Register to reply 
Ratio of matter to radiation density 
Share this thread: 
#1
Jun2614, 09:38 AM

P: 115

Is the ratio of matter to radiation density constant in the universe? Or does it vary over time, as matter annihilates to radiation and viceversa?



#2
Jun2614, 10:09 AM

Mentor
P: 6,233

As the universe expands, both radiation and matter "thin out", but at different rates. Expansion of the universe decreases the density of radiation more rapidly than it decreases the density of matter.
If ##a \left(t\right)## is the linear scale of the universe (so ##a \left(t\right)## increases as time ##t## increases), then the volume that a given amount of matter occupies is proportional to ##a \left(t\right)^3##, and thus matter densities scales as ##1/a \left(t\right)^3##. Radiation is made of photons, and photon density also scales as ##1/a \left(t\right)^3##, but the expansion of the universe also scales the wavelength by another factor of ##a \left(t\right)##, so radiation energy density scales as ##1/a \left(t\right)^4##. 


#3
Jun2614, 10:38 AM

P: 115

Thank you for your reply. While I am aware of how matter and radiation vary with the scale factor, this is what I am trying to ascertain: is the total amount of matter and total amount of radiation in the universe constant, or does it vary because of annihilation of matter to radiation and viceversa?



#4
Jun2614, 10:46 AM

Mentor
P: 6,233

Ratio of matter to radiation density
Let ##\rho_r \left(t\right)## be the density of radiation and ##\rho_m \left(t\right)## be the density of matter. I think that you are asking "Is
$$\frac{\rho_m \left(t\right) a\left(t\right)^3}{\rho_r \left(t\right) a \left(t\right)^4}$$ constant?" I think that this ratio is now fairly constant. 


#5
Jun2614, 12:02 PM

P: 115

Yes, that is what I am trying to ascertain. Could you please clarify what do you mean by "fairly constant"?
While I should not plug my own work, recently I published a paper online on dark energy where I argue for a correlation between inertial mass density and the cosmological constant. Thus, if total matter density were not to be constant, that would affect the rate of acceleration of the universe, and thereby provide a way to test the correlation. You may like to check out the paper at http://article.sapub.org/10.5923.j.a...140301.02.html 


#6
Jun2614, 04:02 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 4,160

Please take another look at the PF Guidlines: 


#7
Jun2614, 11:13 PM

Mentor
P: 16,999

Unacceptable references have been removed and this thread is closed.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Number Density vs Energy Density of Radiation and Matter  Advanced Physics Homework  0  
Effect of ratio of energy density of matter and radiation on redshift  Advanced Physics Homework  1  
At what redshift does energy density in matter equal energy density in radiation?  Cosmology  5  
Calculating Energy density in matter & radiation  Cosmology  1 