A plane shoots a bullet -- energy at different frame?

In summary, energy is not frame invariant and neither is work done. This means that in order for energy conservation laws to hold, everything must be described in the same frame of reference. The plane's speed and direction must be taken into account when considering the energy of the projectile fired from it. Additionally, conservation of momentum plays a role, with the plane experiencing recoil as a result of the firing of the gun. Ultimately, the additional energy of the projectile fired from the plane comes from the plane's engines when it takes off.
  • #1
lemd
31
0
Let say a plane flights at 1km/s, shoots a 2kg projectile at 1km/s, so to the Earth, the projectile flights at 2km/s with 2*2*2/2 = 4MJ.

The same gun when fixed on Earth, shoots the same 2kg projectile at 1km/s, achieves 2*1*1/2 = 1MJ

Assume that the energy comes from burning propellant or electrical energy (railgun), how can the gun on the plane does more work than the same gun fixed on Earth? Is the additional energy from the plane?

How can energy transfer from plane to the projectile? I.e. energy is transferred by force, and the pressure that pushes the projectile is the same in both cases. How can the projectile fired from a plane has higher energy?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Energy is not frame invariant and neither is work done. In order for the energy conservation laws to hold, you must describe everything in the same frame. However, energy is going to be conserved in both cases as long as you also include the recoil energy of whatever you fixed the gun to.
 
  • #3
lemd said:
Let say a plane flights at 1km/s, shoots a 2kg projectile at 1km/s, so to the Earth, the projectile flights at 2km/s with 2*2*2/2 = 4MJ.

The same gun when fixed on Earth, shoots the same 2kg projectile at 1km/s, achieves 2*1*1/2 = 1MJ

Assume that the energy comes from burning propellant or electrical energy (railgun), how can the gun on the plane does more work than the same gun fixed on Earth? Is the additional energy from the plane?

How can energy transfer from plane to the projectile? I.e. energy is transferred by force, and the pressure that pushes the projectile is the same in both cases. How can the projectile fired from a plane has higher energy?

Because of conservation of momentum, the plane will lose speed. The faster the plane is flying, the more energy this represents. The plane is so large that it is difficult to see. But, if the gun is mounted on the plane and is free to recoil, you can see what is happening more easily:

On the ground, the bullet travels at v and the gun recoils at u, say. That represents a total gain of kinetic energy from the firing mechanism.

On the plane, the gun recoils at u and this represents a loss of KE in the gun. If you add up the loss of KE in the gun and the energy from the firing mechanism this equals the gain in KE of the bullet.
 
  • #4
Indeed, how can it happen that way?

The answer is, you are forgetting something about conservation laws. Energy is not the only thing conserved. So also is momentum. And so you need to extend your calculation a little. The plane experiences re-coil. So it has to change its energy.

So make things simple. Make the plane 200 kg. So it will get a recoil of 1/100 the forward speed of the bullet.

So the starting kinetic energy of the whole system is (remember the whole system starts at v)

1/2 (M + m) v^2

Here v can be 0 if the plane starts stationary relative to us, or 1000 m/s if it starts at 1 km/s. Or even negative if we start out running ahead of the plane.

And the bullet winds up going v + 1km/s, but the plane winds up going v - 10 m/s

So the energy after is

1/2 M (v-10)^2 + 1/2 m (v+1000)^2

And if you use the fact that M = 100 m, where m=2, you find that the change in total kinetic energy turns out to be

1/2 m (10,000 + 1,000,000)

Notice that v has disappeared. That is, the change in total kinetic energy is the same no matter how fast the plane starts out when it shoots the bullet.

So for homework:
Do the general case where the mass of the bullet and the mass of the plane can be anything, and the speed the bullet is fired can be anything. Show that the change in kinetic energy does not depend on the starting velocity of the plane.

And for extra advanced credit:
Do the relativistic case where the plane is replaced by a particle moving at some fraction of the speed of light, and it breaks up into two decay products with smaller total rest mass. Do the simple case where the decay products move forward and backward relative to the motion of the initial particle. Show that total energy is conserved, as well as total momentum. Use all of he correct special relativistic formulas.
 
  • #5
lemd said:
Let say a plane flights at 1km/s, shoots a 2kg projectile at 1km/s, so to the Earth, the projectile flights at 2km/s with 2*2*2/2 = 4MJ.

The same gun when fixed on Earth, shoots the same 2kg projectile at 1km/s, achieves 2*1*1/2 = 1MJ

Assume that the energy comes from burning propellant or electrical energy (railgun), how can the gun on the plane does more work than the same gun fixed on Earth? Is the additional energy from the plane?

How can energy transfer from plane to the projectile? I.e. energy is transferred by force, and the pressure that pushes the projectile is the same in both cases. How can the projectile fired from a plane has higher energy?
Frankly, I think you understand it just fine except for the very last bit: that force for the extra kinetic energy came from the plane's engines when it took off.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
russ_watters said:
Frankly, I think you understand it just fine except for the very last bit: that force for the extra kinetic energy came from the plane's engines when it took off.

Let's be careful. The engines gave the bullet 1 MJ on takeoff. But the firing of the gun mechanism in flight moves it from 1km/s to 2 km/s, so it gives it 3 MJ to total to 4MJ. Meaning the engines did not give the bullet the extra kinetic energy. The engines gave it only 1 MJ. Firing it gave it 3 MJ when fired in flight compared to 1 MJ when fired on the ground.

To understand this you have to do the recoil analysis presented up-thread. That's the only way you can conserve energy.
 
  • #7
russ_watters said:
that force for the extra kinetic energy came from the plane's engines when it took off.
It has nothing to with the plane's engines, just with reference frames. When you view the plane standing on the ground from a reference frame where the plane moves, it's bullets will also have more energy than in the frame of the plane. But the engines were never on.
 
  • Like
Likes Nugatory

1. How does the energy of a bullet change when it is shot from a moving plane?

The energy of a bullet does not change when it is shot from a moving plane. This is because the total energy of an object, including its kinetic and potential energy, remains constant regardless of the frame of reference.

2. Does the velocity of the bullet affect its energy when shot from a plane?

Yes, the velocity of the bullet does affect its energy when shot from a plane. This is because the kinetic energy of an object is directly proportional to its velocity, so a faster bullet will have more energy than a slower one.

3. How does the energy of the bullet compare to the energy of the plane?

The energy of the bullet is significantly less than the energy of the plane. This is because a plane contains much larger and heavier objects, such as engines and fuel, which require more energy to move than a small bullet.

4. Is the energy of the bullet affected by the direction of the plane's motion?

No, the energy of the bullet is not affected by the direction of the plane's motion. This is because the direction of an object's motion does not affect its kinetic energy, as long as its speed remains constant.

5. Can the energy of the bullet be increased by shooting it from a faster plane?

Yes, the energy of the bullet can be increased by shooting it from a faster plane. This is because, as stated before, the kinetic energy of an object is directly proportional to its velocity. So, a faster plane will result in a faster bullet with more energy.

Similar threads

  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
387
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
34
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
16
Views
5K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
689
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
13
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
2
Replies
64
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
184
Back
Top