Register to reply

Is empty set part of every set?

by sozener1
Tags: None
Share this thread:
sozener1
#1
Mar30-14, 06:23 PM
P: 16
you have a power set of s

represented by p(s)

and s is { x is integer and either x=<-2 or x>=5}

and you have another set d = {{-3 -2 1}, {4}, {6, 7}, {-5, 6, 9}}


when you are asked for intersection of p(s) and d in a plain maths question

am I meant to include { } the empty set as well since it is a subset of everyset???
Phys.Org News Partner Mathematics news on Phys.org
Math journal puts Rauzy fractcal image on the cover
Heat distributions help researchers to understand curved space
Professor quantifies how 'one thing leads to another'
jbriggs444
#2
Mar30-14, 06:49 PM
P: 998
Quote Quote by sozener1 View Post
you have a power set of s

represented by p(s)

and s is { x is integer and either x=<-2 or x>=5}

and you have another set d = {{-3 -2 1}, {4}, {6, 7}, {-5, 6, 9}}


when you are asked for intersection of p(s) and d in a plain maths question

am I meant to include { } the empty set as well since it is a subset of everyset???
The empty set is a subset of every set. But it is not an element of every set.

In the question above, how many elements are in set d? Of those elements, which are members of p(s)?
Vahsek
#3
Mar30-14, 06:53 PM
P: 85
Quote Quote by sozener1 View Post
you have a power set of s

represented by p(s)

and s is { x is integer and either x=<-2 or x>=5}

and you have another set d = {{-3 -2 1}, {4}, {6, 7}, {-5, 6, 9}}


when you are asked for intersection of p(s) and d in a plain maths question

am I meant to include { } the empty set as well since it is a subset of everyset???
{} is a subset of every set, so it is a subset of s. Therefore, {} is an element of p(s). However, it is clear that {} is not in set d. Therefore, {} is not an element of the intersection of p(s) and d.

Hope that answers your question.

1MileCrash
#4
Mar31-14, 01:23 AM
1MileCrash's Avatar
P: 1,304
Is empty set part of every set?

The empty set is an actual element of the power set.
The empty set is also a subset of the power set.
The empty set is not an actual element of d.
The empty set is a subset of d.

The intersection considers elements of both sets, so the empty set is not an element of the intersection. But, the empty set is a subset of the intersection.

The fact that the empty set is an element of the power set means that in addition to the empty set being a subset of the power set, the "set of the empty set" is also a subset of the power set, but this is not true for d. This is the difference.
Stephen Tashi
#5
Mar31-14, 10:12 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 3,314
When speaking about sets, it's tempting to use phrases that don't have precise definitions like "is a part of" and "is contained in" or "contains". This question is a good example of why the more specific phrases "is a subset of" and "is an element of" are needed.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Is the empty set always part of the basis of a topology? Topology and Analysis 18
How empty is the empty wave? Quantum Physics 14
What's your favorite part of this music video and give the formula for that part General Discussion 1
Divergent series: essential infinite part and finite part. Calculus 0
Empty Part of the Universe? Cosmology 8