Carnot Cycle and Adiabatic process

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the Carnot cycle and adiabatic processes involving a mono-atomic gas contained in a cylinder with a piston. The original poster seeks to understand the changes in pressure, volume, and temperature during the adiabatic process of the cycle.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the calculation of changes in pressure, volume, and temperature during the adiabatic process and question the relationship between work done and these changes. There is also inquiry about the appropriate value of \(\gamma\) for a mono-atomic gas. Additionally, participants explore the implications of the isothermal process in the context of the Carnot cycle.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problem, raising questions about the calculations and the necessary conditions for the adiabatic and isothermal processes. Some guidance has been offered regarding the use of the adiabatic condition, but there is no explicit consensus on the approach or the values to use.

Contextual Notes

There are uncertainties regarding the specific parameters needed for calculations, such as the values of pressure and volume at various points in the cycle. The original poster has noted missing information and is seeking clarification on how to proceed with the calculations.

Bob19
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
I have a question regarding Carnot Cycles and Adiabatic processs.

I have cylinder with n moles of a mono-atomic gas with a specific Volume, Pressure and Temperature. This Cylinder is closed by a piston.

This system undergoes the four step Carnot Cycle A-B, B-C, C-D and D-A.

A-B: Is the adiabatic process where no heat gets in or out Q=0. What I'm required to do is to calculate the change in Pressure, Volume and Temperature. Any hits or idears on how I do that?

Is it something about calculating the work done by the gas? Which during the adiabatic process expands the initial volume. But does this also change the pressure and temperature of the gas too ?

Sincerley and Best Regards,

Bob
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Thanks,

I will this out, and get back to You if the need more asistance.


/BOB
 
Bob19 said:
I have a question regarding Carnot Cycles and Adiabatic processs.

I have cylinder with n moles of a mono-atomic gas with a specific Volume, Pressure and Temperature. This Cylinder is closed by a piston.

This system undergoes the four step Carnot Cycle A-B, B-C, C-D and D-A.

A-B: Is the adiabatic process where no heat gets in or out Q=0. What I'm required to do is to calculate the change in Pressure, Volume and Temperature. Any hits or idears on how I do that?

Is it something about calculating the work done by the gas? Which during the adiabatic process expands the initial volume. But does this also change the pressure and temperature of the gas too ?
You will have to use the adiabatic condition: [tex]PV^\gamma = constant[/tex]

AM
 
Hello again,

The mono-atomic gas is not specified. Therefore which [tex]\gamma[/tex] -value do I use ? 1.64 or 1.69 ??

/Bob

Andrew Mason said:
You will have to use the adiabatic condition: [tex]PV^\gamma = constant[/tex]

AM
 
Therefore which [tex]\gamma[/tex]-value do I use ? 1.64 or 1.69 ??
:confused: i believed that for mono-atomic gas we assume [tex]\gamma=5/3=1.67[/tex]
 
Yegor said:
:confused: i believed that for mono-atomic gas we assume [tex]\gamma=5/3=1.67[/tex]


I have a second question.

As part of the carnot cycle I have the isothermical process D -> C, where

[tex]P_D = 711.3 \textrm{KPa} , V_D = 15.0 \textrm{L and} \ T_D = 584.43 \textrm{K}[/tex]

Since D and C are on the same path in the carnot cycle then according to theory T_D = T_C.

I'm required to calculate V_C from the data availible to me. Which formula do I use to calculate V_C ?

Sincerely
Bob
 
If A-B is adiabatic then C-D (or D-C) is also adiabatic.
Nevertheless, if both are isothermic, then you should use [tex]PV^\gamma = constant[/tex] for adiabatic and [tex]PV = constant[/tex] for isothermic.

[tex]P_D = 711.3 \textrm{KPa} , V_D = 15.0 \textrm{L and} \ T_D = 584.43 \textrm{K}[/tex]

I think that any parameter in point B or A must be given. Isn't it?
 
Since A and B are on the same path in the carnot cycle then

[tex]T_A = T_B[/tex]

I have reached the following point (where I'm stuck in my calculation of [tex]V_C[/tex] and [tex]P_{C}[/tex]

[tex]P_{c} * V_{c} = T_{c} \frac{P_{D} * V_{D}}{T_c}[/tex]

I get that [tex]P_{c} * V_{c} = 10671,5[/tex]

Can I use this result to obtain [tex]V_{C}[/tex] and [tex]P_{D}[/tex] ??

/Bob

Yegor said:
If A-B is adiabatic then C-D (or D-C) is also adiabatic.
Nevertheless, if both are isothermic, then you should use [tex]PV^\gamma = constant[/tex] for adiabatic and [tex]PV = constant[/tex] for isothermic.



I think that any parameter in point B or A must be given. Isn't it?
 
A-B: Is the adiabatic process where no heat gets in or out Q=0. What I'm required to do is to calculate the change in Pressure, Volume and Temperature
Or it was another problem?
I have reached the following point (where I'm stuck in my calculation of and
[tex]P_{c} * V_{c} = T_{c} \frac{P_{D} * V_{D}}{T_c}[/tex]
I get that [tex]P_{c} * V_{c} = 10671,5[/tex]
Can I use this result to obtain [tex]V_{C}[/tex] and [tex]P_{D}[/tex]??
Yes, you can use, but it isn't enough.
Do you really have nothing more given?

P.S. How it's possible to quote? What is the right command?
 
  • #10
Hello again,

Yes its a different part of the problem this time:

First I made a typoo:

Here is the right formula

[tex]P_{c} * V_{c} = T_{c} \frac{P_{D} * V_{D}}{T_D}[/tex]

I'm told that [tex]V_C = 24 \ Liters[/tex] but how that's derrived from the above result I'm a bit unsure of ?

/Bob


Yegor said:
Or it was another problem?

Yes, you can use, but it isn't enough.
Do you really have nothing more given?

P.S. How it's possible to quote? What is the right command?
 
  • #11
May be you should use any results from another parts of the problem!?
A-B: Is the adiabatic process where no heat gets in or out Q=0. What I'm required to do is to calculate the change in Pressure, Volume and Temperature. Any hits or idears on how I do that?
If you have worked this out you should have some information about other points of the cycle.
 
  • #12
I have data for D and A the volume in C but not other data.

So what do I do ?

BOB

Yegor said:
May be you should use any results from another parts of the problem!?

If you have worked this out you should have some information about other points of the cycle.
 
  • #13
C-D and A-B are isothermic; and D-A and B-C - adiabatic.
Then [tex]V_C P_C= V_D P_D[/tex]
[tex]V_A P_A= V_B P_B[/tex]
[tex]P_D V_D^\gamma=P_A V_A^\gamma[/tex]
[tex]P_B V_B^\gamma=P_C V_C^\gamma[/tex]
Also use [tex]PV^\gamma = TV^{\gamma-1}=P^{1-\gamma}T^\gamma =constant[/tex] for adiabatic. Now you can calculate all data
 
  • #14
Yegor said:
C-D and A-B are isothermic; and D-A and B-C - adiabatic.
Then [tex]V_C P_C= V_D P_D[/tex]
[tex]V_A P_A= V_B P_B[/tex]
[tex]P_D V_D^\gamma=P_A V_A^\gamma[/tex]
[tex]P_B V_B^\gamma=P_C V_C^\gamma[/tex]
Also use [tex]PV^\gamma = TV^{\gamma-1}=P^{1-\gamma}T^\gamma =constant[/tex] for adiabatic. Now you can calculate all data

Hi,

Which of these formulas do I then use to calculate V_c ?

/Bob
 
  • #15
Hm. I think it's impossible. Imagine the P-V plot. You have two points D and A, as you told. There are no restrictions on where adiabata B-C intersects isothermas.
 
Last edited:
  • #16
Sorry scratch that:

I have discovered that [tex]V_C = 24[/tex] is avalible in the text.

Sorry I missed that cause I'm suffering from terrible hayfever today.

I'm Sorry :-)

/Bob
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 67 ·
3
Replies
67
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
49
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K