Any takers approximating evaporation rate?

In summary, the conversation is discussing the evaporation rate of water from a mixing container under a vacuum and with air flow. The rate is affected by factors such as surface area, temperature, air composition, and the concentration and nature of solids in the slurry. Approximations can be made based on vapor pressure and diffusion limitations, but the actual rate will vary depending on the specifics of the slurry. Experimentation is recommended for a more accurate estimation.
  • #1
sdmparr
2
0
Any takers approximating evaporation rate?!

I am trying to estimate the rate of water loss from a 13'L x 6'W x 6'D mixing container at room temperature under a 12 inches of mercury vacuum. There is constant mixing of the fluid (dirty water). There is 180 cfm air movement through the top of the container across the surface of the mixing solution. The mixture is about 50% water. The container is 4.5' full. I am concentrating sludge.

Any insight is appreciated,

Steven
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
A diagram of the set-up will be required. I don't see how you can maintain a 12" (or about 300 torr) vacuum and have 180 cfms of air flow.

Let me ask you to not be very hopeful on this one. The binding energy of water to the solid component of the slurry is a strong function of the solid material itself (and is not usually small compared to the latent heat). Without a knowledge of the solids in the slurry, this will be impossible. Even with a knowledge of the solids, an ab initio calculation is out of the question. If all the physical, chemical and geometric conditions are specified, an order of magnitude estimate may be doable...

But realistically speaking, I would be extremely skeptical about any calculation done here. In fact, I doubt that any numbers available for sludge dewatering are generated computationally.

Wouldn't it be much easier to determine the evaporation rate experimentally ?
 
  • #3
Approximation? Things to consider: evaporation rate is going to be a function of surface area, temperature, and composition of the air you're passing over the tank, and to a lesser extent, the dissolved solids content of the water in the slurry, and to a yet lesser extent, the nature of the suspended solids.

Vapor pressure of water at "room temp" is 15 - 20 mm Hg, 2 -2.5 kPa. Evaporation rate of pure water into a perfectly dry gas stream is going to be 10-13 g/m2s (from a Langmuir argument). This will be reduced by the mole fraction of material in solution as a first approximation. It will be further reduced by the water content of the air being passed over the surface being dried. It is further reduced by the area of the surface obscured by dry "scum" forming (stirring keeps this effect small).

Eight square meters at room T? You can get 100 g/s maximum. How well the air is dried, and the amount of crap dissolved in the water are going to cut that down.
 
  • #4
part of answer maybe in 'psychrometry'

If I remember well, the measurement of moisture in a flow of moist air is called psychrometry.
I also remember that the mixture air/water vapor is somewhat particular in the sense that the "Lewis" number is nearly 1. (not completely sure about "Lewis")
I think this "Lewis" number compares heat flow and the energy cost of mass flow (evaporation).
The trick should be now to use the known scaling laws for heat flow and get from that the mass flow.

Still, I am not sure about the impact of the sludge concentration. However I guess that as long as the moisture content is high, the evaporation rate is not influenced. It begin to decreased when the available water is somewhat 'bond' to the solids. Then, this can only be determined experimentally, as a correcino factor. Indeed, it is clear that some solids are hydrophiles and others hydrophobes. It is also clear that water can participate is not kind of gel. Therefore, the detailled chemistry could enter on stage then.
 
  • #5
Bystander said:
Approximation? Things to consider: evaporation rate is going to be a function of surface area, temperature, and composition of the air you're passing over the tank, and to a lesser extent, the dissolved solids content of the water in the slurry, and to a yet lesser extent, the nature of the suspended solids.

Vapor pressure of water at "room temp" is 15 - 20 mm Hg, 2 -2.5 kPa. Evaporation rate of pure water into a perfectly dry gas stream is going to be 10-13 g/m2s (from a Langmuir argument). This will be reduced by the mole fraction of material in solution as a first approximation. It will be further reduced by the water content of the air being passed over the surface being dried. It is further reduced by the area of the surface obscured by dry "scum" forming (stirring keeps this effect small).

Eight square meters at room T? You can get 100 g/s maximum. How well the air is dried, and the amount of crap dissolved in the water are going to cut that down.
This approximation is likely a good one at low concentrations, but the OP's sludge is more than 50% solid and getting more concentrated as drying happens. This is not a solution or suspension anymore, and the rate of diffusion of water through the solids may not be large enough to assume that water at the surface is "instantaneously" replenished. This process will be diffusion limited beyond some "concentration".
 
  • #6
Until the OP is expanded with a more detailed composition of "the sludge," there is not a whole lot to be said --- absolute statements about "50% solids" are particularly dangerous --- try it with concrete sometime.
 
  • #7
MOre information on this problem

I really appreciate the replies! I agree the it would be much easier to experimentally evaluate the rate and that is probably what I am going to do ultimately but I am trying to keep down the cost of unfruitful equipment.

I guess to simplify the question and get me into the ballpark it would be easier to assume a container full of pure water 2 meters deep having a surface area of 8 square meters. Use the vacuum above and the 180 cfm airflow and assume 50% humidity of the air before the pressure is reduced.

I understand that solute will raise the boiling point and make a big difference from the above assuptions as would any oils in the solution etc. I am trying to get into the ballpark. I am only trying to thicken this waste enough to make it landfill compatable. I also have a low enough volume of material that if it takes a week to decrease the moisture content to a satisfactory level it will be ok.

I can also get a different machine that has comparable airflow and can pull up to 24 inches of mercury vacuum but it will cost more and may not be necessary for this application.

I believe that the kind of processes are used in the food processing industry for concentrating tomato juice to ketchup etc.

Thank you everyone for your time and help.

Steven
 
  • #8


can anyone help me how to calculate the evaporation rate of water at 95 degree celsius (kg/hr.m2 )
 

What is evaporation rate and why is it important?

Evaporation rate refers to the rate at which a liquid changes into a gas. It is an important factor in understanding the water cycle and the movement of water through various systems, such as soil and plants. It is also important in industries where accurate measurement of evaporation rate is necessary, such as in the production of food, pharmaceuticals, and chemicals.

How is evaporation rate measured?

Evaporation rate can be measured using a variety of methods, including gravimetric measurement, which involves weighing a sample of liquid over time as it evaporates, and instrumental methods such as the use of a hydrometer or a humidity sensor. The method used will depend on the specific requirements and conditions of the experiment or process.

What factors affect the evaporation rate?

The evaporation rate can be affected by several factors, including temperature, humidity, air flow, surface area, and the type of liquid being evaporated. Higher temperatures and lower humidity levels generally lead to a higher evaporation rate, while factors such as air flow and surface area can affect the rate in more complex ways.

Can the evaporation rate be controlled?

Yes, the evaporation rate can be controlled to some extent by manipulating the factors that affect it. For example, in industrial processes, evaporative cooling systems can be used to control the temperature and humidity levels, thereby controlling the evaporation rate. In agricultural settings, techniques such as mulching can be used to reduce the surface area of soil and control the evaporation rate.

How does evaporation rate impact the environment?

The evaporation rate plays a crucial role in the water cycle and the overall balance of water in the environment. Changes in evaporation rate can affect weather patterns, water availability, and the health of ecosystems. In addition, the evaporation rate of certain chemicals can contribute to air pollution and other environmental issues. Therefore, understanding and monitoring evaporation rate is important for maintaining a healthy environment.

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
911
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
23
Views
3K
  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
8
Views
51K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Differential Equations
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top