Is the Planet's Surface Hotter Than Its Shell?

  • Thread starter Tandem78
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Planet
In summary, the planet's surface is not hotter than the shell, and the atmosphere has a temperature gradient.
  • #1
Tandem78
18
0
well, not quite... imagine an earth-like planet totally enclosed in a shell of some material which conducts heat and has near black-body properties both inside and out.
The shell is at a distance of some 100s of kilometres from the planet's surface. The shell is light enough so that it has no significant gravitational mass, and totally encloses the atmosphere.
The planet orbits a sun-like star at a distance of one AU. It has no geothermal source of heat.

The question is - is the planet's surface hotter than the shell? Or put another way, is there a temperature gradient in the atmosphere?
 
Earth sciences news on Phys.org
  • #2
Tandem78 said:
well, not quite... imagine an earth-like planet totally enclosed in a shell of some material which conducts heat and has near black-body properties both inside and out.
The shell is at a distance of some 100s of kilometres from the planet's surface. The shell is light enough so that it has no significant gravitational mass, and totally encloses the atmosphere.
The planet orbits a sun-like star at a distance of one AU. It has no geothermal source of heat.

The question is - is the planet's surface hotter than the shell? Or put another way, is there a temperature gradient in the atmosphere?

What is the context of the question? What do you know about the transmissivity and reflectance of "transparent" layers?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflectivity

.
 
  • #3
berkeman said:
What is the context of the question? What do you know about the transmissivity and reflectance of "transparent" layers?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflectivity

.
The context is a dispute as to whether the temperature gradient of an atmosphere is the inevitable consequence of the increasing pressure with depth, or whether a source of energy is required.
 
  • #4
Tandem78 said:
well, not quite... imagine an earth-like planet totally enclosed in a shell of some material which conducts heat and has near black-body properties [..] is there a temperature gradient in the atmosphere?

No.
And worse, life ends.

Life is much about entropy. The sun's energy is only of use to us because we receive it from such a hot reservoir and the rest of the sky presents to us such a cold reservoir. If the whole sky were a constant minus 20 Celsius (the default temperature at 1AU), then the whole Earth (and atmospheric column) would also eventually thermalise to the same temperature. Photosynthesis (the food chain) would be thermodynamically prohibited.

The key to the thermal gradient is having an energy source on the inside. So if we had a petawatt of nuclear electricity stations to go on working our climate-controlled cities and grow-houses (or if you just pedantically focus on the residual heat coming from the mantle), then yes, there would still be a thermal gradient (less steep in that case, due to nonlinearity of the Stefan-Boltzmann law). And if you added more and more of those black shells, each would make the planet hotter still, and there would also be a gradient from shell to shell.

If you make the shells more complicated by introducing a mechanism for some heat to escape directly from inner shells (without getting intercepted by the outer shells) then you can even make the outermost shells cooler than they would otherwise be, replicating another effect from Earth's atmosphere.

PS: Pressure has nothing to do with it.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
cesiumfrog said:
Pressure has nothing to do with it.

That is what I thought too. Thanks.
 

1. Is the planet's surface always hotter than its shell?

Not necessarily. The temperature of a planet's surface and its shell can vary depending on a variety of factors such as the planet's distance from the sun, its atmospheric composition, and its geological activity.

2. What causes the difference in temperature between a planet's surface and its shell?

The difference in temperature between a planet's surface and its shell is primarily due to the planet's internal heat sources, such as radioactive decay and residual heat from its formation. This heat is trapped within the planet and can cause the temperature at the surface to be higher than that of the cooler shell.

3. Can the temperature difference between a planet's surface and its shell affect its climate?

Yes, the temperature difference between a planet's surface and its shell can greatly impact its climate. This temperature difference can contribute to the formation of weather patterns and atmospheric circulation, which in turn affect the planet's overall climate.

4. Is there a specific ratio between the temperature of a planet's surface and its shell?

No, there is no specific ratio between the temperature of a planet's surface and its shell. The temperature difference between the two can vary greatly depending on the specific characteristics and conditions of each planet.

5. How do scientists measure the temperature of a planet's surface and shell?

Scientists use a variety of methods to measure the temperature of a planet's surface and shell, including remote sensing techniques, thermal imaging, and direct measurements from probes or landers. These methods allow for accurate temperature readings to be taken from both the surface and the interior of a planet.

Similar threads

  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
21
Views
853
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
0
Views
627
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
22
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Back
Top