Are Neutrinos the Missing Graviton Particles? Exploring the Possibility

  • Thread starter meemoe_uk
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the possibility of neutrinos being the missing graviton particles and the reasons why this is unlikely. The participants mention the difference in spin between neutrinos and gravitons, as well as the difficulty in directly detecting gravitons. They also mention the current theory of cold-body neutrino production and the potential for indirect evidence of gravitons in the future.
  • #1
125
0
a logical shot...

Hey, here's a chance to shoot me down by giving me an endless list of reasons why this is the dummest idea of all time!

Could netrinos actually be the missing graviton particles?
In my nieve mind they qualify in most respects..
1. hardly interact with matter at all.
2. Vast quantitys of sun's netrinos are spose to flow through the Earth and throughout the rest of the solar system.

Only drawback is that current theory reckons non nuclear-active bodys don`t produce enough of them.

So how loose is current theory on cold-body netrino production? 100% certain no way?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2


Originally posted by meemoe_uk
Could netrinos actually be the missing graviton particles?

Eh? No. Neutrinos are spin 1/2 particles; gravitons are spin 2, by definition.

What do you mean, "missing" gravitons, anyway? Did you mean dark matter, instead of gravitons?
 
  • #3
why are gravitons by definition spin 2??

(don't bother to answer if you can't do it
in a few lines, I'm just curious...)

thanks.
cucumber.
 
  • #4
Originally posted by cucumber
why are gravitons by definition spin 2??

Because gravitons come from the quantization of general relativity, and in GR the gravitational field is given by a rank-2 tensor (the metric). A rank-2 tensor corresponds to a spin-2 particle.

It's possible to construct theories with particles other than spin 2, but they don't behave like general relativity does in the classical limit.
 
  • #5
What do you mean, "missing" gravitons, anyway?
as far as I know, no-one has been able to detect them. Give us a link that prooves beyond reasonble doubt otherwise ( not just some optimistic speculation on some new result ).
 
  • #6
Originally posted by meemoe_uk
as far as I know, no-one has been able to detect them.

Of course no one has ever detected them. It is certain that nobody ever will. Theory predicts this: it's extremely difficult to directly detect a gravitational wave, which would be made up of an astronomical number of gravitons, because gravitational waves are so weak. In light of that, directly detecting a single graviton is out of the question. However, it may be within the reach of future experiment to have some indirect evidence of them (much as we have indirect evidence of gravitational waves today), e.g. by photon dispersion experiments or something. It depends on what theory of quantum gravity is true.
 

1. What are neutrinos?

Neutrinos are tiny, subatomic particles that have almost no mass and no electric charge. They are constantly moving at near-light speeds and are produced by nuclear reactions, radioactive decay, and other high-energy processes.

2. What is a graviton particle?

A graviton particle is a hypothetical particle that is thought to be the carrier of the gravitational force. It is predicted by some theories of quantum gravity, but has not yet been observed or confirmed by experiments.

3. Why are neutrinos thought to be the missing graviton particles?

Neutrinos are thought to be the missing graviton particles because they have properties that make them good candidates for carrying the gravitational force. They have no charge, very little mass, and can travel long distances without interacting with other particles, which are all characteristics of a graviton particle.

4. How are scientists exploring the possibility of neutrinos being the missing graviton particles?

Scientists are using various experiments, such as the IceCube Neutrino Observatory, to study neutrinos and their interactions. They are also using theoretical models and mathematical calculations to test the hypothesis that neutrinos could be the missing graviton particles.

5. What are the implications if neutrinos are confirmed to be the missing graviton particles?

If neutrinos are confirmed to be the missing graviton particles, it would provide significant evidence for theories of quantum gravity and help us better understand the fundamental forces of the universe. It could also lead to new technologies and advancements in our understanding of the universe.

Suggested for: Are Neutrinos the Missing Graviton Particles? Exploring the Possibility

Replies
38
Views
2K
Replies
20
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
456
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
64
Views
3K
Replies
24
Views
2K
Back
Top