4-way stop

3,073
3
A car arrives from each direction of a four-way stop intersection simultaneously. How can the drivers determine who has the right of way?
 
662
3
A car arrives from each direction of a four-way stop intersection simultaneously. How can the drivers determine who has the right of way?
This depends on what country they're driving in, and possibly in what state/province/etc, since driving laws can change regionally within a country.

In Massachusetts, there is no legal recourse for determining who goes first of which I'm aware. Someone just takes the initiative.

If you're asking as a hypothetical, one could decide based on any one of a number of statistics, such as the alphabetic precedence of their license plates. However, this is not realistic, as not all cars have license plates that are visible to other drivers on their front bumpers. One could also make the determination based on the closest compass direction, with (say) North/East/South/West taking precedence. But that assumes that you can tell the compass direction. There are a bunch of other ways that might work, but nothing that I can think of offhand that's fool-proof from a realistic standpoint.

DaveE
 
867
0
A trick question? A car as in just one car coming from all four different directions?
 
1,744
50
In Chicago it was always the one with the oldest, beat up car.
 
854
16
The normal rule is that the one on the left has the right of way. However, in this case that would cause an infinite loop and result in a black hole sucking in cars forever. So I'll say that the one on the right goes first.
 
94
3
A car arrives from each direction of a four-way stop intersection simultaneously. How can the drivers determine who has the right of way?
Since all 4 drivers belong to the Physics Forum, they are aware that there is no such thing as absolute simultaneity. So they exit their vehicles to determine exactly in whose frame of reference this simultaneity occurred, and during the course of this discussion they agree on an order in which to proceed.
 
101
0
Since there are no established accepted rules and presumably they haven't communicated beforehand, some form of universally understood communication needs to take place, so this teaser is :yuck:
 
119
0
they sit there forever, or untill they come up with a superior alternative to a 4 way stop, and so the round about was born!
 
102
0
Since all 4 drivers belong to the Physics Forum, they are aware that there is no such thing as absolute simultaneity. So they exit their vehicles to determine exactly in whose frame of reference this simultaneity occurred, and during the course of this discussion they agree on an order in which to proceed.
I think this one's the right answer. lol
 
4,222
1
Since all 4 drivers belong to the Physics Forum, they are aware that there is no such thing as absolute simultaneity. So they exit their vehicles to determine exactly in whose frame of reference this simultaneity occurred, and during the course of this discussion they agree on an order in which to proceed.
Yes, but the discussion can go on for days, and often stimulate similar discussion in related intersections that would have otherwise proceeded unimpeded.
 

BobG

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
110
80
Yes, but the discussion can go on for days, and often stimulate similar discussion in related intersections that would have otherwise proceeded unimpeded.
And, naturally, the discussion wandered off topic, although occasionally passing back through the original topic - which is how PF invented the round about.
 
It's a moot point. If you see that three other drivers are going to reach the stop at the same time you do, just slow down or speed up to make sure the problem doesn't arise. That's what I do. Like I can't wait a few more seconds to get where I'm going?
 
11
0
Are you serious? The stoplight/stop signs. How do you people not figure that out? I guess you were just thinking TOO hard...:grumpy:
 
11
0
or...get out, shoot the other drivers, and go.:rofl:
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,237
1,843
It's a moot point. If you see that three other drivers are going to reach the stop at the same time you do, just slow down or speed up to make sure the problem doesn't arise. That's what I do. Like I can't wait a few more seconds to get where I'm going?
OK. All four of them attempt to slow down and speed up simultaneously, ultimately arrving at the intersection simultaneously, despite their best efforts.
 
Last edited:

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,237
1,843
If you're asking as a hypothetical, one could decide based on any one of a number of statistics, such as the alphabetic precedence of their license plates.
I think there's an implicit proviso: the drivers have not agreed to any rules beforehand.

Loren, is it safe to say that getting out of their car to discuss it is effectively ruled out as an impracticiblity?
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,237
1,843
Argh!

All of them signal to make right turns. Now they have right-of-way, and may proceed.
 
126
0
They look at each other, and one waves to another to go, who edges out, and sees he's being allowed to go, and goes. The rest repeat.

We've all been in this situation dozens of times, usually with just another car or two, however, in mall parking lots or the like.

It's situations like this where we should be happy that people are driving the cars, and not computers.
 
369
0
Why does it matter who goes first if they are all making right hand turns?
 
3,073
3
Find out which violates CPT symmetry.
 

Related Threads for: 4-way stop

  • Posted
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Posted
2
Replies
29
Views
3K
  • Posted
2
Replies
25
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
22
Views
6K
  • Posted
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
43
Views
5K
  • Posted
Replies
5
Views
2K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top