Electron probability in oscillating hydrogen molecule

In summary, the electron probability is highest between the two nuclei of a hydrogen molecule, but this statement is false. The plot of electron density looks like a two-humped camel, and there are two maximums near the nuclei. As separation decreases, density increases monotonically even at very small separations.
  • #1
sid_galt
502
1
In a hydrogen molecule, the electron probability is the highest between the two nuclei of the hydrogen molecule. Let's say that the nuclei of the hydrogen molecule start oscillating.
When they get closer to each other, will the electron probability decrease or increase between the two nuclei?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
  • #2
1. This is not a chemistry question.

2. Why is this important ?

3. This is a non-trivial calculation. You want to apply a time dependent perturbation to a many-particle hamiltonian (with a non-central potential) and determine the evolution of the angular part of the wave function.

4. Not doing the above, I'd go with 'decrease'. (consider the limiting case)
 
  • #3
sid_galt said:
In a hydrogen molecule, the electron probability is the highest between the two nuclei of the hydrogen molecule.

It is not. Plot of electron density looks like a two-humped camel.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
Borek said:
It is not. Plot of electron density looks like a two-humped camel.


Borek
--
http://www.chembuddy.com
Chemical calculators for labs and education
BATE - pH calculations, titration curves
The "two humped camel" is the plot of probability density vs. position along the internuclear line. So it tells you nothing about the angular dependence of the density. For this you must look at a 2d plot with the density designated by the packing of dots (cloud pictures) or an angular plot of the density.
 
  • #5
I know, just 'along the internuclear line' was beyond scope of my English at the moment of writing :blushing:

But it doesn't change the fact that statement "the electron probability is the highest between the two nuclei of the hydrogen molecule" is false. Unless "between the two nuclei" doesn't mean "on the internuclear line" :smile:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #6
Borek said:
But it doesn't change the fact that statement "the electron probability is the highest between the two nuclei of the hydrogen molecule" is false. Unless "between the two nuclei" doesn't mean "on the internuclear line" :smile:


Borek

Then at what angular position is it the highest (roughly) ?
 
  • #7
It seems I was partially wrong, or rather not precise enough when thinking. Angular position has nothing to do with the hydrogen particle. 'Camel plot' goes through the maximum values, but - stricly speaking - maximum is not between nuclei. There are two maximums, both near the nuclei. So it is not difficult to find a place in the particle with the electron density higher then in the cencter of the particle. That's what I was referring to.

Unless I am wrong again...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #8
Yes, there are two maxima, but they both lie along the internuclear line (ie : between the nucleii, but not in the middle of the separation) . Perhaps I was being unclear with my previous remarks.

In any case this is only a side issue and and the real question asks what happens to the wave function as the internuclear spacing changes.
 
  • #9
A very loose bond would have a near-zero probability at the center of the internuclear line. However, as they were brought closer together, you would be more likely to find an electron in between them because they'd be more strongly bonded.
 
  • #10
SpaceTiger said:
A very loose bond would have a near-zero probability at the center of the internuclear line. However, as they were brought closer together, you would be more likely to find an electron in between them because they'd be more strongly bonded.

The equilibrium internuclear spacing (bond length) corresponds to a local minimum in PE and hence a local maximum in bond strength. Bringing the atoms closer than equilibrium spacing will not increase the bond strength.
 
  • #11
Gokul43201 said:
The equilibrium internuclear spacing (bond length) corresponds to a local minimum in PE and hence a local maximum in bond strength. Bringing the atoms closer than equilibrium spacing will not increase the bond strength.

You're right, how sloppy of me! Bond strength does refer to the energy required to separate it, not the proximity. The rest of what I said holds, though.
 
  • #12
SpaceTiger, what would you imagine happened in the limiting case where the nuclei were infinitesimally close to each other. Would you still expect a larger electron density between them, rather than on the outsides ?
 
  • #13
Gokul43201 said:
SpaceTiger, what would you imagine happened in the limiting case where the nuclei were infinitesimally close to each other. Would you still expect a larger electron density between them, rather than on the outsides ?

At that point, it's not really a molecule anymore, it's an atom. So the wave function would be of a different character...
 
  • #14
What you are suggesting is a discontinuity in the density with separation.

As separation decreases, density increases monotonically even at very small separations. Then when the separation goes to zero, the density suddenly drops to zero.

What I'm suggesting is that there is instead a continuous variation of density with separation; the density being zero for infinite as well as zero separation, with a maximum somewhere in between.

Which looks "nicer" to you ?
 
  • #15
Gokul43201 said:
What you are suggesting is a discontinuity in the density with separation.

When they're that close to one another, you have a change in the shape of the potential because the nuclei bond to one another by the strong force. Up until that point, the potential is double-peaked and will give different wave functions. It's not a discontinuity because they don't have to be infinitesmally close, but on the scales of an atom, it's practically one.

Even if your arguments were correct, I still wouldn't be convinced that the probability density would change near that critical point (that is, near the stable separation). I'll concede, however, that my intuition may not be entirely correct on this issue and would defer the final word to someone who has actually solved the SE for this.
 
Last edited:
  • #16
SpaceTiger said:
Even if your arguments were correct, I still wouldn't be convinced that the probability density would change near that critical point (that is, near the stable separation).
Neither am I. I do not claim to know the location of the maximum, but am making a top-of-my-hat guess based purely on intuition.
 

1. What is the significance of electron probability in an oscillating hydrogen molecule?

The electron probability in an oscillating hydrogen molecule refers to the likelihood of finding an electron at a specific location within the molecule at a given time. This probability is influenced by the oscillating motion of the molecule, which affects the distribution of the electron's position.

2. How does the electron probability change during the oscillation of a hydrogen molecule?

The electron probability changes as the hydrogen molecule oscillates due to the changing electric field around the molecule. This causes the electron to shift positions and affect the overall probability distribution.

3. Can the electron probability in an oscillating hydrogen molecule be calculated?

Yes, the electron probability can be calculated using quantum mechanical equations and models, such as the Schrödinger equation. However, the calculations can be complex and may require sophisticated computational methods.

4. What is the relationship between electron probability and energy levels in an oscillating hydrogen molecule?

The electron probability is directly related to the energy levels in an oscillating hydrogen molecule. As the molecule oscillates and changes energy levels, the electron probability also changes, resulting in a different distribution of the electron's position within the molecule.

5. How does the electron probability in an oscillating hydrogen molecule affect chemical reactions?

The electron probability in an oscillating hydrogen molecule can play a significant role in chemical reactions by determining the likelihood of electron transfer between molecules. The changing probability distribution can also affect the stability and reactivity of the molecule, leading to different reaction outcomes.

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
707
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
33
Views
542
  • Chemistry
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Back
Top