Register to reply

Seeming paradox when squaring distance depending on units

by CuriousBanker
Tags: depending, distance, paradox, squaring, units
Share this thread:
Feb28-14, 06:42 PM
P: 115
Hello all

This is probably simple and I'm overlooking something

1 mile = 5280 feet

10% of a mile is 528 feet

528 feet squared is 278,784 feet which is 52.8 miles squared

But 0.1 miles squared is .01 miles squared

So depending on if you square it as 0.1 miles, or if you convert it to feet, then square it and convert it back, you get wildly different answers

Why is this.? Not sure why I thought of this.

Thanks in advance
Phys.Org News Partner Mathematics news on
'Moral victories' might spare you from losing again
Fair cake cutting gets its own algorithm
Effort to model Facebook yields key to famous math problem (and a prize)
Feb28-14, 06:53 PM
P: 160
528 feet squared is 278,784 feet which is 52.8 miles squared
You used the wrong conversion factor.

First of all, (528 feet)2 is not equal to 278784 feet. It is equal to 278784 feet2.

In any case, you want to convert this to a value in miles2.

Now, the conversion factor between feet2 and miles2 is not the same as the conversion factor between feet and miles, because feet2 are not the same as feet, and miles2 are not the same as miles. In fact, the conversion factor is 27878400 feet2 = 1 mile2, and if you use this correct conversion factor you will get the correct answer of 0.01 miles2.
Feb28-14, 06:54 PM
P: 392
Quote Quote by CuriousBanker View Post
528 feet squared is 278,784 feet
That should be feet squared.

##\frac{278784 ft^2}{1} \cdot \frac{(1 mi)^2}{(5280ft)^2} = 0.01 mi^2##

Register to reply

Related Discussions
Question about distance units in relativity Special & General Relativity 2
If you have force depending on distance, then how to find distance depending on time. Classical Physics 7
Is action at a distance possible as envisaged by the EPR Paradox. Quantum Physics 1502
Time Dilation Paradox (variant distance between two accelerating bodies) Special & General Relativity 8
Squaring units Advanced Physics Homework 2