Another locked thread, no reason

  • Thread starter phinds
  • Start date
14,966
4,629
This thread is locked

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/is-this-possible-giant-planet-a-hot-topic-in-astronomy.857258/

I have no problem w/ it being locked as I'm sure there's some decent reason for it, but I point out that someone browsing the forum would be hard pressed to see why in the world the thread is locked and in particular why it was done with no reason stated. Seems to me this makes the forum look bad. It would be better to state why the thread has been closed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OCR

Astronuc

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
18,516
1,628
This thread is locked

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/is-this-possible-giant-planet-a-hot-topic-in-astronomy.857258/

I have no problem w/ it being locked as I'm sure there's some decent reason for it, but I point out that someone browsing the forum would be hard pressed to see why in the world the thread is locked and in particular why it was done with no reason stated. Seems to me this makes the forum look bad. It would be better to state why the thread has been closed.
We are assessing the situation and will hopefully have a resolution soon.
 

davenn

Science Advisor
Gold Member
8,618
5,487
but I point out that someone browsing the forum would be hard pressed to see why in the world the thread is locked and in particular why it was done with no reason stated. Seems to me this makes the forum look bad. It would be better to state why the thread has been closed.
I agree with completely

Some mentors are great and state why a particular thread was locked ... others say nothing :wink:

if it is woo woo/crackpot ... say so. if dangerous to personal health, electrical, chemical etc say so

Doing so may even help encourage others that may read the thread not to post their own similar ones
now knowing the likely outcome of their post :smile:

Dave
 
10,453
3,974
I remember commenting in a report about the IOP journals being okay but I can't find the report. I think it was attached to this thread.

As Evo said, alw34 posted two threads around the same with one clearly crackpottery and the other we weren't sure of so I think this one fell through the cracks somehow.

I will unlock it as no one has shown any objections.
 
14,966
4,629
Thanks for the response, folks. Sorry this rather trivial thing took up time but I think it's solved the issue that I brought up in the OP and that was worth doing.
 

m k

Gold Member
11
7
How come, after all these years, this is not, mostly, automated.
 

Evo

Mentor
22,857
2,313
How come, after all these years, this is not, mostly, automated.
This is an example of when something can't be automated. It takes a human to read the post and links, check to see if the sources are in our "ok" list, even then, we have to double check because we've found a number of journals getting listed that shouldn't be. IIRC, the mentor that locked this thread fell ill, and other mentors were assuming he was working on it.

Never hurts to ask.
 

berkeman

Mentor
54,918
5,154
How come, after all these years, this is not, mostly, automated.
Nope, none of the Mentors use 'bots. Nope. :wink:
 

Ibix

Science Advisor
Insights Author
4,872
3,194
I agree that it would be nice to see an explanation of why locked threads are locked, especially if it isn't obvious. Is there room for some automated and non-automated support for mentors in this?

On the automated front, for example, a two-stage locking mechanism. Stage 1 locks the thread and auto-posts "Thread closed for moderation", and sets periodic reminders that the lock is unresolved. Stage 2 is "closed with an explanation". Jump straight to stage 2 if no discussion needed. You could also have standard lines for standard cases. Where you have someone who's posted a dozen crank threads and you're closing #13 not because the first post is cranky but because you know the OP is going to turn it cranky, have a one-click-to-post-and-lock template saying "Locked because the OP has past form for cranky behaviour". Possibly more tactfully.

On the non-automated front, since writing an explanation for why a thread is locked is yet another call on mentor time, how about a "deputy mentor" post? Give them access to (some of?) the mentor forums (but not the ban hammer) and encourage them to join the discussions and especially to write summaries of discussions, with a view to a mentor posting their summary as an explanation for the final lock. Maybe consider it a non-permanent position, rotating round members in good standing and see who participates?

Anyway - I'm drifting into crank territory myself by proposing solutions to problems I don't completely understand, so I'll shut up now.
 

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
2018 Award
20,468
4,163
Regardless of what may or may not happen in the future, remember that you can use the "Report" feature to notify the mentors that a locked thread has no explanation of why it's locked.
 

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
2018 Award
20,468
4,163
Ooh! Report a mentor's post for the good of the forum! I like that... :wink:
If a mentor reports a mentor's post, is that like dividing by zero?
 
14,966
4,629
If a mentor reports a mentor's post, is that like dividing by zero?
Well, in your case, it could be more like the blind leading the ... uh, wait ... I was going to say blind but the other mentor probably knows what they are doing so now I'm hung up in the middle of a metaphor ... Well, nuts. I guess us dogs aren't good at metaphors.



:smile:
 

Redbelly98

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
12,036
123
How come, after all these years, this is not, mostly, automated.
Just wanted to correct a misconception that relatively new forum members can get. About 1-1/2 years ago, Greg moved the forum to a completely new system, with very different procedures for moderating and for Mentors to deal with problem threads and problem members. So, it's not a matter of "after all these years"; it's been less than two.

Plus: (1) there is no automating of human judgment, and (2) Mentors are volunteers, who may be busy with work or other real-life matters and need to close a thread ASAP in order to stop a flood.
 
Last edited:

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
2018 Award
20,468
4,163
Just wanted to correct a misconception that relatively new forum members can get. About 1-1/2 years ago, Greg moved the forum to a completely new system, with very different procedures for moderating and for Mentors to deal with problem threads and problem members. So, it's not a matter of "after all these years"; it's been less than two.
Indeed. The entire moderation procedure is much more streamlined now than it had been under the old software.
 
1,166
500
About 1-1/2 years ago, Greg moved the forum to a completely new system, with very different procedures for moderating and for Mentors to deal with problem threads and problem members.
That's right, and since then PF has become a kindlier, friendlier forum. Before that, logging into PF was a lot like running into a Mongol horde out on lower reaches of the Volga...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Evo

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
2018 Award
20,468
4,163
That's right, and since then PF has become a kindlier, friendlier forum. Before that, logging into PF was a lot like running into a Mongol horde out on lower reaches of the Volga...
Well, I don't remember it being that bad.... I think it was more like running into a horde of small Mongols, all of which want new protractors.
 
Last edited:

fresh_42

Mentor
Insights Author
2018 Award
10,347
7,048
Those things happen from time to time. One of my posts has been deleted for being "off topic". The very next day I found another post with many lines plus an answer which exactly had the same topic. Only that it has been from someone with more credits. Strange? Yes. Bad? No.
 

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
2018 Award
20,468
4,163
One of my posts has been deleted for being "off topic". The very next day I found another post with many lines plus an answer which exactly had the same topic. Only that it has been from someone with more credits.
If that happens then please notify the mentors.
 

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top