This question may have no value since it defeats itself. We can't use logic to discuss an illogical god.
Nonetheless I would be interested in other peoples thoughts on the possibility of a "not-always-logical" god.
I'm trying to show my students that CaCO_3 is basic.
Ca^2^+ comes from Ca(OH)_2, which is a weak base due to it's low solubility. CO_3^2^- comes from the weak acid HCO_3^-. To compare the two we compare:
1) Ca^2^+ + H_2O --> Ca(OH)_2 + H_3O^+
2) CO_3^2^- + H_2O --> HCO_3^- +...