Register to reply 
Greater Free Energy 
Share this thread: 
#1
Apr614, 05:18 PM

P: 8

This question came to mind when studying voltaic cells. In voltaic cells, for some ions (Cu2+ for example), both oxidation and reduction are possible. Given both possiblities, how do we determine which reaction will take place? I first thought that comparing the signage in voltage of both reactant combinations would give the answer. But it then occurred to me that, even in both cases, signage could be positive.
In other words. V1>0 V2>0 but V1>V2 how does one determine which reaction takes place then? the same can be said about free energy G1< 0 G2< 0 but G1<G2. 


#2
Apr714, 10:47 AM

P: 380

This depends on how you construct your cell, remember that a reduction table is created by using a standard (SHE) and giving it an arbitrary reduction of zero. You cannot have a redox reaction with a reductant AND an oxidant. If you have metal iron and Cu^{2+}, why would you think that the copper will form oxidation states of >2+?
Edit to add: If you have a situation where the free energy is indeed such that both reactions are predicted to occur spontaneously, then they both will occur proportionally to their respective kinetics parameters. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Enthalpy ,gibbs free energy, helmholtz free energy  General Physics  1  
Difference between enthalpy, Helmholtz free energy,& Gibbs free energy  Classical Physics  1  
Does greater light intensity imply greater energy?  General Physics  1  
Which one will have greater kinetic energy.  General Physics  2  
Potential energy greater total energy in the system?  Classical Physics  4 