Why do clouds cast shadows in space?

  • Thread starter Ayesha_Sadiq
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Air Form
In summary: The smaller the object, the less diffraction is needed to hide or remove the shadow. The reason that shadows are blurry when you move your hand farther from the ground is that the shadow is spread out over a larger area.This would happen whether light consisted of waves or corpuscles.
  • #1
Ayesha_Sadiq
21
1
I am guessing this is due to diffraction due to the small size of the molecules of air. But then, we never see diffraction effects (interference) for any arrangement or configuration of molecules in space?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Can you expand the question a bit?

A shadow normally forms when an opaque object block light. Air isn't opaque so why does it need a mechanism like diffraction to stop it making shadows?
 
  • #3
Just like the post above, but I'd like to add a few more details.

Have you ever looked at your shadow when it bright and sunny? Move your hand further away from the ground... what will happen is that the shadow will look blurry. Why? As the above stated, diffraction comes into effect BUT more importantly, the smaller the object, the smaller the shadow. The smaller the shadow, the less diffraction is needed to hide or remove the shadow.

So, simply, in a pinch, you could say that Air molecules are too small and light doesn't tend to hit them.

Also note that light reflects off of objects too! So that means that light hits a single spot from multiple angles.
That is why you can the the ground even though there is a shadow.
 
  • #4
FilupSmith said:
Have you ever looked at your shadow when it bright and sunny? Move your hand further away from the ground... what will happen is that the shadow will look blurry. Why? As the above stated, diffraction comes into effect BUT more importantly, the smaller the object, the smaller the shadow. The smaller the shadow, the less diffraction is needed to hide or remove the shadow.

I think this may have more to do with the sun not being a point-like light source, but an extended one. At the edge of the shadow you will have some of the ground that is blocked from the entire light source, but as you keep going, more of the light source is visible to the ground, leading to a gradual fading instead of a sharp edge.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #5
shadow to human eye implies absence of light, why would air cast shadow when most of the light passes through it.
 
  • #6
A mirage is an example of air casting 'shadows'. Changes in air density causes both diffraction and refraction. The transmissibility of light through air is affected both by temperature gradients and turbulence.
 
  • #7
Chronos said:
A mirage is an example of air casting 'shadows'. Changes in air density causes both diffraction and refraction. The transmissibility of light through air is affected both by temperature gradients and turbulence.

In this case the air is acting like a lens, focusing and redirecting light to different places than it would otherwise land. I personally wouldn't put this in the same category as casting a shadow, but that's just me. I suppose you can if you want to.
 
  • #8
The vast clouds of gas, out there in space, do actually 'cast shadows' when they lie between a source and an observer. By scattering light, they will reduce the intensity of the light traveling through them.

This would happen whether light consisted of waves or corpuscles.
Have you ever looked at your shadow when it bright and sunny? Move your hand further away from the ground... what will happen is that the shadow will look blurry.
It's a matter of geometry, not diffraction (remember the School diagram with Umbra and Penumbra?)
 

1. Why can't we see shadows in the air?

The main reason why we can't see shadows in the air is because air is a transparent medium. This means that light can pass through it without being scattered or absorbed, which is necessary for the formation of shadows.

2. Can air be considered a solid or a liquid in terms of shadow formation?

No, air cannot be considered a solid or a liquid in terms of shadow formation. Solids and liquids have particles that are closely packed together, which allows them to block or absorb light and form shadows. Air, on the other hand, has particles that are more spread out, making it difficult for them to form a solid barrier to block light and create shadows.

3. Why do we see shadows on cloudy days if air is transparent?

On cloudy days, the air is not completely transparent due to the presence of water droplets and ice crystals in the atmosphere. These particles can scatter and absorb light, creating areas of darkness behind them and forming shadows.

4. Can air ever form shadows?

Technically, air can form shadows in certain conditions. For example, if there is smoke or dust in the air, these particles can block or scatter light and create shadows. However, in general, air is not dense enough to consistently form shadows like solid objects can.

5. Is there any scientific significance to understanding why air doesn't form shadows?

While the lack of shadow formation in air may seem like a simple concept, it actually has significant scientific implications. Understanding how light interacts with different mediums, such as air, is crucial in fields such as optics, meteorology, and astronomy. It also helps us to better understand the properties of air and how it affects our daily lives.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
776
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
15
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
19
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
973
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
24
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
210
Back
Top