Register to reply

Reversible engines with different efficiencies

by AbhiNature
Tags: efficiencies, engines, reversible
Share this thread:
Aug21-14, 12:11 PM
P: 18
Is is possible to have 2 different engines with all the following criterion?

1) Are reversible
2) Work differently (different cycles)
3) At the same working temepratures have different efficiencies.

Working temperatures 100K and 50K.
Engine 1: Carnot's
Efficiency - 50%

Engine2: Some cycle
Efficiency - 20%

Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on
Physical constant is constant even in strong gravitational fields
Physicists provide new insights into the world of quantum materials
Nuclear spins control current in plastic LED: Step toward quantum computing, spintronic memory, better displays
Dear Sir
Aug23-14, 05:25 PM
P: 7
All Reversible Heat Engines have same efficiency when operating between the same two temperature reservoirs.

This is proved by showing that there is a contradiction, if they do not. We set the two heat engines to be compared operating between the same two heat reservoirs. Assume one is more efficient than the other. Run the less efficient one in reverse (as a refrigerator) using the fraction of the work from the more efficient engine that the less efficient engine would produce running forward. At that point there is zero net heat flow from the hot reservoir and the differential in work between the two engines is comes from the net heat removed from the cold heat reservoir. This contradicts the Carnot assumption. Thus to stay consistent:
Every reversible heat engine operating between the same two temperature reservoirs have identical efficiency. This means no matter how a reversible heat engine is constructed or what the working fluid is, its efficiency is the same as all other heat engines working from the same two temperatures.
Aug23-14, 10:43 PM
P: 18
I thought so. It is as improbable to create a lesser efficient reversible engine (compared to Carnot's) as to create a more efficient reversible engine.
Whenever second law is violated, maybe, it would be due to the lesser efficient engine.

Register to reply

Related Discussions
Do all reversible engines become heat pumps? Classical Physics 2
Compare FIR and IIR efficiencies Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework 0
Reversible & non reversible internal combustion engines General Engineering 12
Reversible heat engines Advanced Physics Homework 0
Actual vs MTE Efficiencies of Heat Engines Introductory Physics Homework 0