory assumes chiral symmetry, and therefore massless quarks, it cannot be used to model interactions of the heavier quarks.
Although not being a fundamental renormalizable quantum field theory, these effective theories are used a lot by theoreticians.
Drakkith
#16
Jan27-14, 05:27 AM
Mentor
Drakkith's Avatar
P: 11,583
Quote Quote by Hawkwind View Post
Getting curious: what exactly do you think is wrong in my post?
I don't think he was referring to you in that post.
ChrisVer
#17
Jan27-14, 06:36 AM
P: 756
i was referring to OP
llynne
#18
Jan27-14, 07:29 AM
llynne's Avatar
P: 27
I'm sure I read it, not sure what remains in my brain. I read about chirality several times but if I ask myself what it is, I find nothing. But I know how my brain works. I take in information and suddenly it comes together. I found myself asking isn't what a gluon does more like a field? Not really trying to display my ignorance but for a quick way to find if that has already been worked through.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Soft gluons and colinear gluons High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics 2
8 Gluons...? High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics 6
Gluons emitting gluons General Physics 3
Why 8 gluons? High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics 14
Gluons 101 Quantum Physics 1