Register to reply 
Solar radiation force on comets. 
Share this thread: 
#1
Aug714, 09:09 AM

P: 143

I see this comet being chased by ESA, they said it is presently about 500 million km from the sun.
That puts the radiation received by that comet at about 10% (roughly) as what we receive on Earth, well at least on top of the atmosphere, at 1355 watts per meter ^2. Looking at the size of that comet, I just rounded it out to 3000 by 4000 meters that would receive energy from the sun and at ten %, 135 watts per meter squared comes out to something like 1.5 gigawatts deposited on the surface at any given time, which of course goes up as it gets closer to the sun. My question is, given 1.5 gw hitting the comet, how much force does that represent on the comet trying to push it away from the sun and how much would the orbit be altered by that force each orbit? Could you calculate how much different the obit would be if it was orbiting say a black hole that doesn't radiate so there is no direct energy being deposited and it had a similar orbit to that comet. That force would be trying to accelerate a mass about that of Mount Everest so I know it wouldn't have a massive effect but how much would that force move the orbit from orbit to orbit? And wouldn't the orbit also be effected by the propulsion given by the ejected water when that water acts like a rocket leaving the comet, but in this case it could be aimed at any arbitrary angle. So could you calculate all those potential changes to the orbit of that or any other comet? 


#2
Aug714, 09:33 AM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 6,723

The pressure due to radiation can be calculated using the formulas in this article:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_pressure The pressure is basically the energy flux divided by c (the speed of light) and multiplied by the cosine of the angle of incidence of the radiation to the illuminated surface. The problem with an irregularly shaped object like a comet is it makes a simple calculation relatively complex, to account for the changing angles of incidence over the surface of the comet. (If the comet is tumbling as it orbits the sun, the calculation becomes exponentially more complicated). 


#3
Aug714, 09:40 AM

P: 994

The direct force of light pressure on the comet is quite small. That force can be derived by dividing the power (1.5 gigawatts by your estimate) by the speed of light to get a rate of momentum change. This follows from the equation e = pc that applies for photon energy.
1.5 gigawatts / c = 1,500,000,000 kg m^{2}/sec^{3} / 300,000,000 m/sec = 5 kg m/sec^{2} = 5 Newtons The force produced by the outgassing water will be higher. It is more difficult to calculate but can be obtained by dividing the power carried away as kinetic energy in the outgassing water by the velocity of that outgassing water and multiplying by 2. This follows from the equation e = 1/2 mv^{2} (= 1/2 pv) that applies for kinetic energy at nonrelativistic speeds. Edit: The above estimate for force from incident ratiation assumes that the radiation is absorbed rather than being reflected and ignores any net force from reradiation of lower energy photons. 


#4
Aug714, 12:06 PM

P: 143

Solar radiation force on comets.
5 newtons. I guess it might have an effect in a couple million years:) So 5 newtons pushing against Mt Everest floating in space, 1.1 pounds, 2.2 kg, You'd have to really hang on with that much acceleration:)
Not much bang for the buck energy wise, eh. 


#5
Aug714, 05:08 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,721

don't forget that the whole surface wont be facing the sun, lots, more than 1/2 of the surface, depending on its shape will; be in the shade. so maybe only ~ 40% of that 1.5 GW Dave 


#6
Aug714, 05:51 PM

P: 658




Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Solar radiation  conversion to calculate radiation impacting vertical surface  Earth  0  
Solar Radiation Force  Astronomy & Astrophysics  1  
Conical Solar Tunnel to Redirect Solar Radiation  Engineering Systems & Design  2  
Force of solar radiation on earth  Introductory Physics Homework  4  
Emitted radiation and absorbed solar radiation  Astronomy & Astrophysics  1 