Register to reply 
Odds of identical DNA 
Share this thread: 
#1
Apr214, 08:37 AM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 12,501

Is it theoretically possible that two people not directly related could be born with identical DNA? I would imagine that there is always the chance of a series of mutations that make one person identical to another, but I have no sense of the magnitude of the odds of such an event  I assume they would be astronomical. I was also wondering if two different sets of parents could theoretically produce children with identical DNA.



#2
Apr214, 10:13 AM

P: 41

I'll give a shot at considering the problem in a researchfree fashion.
Need: # of bases in the human genome average % difference in base sequence between siblings Calculate the average number of bases different. Consider that the odds of randomly matching bases is 1/(4^n) where n is the number of random bases being compared. Sound like a reasonable approach? 


#3
Apr214, 10:23 AM

PF Gold
P: 6,501

I have read (sorry, no citations) that although it is technically not IMpossible for two people to have the same DNA, the odds of any given living person having the same DNA as another living person are ... I forget what exact description was used, but your choice of "astronomical" (meaning, I assume, infinitesimal in this case) seems fitting.



#4
Apr214, 01:07 PM

Best Humor
P: 560

Odds of identical DNA



#5
Apr214, 02:05 PM

Other Sci
Sci Advisor
P: 1,401

One in 10^480000 would be an upper bound on the probability of two individuals having the same DNA (the calculation was made in the context of estimating the number of possible human genome sequences). For this to be the actual probability would require 1) that these variants are distributed randomly throughout the population with respect to each other (many populations will likely share the same variants), and 2) that the variant and wildtype alleles are present in a 5050 mixture throughout the population (many variants are likely rare).
Of course, the likelihood of two individuals having identical genomes is still infinitesimally small. 


#6
Apr314, 06:43 PM

Engineering
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 7,285

Just to complicate things a bit more: if the DNA in a single cell mutates, that mutation doesn't instantly alter every other cell in the body.
So what it the probability that even ONE person has totally "identical" DNA, let alone two people? (The answer obviously depends on the person's age  make whatever assumptions you want.). 


#8
Apr414, 08:11 AM

PF Gold
P: 6,501




#9
Apr414, 11:47 AM

PF Gold
P: 4,292

Sorry for the implication, that was intended for the casual reader.



#10
Apr414, 11:57 AM

P: 446

The odds of two people having the same DNA = the odds that they are clones.



#11
Apr414, 01:23 PM

PF Gold
P: 6,501




#12
Apr414, 02:45 PM

P: 446

I suppose, more precisely, it's: The probability that two people have the same DNA = the probability that they were artificially engineered that way + the negligible probability that it happened naturally. 


#13
Apr414, 05:46 PM

PF Gold
P: 6,501

If you want to just say they are both very small, I agree, but your careless use of the equals sign is not helpful. 


#14
Apr714, 03:40 PM

Best Humor
P: 560

10E30 being analogous to probability of them being artificial clones and 10E50 being analogous to them having same genetic matter naturally. Though for the blue to be correct we would have to discount identical twins which is much more likelier than artificial cloning. 


#15
Apr714, 06:39 PM

PF Gold
P: 6,501




#16
Apr1014, 02:15 PM

P: 3,097

And then there's chimeras, people with more than one DNA signature. In one case, a woman had two sets of DNA which was determined to have come from a twin that was somehow absorbed into her shortly after conception.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chimera_%28genetics%29 


#17
Apr1214, 02:30 PM

P: 86

Two people with the same DNA is already really unlikely, therefore we can go a bit further. But, if these parents have many differences in their DNA we would need more and more mutations for this to work. I don't think this can, mathematically at least, reach a point where it is impossible to have people with the same DNA, but it gets ridiculously unlikely. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Against all odds  General Discussion  26  
Two identical springs with spring constant k and with two Identical masses m  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Quantum Mechanics  Identical and NonIdentical Spin 1 particles  Advanced Physics Homework  4  
What are the odds?  General Math  13  
The odds of it all...  General Discussion  2 