Register to reply 
Thermal White Noise  Johnson–Nyquist noiseby Mechatron
Tags: alternating current, batteries, battery, frequency, johnson–nyquist, noise, nyquist, signaltonoise, thermal, thermal noise, white, white noise 
Share this thread: 
#1
Feb414, 06:32 PM

P: 38

I'm trying to measure the thermal white noise generated by chemical batteries.
So far I've measured the current noise, the voltage noise (V noise) and the bandwidth (delta v). From the equation below, I'm trying to solve the equation for the frequency. The problem is that there's an exponential expression in it. But it gets worse, the frequency f is in it. http://s24.postimg.org/jbunj5z1h/Vnoise.jpg All I could come up with is to put hf/kt on one side of the equation and I'm stuck with ln (4hfr delta v / V^2). Do you have a solution? 


#2
Feb414, 07:51 PM

P: 589

Looks like you are using the wrong formula for you situation.
The formulas for thermal noise that we typically use in EE are derived from classical thermodynamics which leads to power spectral density being independent of frequency. Of course this implies that there is an infinite amount of thermal noise power in every resistor when we include all frequencies up to infinity (look up "ultraviolet catastrophe"). The resolution to this paradox (thanks to Planck) is that when frequencies get very high, classical thermodynamics breaks down because the quantization of energy (E=hv) becomes significant. Your formula is a general formula that includes quantum effects, and thus shows a dependency on frequency. 


#3
Feb414, 08:22 PM

P: 38




#4
Feb414, 08:24 PM

P: 38

Thermal White Noise  Johnson–Nyquist noise



#5
Feb414, 08:27 PM

P: 38




#6
Feb414, 08:47 PM

P: 589

Look up "Noise at very high frequencies" under http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_noise



#7
Feb414, 09:13 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,665

Dave 


#8
Feb414, 09:35 PM

P: 1,084

Color me confused. How is noise measured in Hertz?
I thought noise was expressed in power or voltage or current. The amount of power may depend on the bandwidth ( so noise voltage is sometime expressed as volts/roothertz, etc) At very high frequencies you can determine the power spectral density by using hf. Do a unit analysis of hf and you get volts, or eV. 


#9
Feb414, 09:59 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,665

uh huh
when I am dealing with thermal noise in low noise RF preamplifiers etc its always measured in K D 


#10
Feb514, 05:34 AM

P: 693

[tex] v_n^2 = 4 R k_B T \delta \nu [/tex] in order to explain the experimental results published by Johnson. This is the classical result. Notice that it is not the equation you posted. Yours has Planck's constant in it, which does not show up in classical physics. Nyquist does state the equation you use at the end of his paper to indicate what happens at very high frequencies and/or low temperatures, when the classical equipartition law no longer holds and quantum effects must be included. Of course the classical result is all that was needed to explain Johnson's data. If you take the limit as [itex]h \rightarrow 0[/itex] (or equivalently assume [itex]h f << k_B T[/itex]) in your expression then you recover the classical result. May I ask how you are doing this measurement? Are you really in a regime where it is not true that [itex]h f << k_B T[/itex]? What is the bandwidth of your measurement? etc. If you really want help (as opposed to simply looking to "in your face" people) then we need more information. For example, usually we know [itex]f[/itex] and [itex]\delta \nu[/itex] from the measurement setup, so it isn't clear why you want to solve for [itex]f[/itex] at all ... jason 


#11
Feb514, 06:12 AM

P: 693

jason 


#12
Feb514, 08:45 AM

P: 38

http://s24.postimg.org/4cqk2wbet/Vnoise.jpg 


#13
Feb514, 09:04 AM

P: 38

Please go to the following website regarding 1995 IEEE international frequency control symposium: http://tf.nist.gov/general/pdf/1133.pdf In general, it is accepted that a common DC battery only supplies a DC voltage. However, a small frequency somewhere arround 20  1000 Hz is generated, due to heat generated in the battery. I call it thermal noise, forget I ever said white noise. You can calculate the current noise with the instrument shown on page 370 (page 4 in the pdf). You can then use the current noise to calculate the voltage noise. Subsequently you use the voltage noise and the measured temperature of the battery, which would be between 300  323 Kelvin, to find the bandwidth of the frequency/noise. Finally, you can add this data into the equation in the link below, as shown on page 1: http://s24.postimg.org/4cqk2wbet/Vnoise.jpg But you see, there's a problem, you've got exp / e in the equation. By simplifying the equation, you can get y = ln (x*y 1) / w. You can solve this equation with respect to y, which represents the frequency. You end up with an expression including a product log: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i...h+respect+to+y But the problem doesn't stop here. Now you're stuck with a complex number. But really, this is a representation of a complex frequency. Concept of complex FrequencyDefinition: A type of frequency that depends on two parameters ; one is the ” σ” which controls the magnitude of the signal and the other is “w”, which controls the rotation of the signal ; is known as “complex frequency”. Makes sense, right? A complex number is just a two dimensional number: http://m.eet.com/media/1068017/lyons_pt2_3.gif So I think I just need to know, is the frequency in the equation, the frequency which you'd see on an oscillator, generated from the heat from the battery? Sincerely, Michael 


#14
Feb514, 09:29 AM

P: 589

You are using the wrong equation.
You are using equation (1) of the NIST document. You should be using equation (2) "At low frequencies Johnson noise can be approximated by...", which is the same equation that jasonRF has posted. You are dealing with kHz right, not GHz or THz. 


#15
Feb514, 10:33 AM

P: 693

[tex] \frac{h f}{k_B T} \approx 10^{10} [/tex] so surely the classical result is all that matters. Just look at the data in the paper. It is flat with frequency except at the lowest frequencies where other processes are dominating. It is not frequency dependent (edit: it is not frequency depended in the portion of frequency space you seem to care about). jason 


#16
Feb514, 10:51 AM

P: 38

The noise you put in the equation is a specific one. The frequency I want to calculate using the equation, is the same frequency I measure using an oscilloscope. Please stop saying it's not frequency dependent when the frequency is in the equation, and the frequency is what I want to calculate. In other words, it's a DC voltage signal I'm looking for, with oscillations. I've added a graph: http://s22.postimg.org/hp31y8dnl/Graph.png Here's why it's so important to me: http://www.acs.psu.edu/drussell/Demo...ion/pulses.gif The small wave represents the wave/frequency generated from heat from the battery, and the larger wave is the desired wave which I generate in a circuit. The DC voltage with oscillations is introduced into the circuit, and I believe with a feedback/loop, thing's just get worse. 


#17
Feb514, 11:12 AM

P: 589

Mechatron,
For the third time...you are using the wrong forumla. Use equation (2) in NIST document, not equation (1). We don't need to invoke Planck's constant when working with signals in the kHz range. 


#18
Feb514, 11:19 AM

P: 38

I think you need to read the paper again. They calculate the Voltage noise with an equation which consists of the bandwidth and the temperature. You can rearrange this equation and solve it with respect to frequency. Please look at the following image in the link below!!! http://s30.postimg.org/c86jz3fkh/frequency.png This frequency F, is this the frequency I would see on an oscillator? Is this the frequency generated from heat from the generator? 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Signal to noise ratio for thermal and shot noise  Introductory Physics Homework  4  
Level of johnsonNyquist noise in analog voltmeter  Electrical Engineering  3  
Resistor NyquistJohnson noise formula question  Electrical Engineering  0  
Thermal Noise (Johnson–Nyquist)  Classical Physics  5  
Johnson noise & Shot noise  Advanced Physics Homework  4 