Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

A puzzle-can you solve it?

  1. May 25, 2004 #1
    a puzzle------can you solve it?

    Ye've lost yer marbles
    Puzzle by mathgrant
    It has been a long year at Puzzlania Academy, and the sweet smell of spring (and graduation) is in the air. Ah, how wonderful life is. Unfortunately for you, there's one little thing left before you can savour the aroma of graduation : the Puzzlania Ordinary Level Examinations. Rumour has it that your examiner this year is none other than Dr. M. Grant, the famous mathematician.

    As you enter the dimly-lit examination room for the first time, you are unsurprised to see Dr. Grant sitting behind an old desk.

    "I assume you are familiar with the format of your POLEs?" he asks. You nod. "There will be seven exams this year. You will have as much time as you'd like to write each one." He gestures toward a table with a pencil and piece of paper on it. "You may begin."

    You sit down at the table and begin reading the paper. There is only one question written on it, and it seems rather simple.

    I have 729 black marbles and 243 white marbles. I will draw one at random and discard it into a fiery pit. I will then keep drawing more random marbles and discarding them until one doesn't match the previous one. That marble will not be discarded, but put back in the bag. The marbles will be reshuffled and the process will start over.

    Example:
    I draw a black marble and discard it.
    I draw another black marble and discard it.
    I draw a white marble and shuffle it back into the bag.
    I draw a black marble and discard it.
    I draw a white marble and shuffle it back into the bag.
    I draw a white marble and discard it.
    I draw another white marble and discard it.
    I draw another white marble and discard it.
    I draw a black marble and shuffle it back into the bag.

    After a little while, eventually only one marble is left. What is the probability of it being black?

    "This is easy," you exclaim, "the answer is..."
     
  2. jcsd
  3. May 25, 2004 #2
    i came to the answer 50/50......can you help me?
     
  4. May 25, 2004 #3

    Njorl

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Looking at the simple case of 2 black marbles and one white yields a 50/50 chance.

    Possible orderings *denotes returned marble

    1. w b* b
    2. b w* w
    3. b w* b
    4. b b

    case 1. is 2/6 probable and leaves a black
    case 2. is 1/6 probable and leaves a black
    case 3. is 1/6 probable and leaves a white
    case 4. is 2/6 probable and leaves a white

    3/6 probabilty that either is left.

    Generallizing it is more work, but I suspect that it is indeed 50/50 as long as there is at least one of each.

    Njorl
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?



Similar Discussions: A puzzle-can you solve it?
  1. Can you prove you exist? (Replies: 151)

  2. Puzzle for you (Replies: 1)

  3. How honest can you be? (Replies: 21)

Loading...